50 Best Pizza Restaurants near New Kingstown

“My dad used to grab these subs for dinner many years ago when he worked in Carlisle, and now that I work right up the street in Mechanicsburg, they're definitely still a favorite lunch go-to! The staff are always friendly, and I've never been disappointed by a thing they've made yet.“

“Very good pizza. Tastes very fresh and juicy. Great atmosphere. People who work there are very kind. BIG portions. Thanks again for great food.“

“Awesome pizza and craft brews, visit when we are in the area. Had a few laughs with the owners wife tonight wearing her Janis Joplin tee, good sport and great service! Classic Rock playing on the 1975 vintage Fisher receiver sets the mood, love the window seat.“

“4/27/2025 Earl Bancroft, blue cooler, I had 3 meals the last three evenings while attending spring Carlisle. Each meal was very good and an outstanding value. These folks prep and cook with fresh ingredients as if they are feeding family! The fact that they allow carry in beer/wine didn’t hurt either. Don’t miss out, give this place a try!!“

“Great pizza, Owner and staff very friendly and always express their appreciation for your business.“

“Great pizza, friendly atmosphere. We give 5 Stars!“

“Tuna sub with cheese is the best!“

“Us Railroaders love it here!“

“Came down for the Carlisle car show and ordered out. It was excellent food, fast delivery and very friendly! Going back tonight for more!!“

“Okay, we might have a problem… we’ve been coming to Marcello's for a few years and always eat in the dining room and order their delicious Italian food, but we’d never tried their pizza. Last week we had their pizza for the first time and we are now having it for the third time in a week. It’s a problem! This white pizza… 🤌🏼🤌🏼🤌🏼 They gave us these funnel fries and we’re weak in the knees. Cant recommend this place enough. My favorite part is that every time we come in we feel like family. Our new fav! 🍕“

“Best pizza in town“

“Gave a 24 hr notice for 25 people. We arrived and the seating was reserved and marked easily to find. Service was quick. Food orders were prepared as per request. Food was delicious. Would highly recommend visiting here for a delicious lunch or dinner. Family friendly. Off street parking. Plenty of seating! Accommodations for couples and large groups as well as a banquet area. 5*****“

“Gave a 24 hr notice for 25 people. We arrived and the seating was reserved and marked easily to find. Service was quick. Food orders were prepared as per request. Food was delicious. Would highly recommend visiting here for a delicious lunch or dinner. Family friendly. Off street parking. Plenty of seating! Accommodations for couples and large groups as well as a banquet area. 5*****“

“The Barrett family is sending a huge thank you to the Pizza Shop for showing their community support in providing a donation for sponsorship to support William in going to Fargo ND to compete in the National Championship for freestyle and greco wrestling!! Thank you for your support!“

“Great food, and fast, friendly service!“

“Pizza was delicious and their subs are huge and filling. Best cannoli I’ve ever had!“

“Ordered on one of the busiest nights of the week. HALLOWEEN! Food still came out hot a fresh. Worth the wait! I hope you all get to enjoy a nice cold beverage after work.“

“Yummy pizza & super fresh salad! Kind, friendly & attentive staff! Most pizza shops in my area are closed on Monday so I took a chance on a new spot & we will be back!😃 My little guy loves the chips! Thank you!“

“the Italian subs you make are the best in Cumberland county! Thank you for having delivery service.“

“Normally a great experience at Home Slice with great food. Point of criticism to work on is having your staff better communicate wait times. Arrived at the time I was told it would be ready. Was then told 10 more minutes, fine. Food wasn’t ready for an additional 45 min. Clearly wasn’t in the process of being made when told 10 more minutes (a pizza and 2 subs doesn’t take that long to make)“

“Hands down my favorite grocery store. I’m so glad I have one so close! I can’t imagine doing my shopping anywhere else!“

“I ordered a couple of pizzas today via DoorDash to feed my team. The quality of the pizzas and the flavor was top notch. My only issue was the “large” pizza is tiny. Which normally I would be ok but trying to feed a group at work with those tiny pizzas was a bit rough.“

“We were asking family members who had the best subs in Carlisle. They said Brad's! We had their cheeseburger subs the other night and I came back to comment on how good they were. Nice burgers, not frozen patties. Very good rolls, fresh ingredients and just a great sub!“

“Amazing food! Definitely tastes homemade. Fried zucchini and fried mushrooms were a hit. Not greasy at all! Shrimp and fries were delicious as well. Chicken wings (hot sauce) was a vinegar based sauce, so good. Italian sub was good as well, very fresh tasting. Overall, 8/10. Service was excellent and the only critique I have is an updated dining room:)“

“Lol, when Adelyn says she wants to make a trip to Giant. She is actually saying I want pizza from Tonino’s. Yesterday we tried pizza di Tonino. I’m thinking this is a new favorite. Always well worth the travel and time.“

“Pizza was great and our waitress was very pleasant“

“Good waitress and good food“

“Huge thank you to Santuccis for hosting a fundraiser for our basketball team! Great food, great people! We really appreciate your support! East Pennsboro High School Girls Basketball“

“Great atmosphere, delicious food, and the staff was amazing.“

“Tried it for the first time today. Had the grandmas pie and garlic knots… both absolutely amazing! Will definitely be back!“

“Went here with a friend we got a xl pizza which is 18" and two fountain drinks it was $33 and the pizza was out in 12 minutes, and it was perfect the cheese was gooey, the crust was crispy and the service was amazing the employees are respectful. Go to new york for the views, go here for the best pizza I've ever had and I've been to NY and DC it is better than both of them it is simply beautiful. (Bonus they have cherry Pepsi)“

“One of the best pizzas I’ve had in a long time, great price also. Can’t wait to stop by again.“

“Love peppinos! The food is amazing, the people are always nice and friendly, they have good space inside!!! The lunch specials are amazing!!!

