50 Best Pizza Restaurants near New Kingstown

“My dad used to grab these subs for dinner many years ago when he worked in Carlisle, and now that I work right up the street in Mechanicsburg, they're definitely still a favorite lunch go-to! The staff are always friendly, and I've never been disappointed by a thing they've made yet.“

“Great pizza, friendly atmosphere. We give 5 Stars!“

“Best food i’ve ever had😘😘would never choose anywhere else for pizza!!might order this for my wedding when i’m older!“

“I love EVERYTHING at @Napoli Pizza. I just had a Cold Sub (turkey/bacon/provolone) for early dinner and it was exquisite! It was just perfectly made and every element was cool & fresh - down to the danged mayo. 🤌🏾 UNBELIEVABLE. 🙌🏾“

“pizza lacked flavor and wasn't cut properly. toppings were put on slopy and unevenly distributed. rather spend the extra couple bucks and go to sals.“

“Accidentally ended up here today. Went to go to another place downtown. It now appears so many places are closed on Sunday. Sorry other downtown establishments didn’t get our business. We found our new favorite pizza. Beer was good too. Highly recommend.“

“I had such a wonderful, unexpected experience at this pizza place! By chance, I met the owners and they invited me and my husband to try their pizza, and it is now definitely my favorite pizza I’ve ever had! The pizza was fresh, flavorful, and every bite showed the care they put into it. The prices were comparable to corporate owned chains but the quality was astronomically better than any other place I’ve been to. Having moved here from the West Coast I have been enjoying the opportunity to try new restaurants especially cuisine not as easy to come by back in our hometown. The owner spun the dough right in front of us, and it was clear how proud he is of his restaurant. He welcomed every customer with genuine warmth, making the atmosphere truly enjoyable. It felt like an authentic Italian experience, full of heart and passion. I can’t wait to go back and I am happy to know they even offer delivery! Looking forward to trying other items on their menu as well!“

“Tuna sub with cheese is the best!“

“Congratulations on your “Best of 2025” best of business award!“

“Gave a 24 hr notice for 25 people. We arrived and the seating was reserved and marked easily to find. Service was quick. Food orders were prepared as per request. Food was delicious. Would highly recommend visiting here for a delicious lunch or dinner. Family friendly. Off street parking. Plenty of seating! Accommodations for couples and large groups as well as a banquet area. 5*****“

“clean ,10 to 13 for subs.Subs where very taste 2.50 for slice of pizza .Good service .Will go again.“

“We were there for dinner last night for Mother’s Day and, as always, the food was absolutely amazing! The restaurant was extremely crowded, and those waitresses were HUSTLING all night long trying to keep up with the rush. Honestly, I was shocked to see some people get up and leave before their food came because let me tell you — this place is 100% worth the wait. We stayed until closing and even went back into the kitchen just to personally thank everyone. They told us it was the busiest they’ve ever been, and despite that, they still delivered a phenomenal dining experience. A huge thank you to the entire staff for another incredible Mother’s Day dinner. If you love Italian food, you absolutely must check this place out. ❤️🍝“

“We had a party of about 20 people. Navarro's staff was friendly and attentive. The waitress suggested delicious dinners. Our family and friends enjoyed Pastas, Subs, Pizzas and Strombolis. Everything was fresh and delicious. We can't thank them enough for squeezing our party in with less than a week notice.“

“Best pizza and sandwiches around! Clean, great service, great food and reasonable prices“

“some of the best NY style pizza in the area :) but they are the most expensive as well :(“

“Great food Only pizza/sub place we order from Thanks for being the best!!“

“The Barrett family is sending a huge thank you to the Pizza Shop for showing their community support in providing a donation for sponsorship to support William in going to Fargo ND to compete in the National Championship for freestyle and greco wrestling!! Thank you for your support!“

“Feels good to walk into this place!! owner is friendly and respectful. And the food is AMAZING!!! 🤩 5 stars all day!! ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“I ordered a couple of pizzas today via DoorDash to feed my team. The quality of the pizzas and the flavor was top notch. My only issue was the “large” pizza is tiny. Which normally I would be ok but trying to feed a group at work with those tiny pizzas was a bit rough.“

