Oteri's Italian Bakery
$$ • BakeryAbout Oteri's Italian Bakery
Customers' Favorites
Irish Potato 1 2 Pound Average 10 to 12 Pieces
Chocolate Covered Strawberries Large Box
Chocolate Covered Pretzels
Wedding Cake of the Day
Chocolate Covered Oreo
Cannoli Mini Chocolate
9 Strawberry Shortcake
St Joseph Day Zeppoles
Pikachu Birthday Cake
Half Sheet Layer Cake
Oteri's Italian Bakery Reviews
429 ratings
Share your opinion about Oteri's Italian Bakery
Love the pound cake the round birthday and cannolis
I have to say your cakes are outstanding from what I can see and you have really true talent :)
I ordered a cake 7pm and needed it for the next day. The cake came out PERFECT! My daughter wanted a fall theme cake and we found one online while standing in the bakery. The young lady that helped me said “yes we can do that” and they did!
We’ve been going to Oteri’s in 5th Street for many years so I knew it would taste good. We always order pound cake with buttercream icing. The decorations were all made of fondant. My daughter absolutely loved...read full review
We’ve been going to Oteri’s in 5th Street for many years so I knew it would taste good. We always order pound cake with buttercream icing. The decorations were all made of fondant. My daughter absolutely loved...read full review
Hours
| Monday | 7AM - 8PM |
| Tuesday | 7AM - 8PM |
| Wednesday | 7AM - 8PM |
| Thursday | 7AM - 8PM |
| Friday | 7AM - 8PM |
| Saturday | 7AM - 8PM |
| Sunday | 7AM - 6PM |
Oteri's Italian Bakery offers a delightful selection of baked goods, particularly their moist and delicious marble pound cake. Customers praise the friendly staff, positive service, and fair pricing, with a 7-inch square cake costing $30. The bakery has gained a loyal following, providing a satisfying experience for customers.
Oteri's has received positive reviews for their customized cakes, with customers describing the cakes as beautiful, delicious, and attention-grabbing. The bakery's online ordering process is also praised, with customers receiving prompt email confirmations and follow-up calls to ensure the order details are correct. Oteri's is a trusted choice for specialty cakes, with customers returning for their exceptional quality and service.