36 Best Ice Cream Shops near Old Forge

“The ice cream cakes are beautifully designed and delicious too! A wonderful treat for any event!“

“Awesome custard!! Highly recommend“

“Best ice cream, perfect spot to sit down and enjoy view.“

“I bought a plain cheesecake at the craft show at OAk st Sr Apts today. It was delicious and price was great too. I really liked this cheesecake because it wasn't as sweet as most you get. You didn't feel like you had a mouthful of sugar!! You won't be disappointed. I promise.“

“The ice cream was delicious, and my family and I love your new location. Every staff member was extremely friendly and attentive, taking their time with us despite the line on a busy weekend night. We are thrilled to see your business doing so well! I recommend this place to everyone!“

“great food in a few years im gonna work there“

“The best ice cream in town🍦“

“Great milk and ice cream, and the employees are the sweetest!“

“Always a treat to stop at Manning’s any time of year 😊“

“the best ice cream! the girls at the counter are extremely kind and very patient with our autistic daughter ♥️“

“I was at the store Sinday night around 7pm. I wanted to get a few things. One of the items I was looking for was a tomato or two. In the pile of tomatoes there were several thay were moldy and had small flies on them. Needless to say, I didn't get any tomatoes. When I checked out I told the cashier and another staff member about them. The other woman said, "I saw that when I went to get the extra bags. The morning people will take care of that issue." How many other people didn't buy them because of this? How long were they in the pile? Long enough for flies to be on them. Sorry, not sorry, if this is how you manage a issue like this, I'm not sure I will be back. The longer these sit in there, the more that will be inedible. Normally the store is up to par on things like this. I wish I had thought to take pictures.“

“I was at the store Sinday night around 7pm. I wanted to get a few things. One of the items I was looking for was a tomato or two. In the pile of tomatoes there were several thay were moldy and had small flies on them. Needless to say, I didn't get any tomatoes. When I checked out I told the cashier and another staff member about them. The other woman said, "I saw that when I went to get the extra bags. The morning people will take care of that issue." How many other people didn't buy them because of this? How long were they in the pile? Long enough for flies to be on them. Sorry, not sorry, if this is how you manage a issue like this, I'm not sure I will be back. The longer these sit in there, the more that will be inedible. Normally the store is up to par on things like this. I wish I had thought to take pictures.“

“Our favorite place! Very friendly and the icecream is the best 🍦“

“Absolutely one of our favorite ice cream places! Lots of flavor options, and the owner is very friendly! Always worth the trip! ❤️“

“While Manning's is cash only, a quick run to the ATM is ABSOLUTELY worth it! Tons of flavors, super creamy ice cream and fresh milk that is to die for! Whether you're driving down the interstate for a quick stop, or a lifetime coal digger that has been enjoying this impeccable diary for years--Manning's is a local spot that is second to none!“

“Just love there ice cream“

“As I’m sure you can tell Jamie Kennedy is trying to tear a good business down. The truth is her boyfriend worked for us for two weeks but we found him on drugs so we had to let him go. Every business goes through this at some point unfortunately“

“Frozen custard is to die for“

“First time ever coming here, I got the blueberry soft and really enjoyed it. My fiance didn’t really like the flavor they chose initially, however the worker accommodated us by giving them a new flavor free of charge. Definitely will have to come back for sure.“

“Very very nice people to deal with they went so far as to load the car rearranged it and everything I was going to make two trips instead they did it so I only had to make one thank you and will buy from you again in the near future.... Frank“

“Amazing ice cream never disappoints!“

“I’ve always been a huge fan of the Diary Bar. I recently hosted a High School Graduation Party there and it was fabulous. The Party Room was absolutely lovely. Just outside of the Party Room there is a very inviting patio area that is also available. The food and service were outstanding. Melodie and her staff are very accommodating. They offer a nice variety of food, incredibly good homemade cannolis and the best ice cream and ice cream creations you can find. I couldn’t have asked for a better experience, atmosphere, food and service than what Myself and Guests had at the Diary Bar. A big “Thank You” to Melodie and her Awesome Staff.“

“Wow! I’ve been here a few times before and it’s never been anything special but I’ve recently been back during the weekend and have been absolutely blown away by kashala (sorry if I misspelled it)! Amazing customer service, so fast and such a kind soul absolutely will be a regular just for the service“

“Very good ice cream 🍦,🍨,ice cream cakes, ice cream sandwiches and more all Blue Ribbon farm dairy made.
Can sit at counter or tables, some benches outside, plenty of parking and a ramp on the parking lot side entrance.“

“Best place to eat in Scranton. So glad you’re coming back. Great people, great food. The predominant word is.GREAT! Antivirus“

“Perfect Scoops for Outdoor Bliss at B&G's!

B&G's is the ideal spot for a delightful outdoor ice cream experience.

I recently enjoyed their soft ice cream and it was incredibly creamy and refreshing, perfect for savoring outside. The flavors are always balanced and delicious.

The friendly staff make every visit a joy, and grabbing a scoop to enjoy in the fresh air is simply the best. For fantastic ice cream and a lovely outdoor treat, B&G's is a must-visit!“

“Best.ice.cream.ever… hands down“

“Their frozen custard is better than ice cream! I love the variety of italian ice flavors! The staff is very nice and the manager! 🥰“

“I visited Duck Donuts for the first time last week. When we got there, there was a line, but it moved quickly. Staff members were extremely friendly and I saw them all working well together. Our Donuts were very warm, fresh and delicious. Will definitely be back again!“

“Used to love Padulas however this year something is off. They had amazing ice cream, Perry's, for all these years now this year it's definitely a different brand, probably Hersheys which is a little bland in my opinion. It is not their fault that I don't prefer Hersheys. Unless I am confused it's ok in a pinch. The sprinkles also seem to be not the best brand either. I asked for layered and extra extra extra, they don't do this quite as well as every other place. Maybe it's a good thing considering.“

“Had a friend tell me this was the best place to get subs while I was out of town. I had envisioned a sub spot but it was a super cute super tiny corner store. I was a bit confused where to order the sub at and had I not been told they had subs there I wouldnt have thought they did from walking in. But im so glad I did my sub was so soft and everything was so fresh and not messy. And I never heard of Joe's teas before but omg im willing to drive 2 hours again. The staff was friendly the lady was so sweet. So all in all an amazing decision. A legit must stop sub shop.“

“This place is fantastic and has great deals. We find ourselves going to Malacari’s more often.“

“I love this shop! You can have a milkshake as soon as they open! They don't judge ? and with it combined with Dunkin donuts, you have an even larger selection to choose from. I think they even can put coffee in a milkshake for you. Their cakes look really cute and I'm sure taste delicious! Definitely worth a try if you haven't already!“

“Staff was very helpful and accommodating. I placed an order for a custom ice-cream cake and was meant to pick it up, unfortunately there was an accident at the store that day so they had to close early, and I wasn't able to pick up the cake. They ended up having it delivered to the recipient for me at no extra charge which I was very grateful for.“

“Did drive thru desserts for a group of 5. They did a good job on getting all of the orders in. But I ordered the Royal New York cheesecake treat which advertised as graham crackers and cheesecake bites swirled together in the ice cream and a core of strawberry (in the middle, top to bottom of cup) to scoop as you wished, what I got was the graham crackers and cheesecake with a very small smattering of strawberry on the top. I was quite disappointed in mine, but the others were all fine. Wouldn't order that one again probably because of the experience.“

“I love this place I always go once a month you guys should add a catering option to this location and be on ezcater so people could order catering from this location thank u and please hopefully soon would love to see this location on ez cater“