“This is a good neighbor spot. The regular pizza is a very basic NYC that could be a little bland, but definitely not bad. The white pizza is very good, but the grandma is the star of the show. The grandma is the most flavorful pizza I have tried from here and all the ingredients go great together. Sauce and crust are better than on the regular. It is more pricey but worth the upgrade!“

“Fast Service, Excellent Food, Friendly Staff. A must visit Pizzeria.“

“Pizza was so delicious and fresh, Jose Sal took care of a party of 10+ people in one go, all by himself!!!! definitely underated and became my favorite pizza joint!!!“

“Best pizza in town“

“very good food and reason prices“

“Today while shopping at Wegmans in Chestnut Hill, I had the unfortunate experience of feeling faint. I immediately took my mask off, but that did not help. In fact, as I tried to make my way to the cashier, I found myself feeling more light headed, unable to see well and very dizzy. I just said out loud, I need a doctor. A wonderful woman heard me and yelled for a doctor and the answer came. An anesthesiologist who happened to be in the check out area responded and took me with the support of store personnel to sit down. While there, he made sure I was ok and got me some water and checked my pulse etc. The next thing I recall is the manager Brian showed up. Eventually, Brian took over and stayed with me as I recovered. He made what seemed like a terrifying experience more manageable. He got me a second glass of water and when I was ready, he walked me to my car and made sure my groceries that he checked out for me were with me. I called him when I arrived home and let him know I was safe. A big thank you to all who supported me today simply does not seem like enough but I am so grateful to everyone who was there. Your kind, compassionate shoppers and staff are remarkable. Thank you!“

“Food has always been outstanding!“

“I've been going to Nonna Ilva since they were on Hanover Street and I'm so glad they have a sit-down restaurant now. The food is always delicious and you can tell it is made with high quality ingredients. Everyone that works there is always super friendly and even when it's busy orders tend to come out quickly. They also don't rush you out the second you're done making it a great place to meet up with friends and catch up. Overall, Nonna Ilva is easily one of the best restaurants in Carlisle. I can't recommend it enough!“

“I ordered a couple of pizzas today via DoorDash to feed my team. The quality of the pizzas and the flavor was top notch. My only issue was the “large” pizza is tiny. Which normally I would be ok but trying to feed a group at work with those tiny pizzas was a bit rough.“

“I absolutely love Bacco! The people are amazing and the wine and food is wonderful. The atmosphere is welcoming and friendly and I love the staff. I recommend if you haven't been there that you check it out...you won't be sorry. I would give them a 5! 💕“

“Picked up a call in order for lunch. Nice atmosphere. Clean looking restaurant. Friendly service. Pizza was freshly made and just came out of the oven. I didn't get to spend a whole lot of time there but I liked what I saw and plan on returning to check out some of the other items available Al's.“

“the Italian subs you make are the best in Cumberland county! Thank you for having delivery service.“

“90% of the time, the food is great! But on April 16th, 2023, I got a delivery. The Fettuccine Alfredo was great, but the salad was AWFUL! I ordered a Grilled Chocken Salad and it DID NOT have any grilled chicken on it, it had NO croutons, & it had NO cheese on it! It was bland and awful!“

“We have found our new favorite local pizza joint! We have placed orders the last 3 weekends (lol I know, I know). They have amazing pizza (they use those cupping pepperoni!), the stromboli was also great! This place has homey, mom and pop, old school pizza shop vibes! Definitely give their pepperoni pizza and bacon cheese fries a try! We haven't had anything bad from them and look forward to trying more menu items 😊“

“Great pizza, wings, huge subs, wife loves the huge taco salad. so much better than Al's! Great friendly people!“

“Excellent pizza, great subs, friendly service. Our favorite pizza shop.“

“Always delicious pizza, and we have used them several times for larger youth group events when we need a lot of pizzas. Hot and ready at the time we ask! Highly recommend.“

“Gave a 24 hr notice for 25 people. We arrived and the seating was reserved and marked easily to find. Service was quick. Food orders were prepared as per request. Food was delicious. Would highly recommend visiting here for a delicious lunch or dinner. Family friendly. Off street parking. Plenty of seating! Accommodations for couples and large groups as well as a banquet area. 5*****“