Kid-friendliness: Kid friendly and everything made to order!!

Wheelchair accessibility: Can access with wheelchair! No stairs!!“

“Great pizza, wings, huge subs, wife loves the huge taco salad. so much better than Al's! Great friendly people!“

“I’m from NY, where good pizza (of all styles) can be found easily. This pizza is delicious and the best I’ve had in PA so far. Thin crust, light sauce, with an airy crust. We had pepperoni with mushrooms and sausage. Although the mushrooms were canned, they still had a good flavor. pepperoni and sausage were tasty.We also had the garlic knots which were delicious. They have just a small amount of garlic seasoning, which I liked. My boyfriend said they needed more garlic, so it depends on your preference. 12 decent sized knots in an order with plenty of sauce! Generous portions for the price.Only problem is, I can't find a menu anywhere to see what else there is to try here. We asked at the restaurant but they didn't have any. My boyfriend ended up just taking a picture of the menu wall. Other than that, it was excellent and I will be coming back anytime I want pizza.“

“Honestly it’s one of the best pizza shops around. The pizza is delicious, not greasy, perfect amount of cheese and sauce all laid on great quality dough. If you have a night where you just don’t feel like cooking, I’d order from Palumbo 👌🏼“

“I would absolutely recommend George's! This restaurant was founded on the American Dream! 66 years is a long time y'all! This is such a treasure in Carlisle! Besides that...The staff is amazing, down to earth and friendly (which is very important to me), the dining area/ restrooms were clean, you can't go wrong with anything on the menu and I especially love all their new options for catering! And how sweet is it to look at all those old vintage pictures, and say "hey you see that picture of the kid with the eye patch and busted up teeth, and looks like they belong on a sad commercial raising money... that was me!" haha. It's nice that they have tables instead of just the booths to accommodate more people with parties. And the soda self refill option is nice so you don't need to wait in line anymore to fill up your cup. Their 3 foot Sub is excellent for any event and is a crowd pleaser and a great price too! My absolute favorites would have to be the burger sub on homemade roll, white pizza, onion petals, fries, and milkshake.. okay like everything is good there haha.“

“Ordered from here for the first time and was really impressed. Everything was delicious and unique! Can’t wait to order again!“

“Our group tried to make reservations for March 16, 2024. This business was called and a female answered and stated the Manager would call back, he never did. She called back and the male manager answered and stated that he called her back two days prior. She only called the day before. Then he said he called he back the day she called and she told him that he did not. So a lieing manager. We we had 15 people interested in coming to your establishment, I would think it would have been a couple hundred dollars, but you refused us. YOUR LOSS. Hopefully anyone from our group will never patronize your business. It would have been my first time since we are driving to meet the others that are from Duncansville/Altoona area. I would give you a ZERO review. The business down the street was more than happy to accommodate us with open arms. YOUR LOSS!“

“you get great family like service from the owners to the staff. the food is excellent from the fresh bread on the cheeseburger sub to the steaks. the home made soups are to die for. when i get off work as a cook i am not usually hungry but when i decide to eat there my stomach is rumbling knowing how great the food is.“

“My first time ordered a pizza from here, and had great experience. Will sure come back for more.
** Pizza: its great considering what you paid for. Its crusty, and the toppings really filled up the pizza (refer to photo). My boy loves it.
** Service: Really polite and helpful. It's my first to-go order, they kept my pizza in a warmer that I can pick it up with code. I didn't know how to use it, the manager stopped what he was doing, took my name, got my pizza, and explained the code reader as well.“

“I absolutely love Bacco! The people are amazing and the wine and food is wonderful. The atmosphere is welcoming and friendly and I love the staff. I recommend if you haven't been there that you check it out...you won't be sorry. I would give them a 5! 💕“

“Haven't been to Pizza Hut in years. I was expecting some sub par service and pizza that was different from how I remembered it. But I was pleasantly surprised! Pizza tasted like it always has (which is great) and the service was very good. Did not dine in, so I can't speak to the interior of the restaurant.“

“I want to take this time out to give u all a high ? . All stars, U all r amazing ppl thanks again for letting me take pictures of my granddaughters in your lounge for homecoming 2024 mechanicsburg pa. The pictures turned out amazing. U all made their memories and mine to. U r a blessing keep up the awesome work ?“

“Food has always been outstanding!“

“First time eating here, on our way home from Myrtle Beach, and I will eat here again when I’m in the area. The food, prices and fast service was beyond exceptional!! I may even drive there just to eat their delicious food!! We even got hoagies to go!! The salad was delicious and the portions were generous! They’re located just off the route 15 corridor in Mechanicsburg.“

“Pizzas were good, my contractors were happy. Would have been 5/5 stars but the guys charged me for cheap Styrofoam cups when I bought two 2 liters. Like really? I just ordered five pizzas and 2 sodas and my bill is already over $105 and I even tipped well after that for a take out and you’re really gonna charge me a second time for almost $4 it was $3.98 to be exact for Styrofoam cups.. like I requested 15 Styrofoam cups for the sodas not a big deal.. that was a joke. Made you look cheap and soured me to this spot.“

“Came down for the Carlisle car show and ordered out. It was excellent food, fast delivery and very friendly! Going back tonight for more!!“

“I visited this pizza bolis because the Mechanicsburg location reportedly experienced a fire and closed down. Their pizza was satisfactory, although a bit oily. They do have a restroom, but it's accessed through the kitchen; I'm unsure about their policy on restroom access for customers.“