Restaurants near Old Forge

“Excellent food, great service and always pleasant!”

“We ordered from here last week , had my sons Birthday and ordered 3 pies , Absolutely loved it , Pizza was very tasty , tho it looked light on top the crust was excellent crisp to it , 7 Italians in one room and it is rare that we all loved the same place , but we did , My main Pizza place to order from weekly now , . Thanks to whole staff and owner for making my sons Birthday a great dinner ❤️❤️❤️”

“Outstanding dinners for our party of 6. Service was excellent and atmosphere phenomenal. 5🌟 Restaurant”

“Our first time there waitress was very friendly and food was amazing definitely be back everything is homemade and that is nice to hear”

“first time here tonight based on my dates recommendation..very happy with our dinners and the service..I got the gnocchi with meat sauce and she got a chicken caesar salad I believe..both large portions . Will definitely be back”

“I'm from Staten Island N.Y., and I'm 56 years old. My wife and I moved to Old Forge Pennsylvania on Monday October 16th, 2023.
I've been a milk route truck driver, a Sanitation worker for NYC, and a Commercial Sanitation Route driver; I had many Straight Truck, Air Brakes, CDL Driving jobs ew my life including dump trucks. I KNOW NYC.
I had apartments in Brooklyn as well as Staten Island. I worked in every Borough including Yonkers, Westchester County, and many parts of New Jersey, where I also had quite a few apartments over the years.
My point?
Being Italian/American and submerged in the heritages culture, I'm VERY familiar with GENUINELY AUTHENTIC Italian Breads; and BOTH the right and wrong types of baking them.
Agostini's Bread?
PHENOMENAL!!!
I was shocked at the old fashioned authentic LOOK, TEXTURE, and TERRIFIC TASTE, of the Two different large loaves that I bought:
Sesame Seeded Twisted loaf; AND, a Dark Brown loaf of Russian Rye bread.
Both, EXCELLENT!
I met Rita in the store front and it was like stepping into Cammerieri's Bakery from the Movie ? "MoonStruck ."
Or Addeo's Bakery in the Bronx.
This 100 year old plus business was purchased by Rita and her husband 2 years ago. They are carrying on the tradition of superior Italian bread and more, and they are carrying the TORCH.
I dipped a piece of that Twisted loaf into Extra Virgin Olive oil that was sprinkled with Cracked Black pepper and Cracked Sea Salt, and was drizzled over Fresh Homemade Mozzarella topped with Garden Basil leaves and Juicy Grape Tomatoes. The Bread was DIVINE!
Dinner was served with a Barbecued Cheese and Parsley Sausage Ring from Staten Island N.Y., with Homemade Red and Yellow Roasted Bell Peppers, and Green Poblano Roasted Peppers marinating in Olive oil and garden parsley and slices of Raw Garlic cloves.
Along with a homemade Pesto my wife makes to perfection, Agostini Bread was a perfect accompaniment to our dinner table. Some home made Sangria and our table was furnished with all of the BEST!
Thank you, Agostini Bakery!
You have a new permanent patron; ME!
GOD BLESS YOU AND YOUR FAMILY, ✝?????✝”

“Great food, fast and friendly service. Never disappointed. Wings rock!”

“Had to give this place a 5 star, food was really good! I enjoyed my turkey club sandwich, so yummy and filling, the workers have such great energy, very friendly. The environment was super chill also. Definitely coming back here”

“No doubt about it, this place has the BEST pizza in the whole world. I've tried pizza from all over, but nothing beats the Old Forge style pizza made here. I'm in love every time.”

“I got 2 trays of red pizza with anchovies & the pizza was Absolutely Scrumptious. Pizza was phenomenal. Loved it! Everything was perfect even though I ordered out. Order was ready when I got there & just the smell, I couldn't wait to get home to have a piece. Sheer Perfection.”

“The Best Meat Ravioli I have ever tasted!”

“They took a group of 18 people last minute and everything was unbelievable! Food and service was top notch…it doesn’t look like much from the outside but their food, portion size, service was fantastic!!!”

