Papa Gelateria
$ • Ice Cream, Coffee ShopsAbout Papa Gelateria
Customers' Favorites
Gelato Bowl
Papa Gelateria Reviews
75 ratings
Share your opinion about Papa Gelateria
Ammmmmazing place to enjoy a nice quiet evening with some of the best in town!! Come try it out you will not be disappointed.
I had my first Gelato on Friday, my great nephew who is 8yrs old showed me where you are located and he bought me a strawberry Gelato and it was delicious better than any ice cream I ever had! I will be back and I am sure some of my family will also show up there because I raved about it. Thanks for a yummy experience
Great little place we ran into sort of on accident. We mostly loved our discussion with Tova. We will most likely be late for our appointment we were headed to, but it was so nice to chat with her regardless of whether or not we make it on time. Thanks for the friendly atmosphere!
Hours
| Monday | 12 - 9PM |
| Tuesday | 12 - 9PM |
| Wednesday | 12 - 9PM |
| Thursday | 12 - 9PM |
| Friday | 12 - 9PM |
| Saturday | 12 - 9PM |
| Sunday | 12 - 9PM |
Papa Gelateria is a charming café with a lovely atmosphere, nestled among tall oak trees. Customers enjoy a variety of gelato flavors like pistachio, chocolate, mango, blood orange, and black cherry. Although some find the strawberry cheesecake lacking in flavor, the gelato is generally described as amazing and creamy. The affogatos, particularly with sea salt honey gelato, and the Afrigatto, which is espresso over gelato, are highly recommended. The staff is friendly and often provides samples before customers choose their flavors. The outdoor deck is delightful, offering a peaceful view of New Castle, while some suggest improving the indoor smell by opening doors and enhancing cleanliness. Sometimes the café is busy, and other times it is a quiet treat-stop. Overall, it is a great spot for a sweet treat in a cozy setting, making it a place customers want to visit every day.