9 Best Pizza Restaurants near New Florence

“I love all of there food specially the chicken melt yumm!“

“The Food is always good and it feels like family there. C&T gets to know there customers and we get to know them that they feel like another family member. All restaurants should feel like that. I worked in this town for 10 years and I know the owners by first and last name even there employees and there family members. When the one owner was still alive he would come over to our business and tell us the Joke of the day and bring over cinnamon buns when they use to sell them. They also are part of the community and donate pizzas for the kids when there is something going on in the community.“

“We just had the eggplant Parm and chicken Parm and it was oh so delicious! Five stars for the food and our delivery man who reminded me so much of my late father. Thank you for a great dinner!!!“

“My wife and I love Bolivar Pizza! We live in the Portage Lakes area, so if we are anywhere close to Bolivar we are making the call. Have been coming here for several years and have never been disappointed.“

“This is the best pizza I have eaten in Johnstown. Nice and gooey. Topping proportions are good. Flavor is excellent. The Margherita Pizza tastes like something I ate in Rome.“

“Ordered 2 Stromboli 's My Stromboli I wanted everything it came with except no ham & wanted double pepperoni. For some reason they put ham on my order. It was good, except the ham tasted old. WHEN I WENT TO EAT IT I HAD TO REHEAT IT CUZ IT WAS A LITTLE WARM JUST WARM I HAD NO PROBLEM WITH THAT BUT ALL THE INGREDIENTS WAS IN THE MIDDLE THERE WAS NONE ON THE ENDS IT WAS REALLY DOUGHY. NOT ENOUGH PEPPERONI.. I HATE TO COMPLAIN I JUST I'M NOT ONE TO COMPLAIN FOR SANTA'S PIZZA AND STROMBOLIS BUT IT WAS JUST TOO DOUGHY FOR ME I DID EAT IT I CAN'T UPLOAD ANY PICTURES BECAUSE I DID EAT IT BUT I THOUGHT IT WOULD GET BETTER BUT LIKE I SAID AT THE END IT WAS ALL THOUGH THERE WAS NO PEPPERONI NOTHING EVERYTHING WAS IN THE MIDDLE ON THE WHOLE THING THAT'S WHY I GAVE IT ONLY THREE STARS“

“We stopped in today Feb 2 2025 with the family. Most excellent food and service. Pizza was awesome as well as steak and cheese and their Stromboli one the best I ever had. Grandson had Mac and cheese and chicken strips he is 4 and ate every last morsel of that Mac and cheese. Will def make this a weekly stop!“

“I love you guys food❤️Stromboli is out of this world“

“Jan is an amazing waitress she was so kind and made you feel like you were eating around the family dinner table. I spilled my drink and she came over right away and started cleaning and made me feel better by making me laugh. Jan deserves to be recognized for her service and the way she tends to her customers.

Kid-friendliness: Jan is definitely a wonderful waitress and would treat kids great“