“My favorite is the steamed dumplings can’t get enough! They are flavorful and loaded with meat, crab Rangoon are large full and crisp love them as well, heck have not had one thing yet I did not like. You have to try them!”

“When living in old forge I stopped here almost daily during the summer. no shame. they also have the friendliest staff”

“I like This Place been A Customer for 5 years nothing bad to say,, everyone have an attitude and personality, the lady is like that she hasnt been rude too me,, Food is Good”

“Hands down best Burger King in the area. Always nice taking order and busiest days down slow or mess them up. If I'm hungry for Burger King I'll drive here.”

“Ordered from las vegas. Everything was perfectly packaged and fresh. Great customer service. Quality was as we remembered it. It was great to have a taste of home. Will definitely order again”

“Love old forge Dunkin’. The workers are awesome however The people that come through the drive tru are awfully rude. In case people are confused you have to order at the drive thru speaker and then pull to the window. Even if you have a Mobile order pick up for the drive thru. Just stop at the speaker and let then employees know you have a pick up and say your name. It’s not hard.”

“Every time I bring my kids here for events they have a blast, management always go above and beyond to make sure we are enjoying ourselves and the kids are happy! They are always doing fun contests and give aways we take part in and we seeing our favorite manager Ariel, she always takes care of us !!! ❤️”

“Shayna was our server and she was amazing! Food was awesome, drinks were great, Best dinner ever!”

“Awesome place to eat! Amazing vibes, great service, great portions and so delicious! Definitely adding it to our regular rotation! I’m so glad we decided to eat here!”

“My third time here & it is consistently great! Came in for their Sunday Dinner, drinks where perfect, apps great, but let’s give the meatballs a moment…maybe the best the area has to offer…and there are some really good ones in town. Perfect size, perfectly soft, really excellent. Had the spaghetti it was spot on, just right. Finished the meal with lovely desserts and house made chocolates the whole meal made me happy :)”

“I had bought some cookies for a gift. I put the order in online and told to pick up at a certain time. First i showed up right on time thinking they would be good to go. This was the first time I tried them. They were not ready when I got there. I was in a rush so that turned me off immediately. The cookies look beautiful and are designed pretty nice. For me. I am more of a simple cookie person. You put chocolate chips in and I'm good. However if you like that sort of thing I would say go for it. Just be prepared to wait a few extra minutes if you order online. It wouldn't be fair of me to say that all the frosting and extras aren't for me because most people like that.”

“Absolutely delicious every single time. You can tell how proud they are of the food and restaurant, it's evident on their faces and in how they explain or offer suggestions. I'm a plain Jane: butter chicken, basmati rice garlic naan, mango lassi. Also tried samosas with fig sauce and cilantro sauce. So good!!”

“Extraordinary is an understatement. This establishment is phenomenal in every aspect, from its atmosphere to the family ownership, cuisine, and pricing. I highly recommend Anthony's with absolute certainty, and I appreciate supporting small, family-owned businesses.  #LoveMyFamilia”

“Mission BBQ catered our wedding, and we truly cannot recommend them highly enough! The food was absolutely amazing—delicious, fresh, and a total hit with all of our guests—but what really set them apart was their exceptional service. The team went above and beyond to make our day special. They prepared custom plates just for me and my husband, packaged up all the leftovers, and even left us a thoughtfully packed meal for the end of the night. Every detail was handled with such care and consideration, and it made the entire experience feel seamless and stress-free. Mission BBQ brought not only incredible food but also warmth, professionalism, and genuine hospitality. We’re so grateful for their role in our big day—it wouldn’t have been the same without them!”

“The best smoothie place ever!”

“We came for my Bachelorette party. Such a great experience to be sipping an iced latte while a cat is asleep in your lap! Highly recommend!”

“Food was good and fresh! People were friendly. If your looking for good food and a food truck vibe then this is the place to go. I just wish it was in a park or something.”