“Our group tried to make reservations for March 16, 2024. This business was called and a female answered and stated the Manager would call back, he never did. She called back and the male manager answered and stated that he called her back two days prior. She only called the day before. Then he said he called he back the day she called and she told him that he did not. So a lieing manager. We we had 15 people interested in coming to your establishment, I would think it would have been a couple hundred dollars, but you refused us. YOUR LOSS. Hopefully anyone from our group will never patronize your business. It would have been my first time since we are driving to meet the others that are from Duncansville/Altoona area. I would give you a ZERO review. The business down the street was more than happy to accommodate us with open arms. YOUR LOSS!“

“Pizza was great and our waitress was very pleasant“

“First time eating here, on our way home from Myrtle Beach, and I will eat here again when I’m in the area. The food, prices and fast service was beyond exceptional!! I may even drive there just to eat their delicious food!! We even got hoagies to go!! The salad was delicious and the portions were generous! They’re located just off the route 15 corridor in Mechanicsburg.“

“I had such a wonderful, unexpected experience at this pizza place! By chance, I met the owners and they invited me and my husband to try their pizza, and it is now definitely my favorite pizza I’ve ever had! The pizza was fresh, flavorful, and every bite showed the care they put into it. The prices were comparable to corporate owned chains but the quality was astronomically better than any other place I’ve been to. Having moved here from the West Coast I have been enjoying the opportunity to try new restaurants especially cuisine not as easy to come by back in our hometown. The owner spun the dough right in front of us, and it was clear how proud he is of his restaurant. He welcomed every customer with genuine warmth, making the atmosphere truly enjoyable. It felt like an authentic Italian experience, full of heart and passion. I can’t wait to go back and I am happy to know they even offer delivery! Looking forward to trying other items on their menu as well!“

“Honestly it’s one of the best pizza shops around. The pizza is delicious, not greasy, perfect amount of cheese and sauce all laid on great quality dough. If you have a night where you just don’t feel like cooking, I’d order from Palumbo 👌🏼“

“Italian Delight is truly one of our favorite local spots! We’ve tried almost everything on the menu over the years, and we are NEVER disappointed. The food is consistently fresh, delicious, and made with care—you really can’t go wrong with anything you order.

What makes Italian Delight even more special is that it’s a wonderful, family-owned business. The owners are incredibly kind, welcoming, and genuinely care about their customers and the community. You can tell they take pride in both their food and the experience they provide.

If you’re looking for a great local pizzeria with excellent food and even better people behind it, we highly recommend Italian Delight! ❤🍕“

“Best pizza in town by far!!“

“Lol, when Adelyn says she wants to make a trip to Giant. She is actually saying I want pizza from Tonino’s. Yesterday we tried pizza di Tonino. I’m thinking this is a new favorite. Always well worth the travel and time.“

“90% of the time, the food is great! But on April 16th, 2023, I got a delivery. The Fettuccine Alfredo was great, but the salad was AWFUL! I ordered a Grilled Chocken Salad and it DID NOT have any grilled chicken on it, it had NO croutons, & it had NO cheese on it! It was bland and awful!“

“We had an amazing experience at Massimo’s Italian Bakery! The food was absolutely incredible — fresh, authentic, and full of flavor — but what truly stood out was the owner’s kindness and knowledge. We have an obscure food sensitivity in our family, and the owner personally took the time to go over ingredients with us and help verify what was safe to eat. That level of care and attention is so rare and deeply appreciated. It made the experience completely stress-free, and we were able to fully enjoy some of the best Italian food we’ve had. We’ll definitely be back and highly recommend this bakery!“

“Best tuna salad sub I've had in a very long time. SUPERB fresh baked roll. Not hard crust! I don't eat much bread anymore but, that was mmmmmm good. Tony's chicken or veal Piccata is my favorite entree' there. Lobster raviolli is my 2nd place entree'. Go enjoy a great dinner at this well priced great service establishment.“

“Basically if Wegman’s doesn’t have it, it doesn’t exist.“