New American Restaurants near New Oxford, PA

“Carissa was our waitress and she was excellent! Our entrees and desserts were fantastic as well, but Carissa's great personality and professionalism made us decide that we will always ask to be seated in her section!“

“We ate at Pattin' before seeing a Broadway show. We were seated immediately at a quaint table for 2 overlooking the street. The wine, the food (brussel sprouts, branzino, halibut), and the dessert (creme brule) were all amazing and we'd order every single item again. The service was also spectacular! The atmosphere was romantic and we loved being able to sit and talk while we experienced dining at Pattin'.“

“Very good. Awesome atmosphere“

“In from out of state and just happened upon this fine little “dive bar”. The bartender was amazing, the food was ridiculously fantastic! If we’re ever back on this area, we will surely stop back!“

“Good food , good prices , good service😊“

“We stopped by for supper May 30 2025. Our waitress was Alyssa she was wonderful helping me with my food allergies very thoughtful you have a wonderful worker in her.I had the ham with baked potato and cottage cheese my husband had the 2 smoked pork chops with a baked potato and cucumber salad the meal was wonderfully cooked well and so delicious Thank you for a great experience eating at you restaurant.“

“Very outstanding,Delicious food. Service is beyond great! Chef Neil is there please. You will want to go back to Sidney's every chance you can.“

“The only real restaurant we found! Gettysburg has lots of restaurants, all geared to tourists and fast food and/or fried food. This was a real restaurant with table clothes, good and healthy options, bread with the meal, and our waitress (wish I could remember her name, a lovely woman! with short hair with highlighted tips). It is in a hotel, but doesn't feel like it at all. Made me feel good to have a non rushed sit down dinner with excellent food!“

“Graybill's is usually very good, as was our breakfast this morning.
But tonight we ordered spaghetti and meatballs.
It wasn't even from one of the many good jarred sauces on the market.
This sauce was thin, similar to a can of Del Grosso. Spaghetti was cooked perfectly.
Meat balls were fair. All summed up, I will not order this again“

“My family and I visited Avalon Ale House not long ago and I felt I needed to share. The friendly staff was very attentive to our table. The exceptional food selection was a plus! I would recommend this to someone who has not visited and we will definitely be back again! Keep up the good work!!“