Custom Cakes in Pittsburgh, PA

Baked With Love Bakery • $
315 Unity Trestle Rd, Pittsburgh

Customers` Favorites

Yellow Cup Cake with Chocolate Icing Snickerdoodles and Chocolate Chip Cookies
Key Lime Cupcakes
Birthday Cake
Wedding Cake
Bakery

“I want to thank my niece Nickole Love Nader . She is the owner and baker of Baked With Love. Her and one of her staff members did an amazing job on decorating this delicious cake for my father-in-law‘s birthday. Her baked goods are absolutely amazing. The staff at this bakery are very pleasant.“

4.9 Superb134 Reviews
Amy's Bakery Bakery • $
654 Washington Rd, Pittsburgh

Customers` Favorites

Passion Fruit Crepe Cake
Lychee Crepe Cake Slice
Passionfruit Foam Cake
Chocolate Crepe Cake
Tiramisu Crepe Cake
egg tart 蛋挞2pc
Custard Mooncake
Coconut Bread
Red Bean Cake
Mochi

“Absolutely loved Amy's bakery! There was more than enough tasty fresh pastry / drink options to make choosing just one basically impossible and the service was friendly enough to make me feel at home 🫶🏽100% a spot I'm coming back to!“

4.7 Superb147 Reviews
Scoops In Bloomfield Ice Cream Shop • $
4806 Liberty Ave, Pittsburgh

Customers` Favorites

Double Scoop Ice Cream Cone
Single Scoop Ice Cream Cup
Single Scoop Ice Cream Cone
Double Scoop Ice Cream Cup
2 Scoop Sundae
Waffle Cone
Quart
Pie

“Always great ice cream and the girl serving was very kind and hard-working!“

4.8 Superb159 Reviews
The Cakery at Mandy's Bakery • $$
512 Perry Highway, Pittsburgh

Customers` Favorites

Birthday Cake

“My friend ordered the cake for my baby shower from you and it was amazing! Not only was the cake beautiful it was by far one of the best tasting cakes. It was not overly sweet and was super moist! Delicious 10/10! Thank you so very much“

4.5 Superb110 Reviews
Scoops On Beverly Ice Cream Shop • $
311 Beverly Rd, Pittsburgh

Customers` Favorites

Single Scoop Ice Cream Cup
Strawberry Cheesecake
Scoop Brownie Sundae
Made to Order Shakes
Pistachio Ice Cream
Grasshopper Sundae
Chocolate Almond
Birthday Cake
Waffle Cone
Sugar Cone

“Always great ice cream and the girl serving was very kind and hard-working!“

4.5 Superb187 Reviews
Food Glorious Food Bakery • $
5906 Bryant St, Pittsburgh

Customers` Favorites

White Lily

“Food Glorious Food is a local business that makes baked goods and also foods for breakfast, lunch, and catering such as sandwiches and pizzas. I shopped here one time. I really liked the derby pie, the pecan pie, the snickerdoodle cookie, and the cinnamon roll. I thought that the sour-cream apple pie and the asparagus-Swiss quiche were alright.“

4.7 Superb90 Reviews
The Butterwood Bake Consortium Cafe • $
5222 Butler St, Pittsburgh

Customers` Favorites

Vegan Sweet Potato Chocolate Cake with Cinnamon Espresso Buttercream
Vegan Lavender Tea Cake with Ube Buttercream
Orange Olive Oil Cake with Honey Cream
Blood Orange Cake with Fig Buttercream
Lavender Cake with Agave Buttercream
Butterscotch Pudding - Gluten Free
Browned Butter Blondie Brownie
Chocolate Chip Cookie Sandwich
Blueberry Lavender Cake Slice
Chocolate Buttercream Cake

“Just tried this place and had an amazing iced London fog and sweet treat. The baked items are so fresh and the place is a vibe. Open late too!“

4.3 Superb320 Reviews
Prantl's Bakery Bakery • $
528 E Ohio St, Pittsburgh

Customers` Favorites

Custom Cake Orders
Carrot Cake
Cake Bars
Cookies
Cakes
Torte

“I visited this Prantl’s location for the first time and was very pleased with the experience. The Cut Out Oreo cookie was excellent, and the staff were very welcoming. They were also running a buy one, get one free promotion, which was a great bonus. It is a well-run establishment that delivers a high-quality product.“

4 Good186 Reviews
Prantl's Bakery Bakery • $
5525 Walnut St, Pittsburgh

Customers` Favorites

Toasted Almond Junior Pastry
Toasted Almond Cake Bar
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Burnt Almond Torte
Chocolate Cake
Almond Cookies
Birthday Cake
Wedding Cake
Bakery

“We met with Kim here to do a wedding cake testing and it was wonderful! Very efficient and clear pricing, plus the cake was delicious and very reasonably priced! Can't wait for the big day with them! Loved that the tasting was complimentary. Kim was very responsive and very nice to work with.“

3.7 Good263 Reviews
Prantl's Bakery Bakery • $
5525 Walnut St, Pittsburgh

Customers` Favorites

Burnt Almond Tort
Almond Cookies
Birthday Cake
Wedding Cake
Almond Torte
Bakery

“Finally tried the famous Burnt Almond Cake from Prantl! They have a bunch of different treats, their almond croissants and cookies have been great, but I was surprisingly underwhelmed by the Almond cake.

The toasted outside was the best part, but the frosting was really sweet and the cream in the middle had no flavor. The cake itself was light and fluffy which was the better part. Also tried the raspberry version, which I would not really recommend if you don’t like fake fruit flavoring, original is the one to try. Overall I still love a lot of their pastries and they’re very consistent, just don’t need to get the almond cake again.“

3.8 Good97 Reviews
Happy Day Dessert Factory Dessert • $
906A Western Avenue, Pittsburgh

Customers` Favorites

Premium Hard Ice Cream
Frozen Soft Custard
Water Ice

“First time having it at an event today in Homewood. Some of the best ice cream I have ever had. The water ice is to die for. This place is truly a must try“

3.8 Good155 Reviews
Cold Stone Creamery Ice Cream Shop • $$
1035 Freeport Rd, Pittsburgh

Customers` Favorites

Apple Pie a La Cold Stone - Freezer
Cookies and Creamery
Coffee Ice Cream
Birthday Cake
Cake Batter

“Cold Stone is my favorite ice cream shop of all time. It has this amazing concept that you can mix in anything you want into your ice cream. They have many different types of ice cream and they always give you way more ice cream then you pay for. The service is great and they are very patient when you are picking your flavor and toppings. Thank you so much, Cold Stone.“

3.6 Good134 Reviews
Cold Stone Creamery Ice Cream Shop • $$
5800 Forbes Ave, Pittsburgh

Customers` Favorites

Mint and Dark Chocolate Ice Cream
Chocolate Devotion
Chocolate Brownie
Waffle Cone
Cake Batter
Strawberry
Cold Stone

“If I talk about something tasty or peaceful for myself, it means Cold Stone. Their ice cream is so good and so fresh! I’ve been a regular customer for 8 years now, and this is my favorite place. Yes, their prices are a bit higher compared to other stores, but the quality is also top-notch. I really like the ice cream from this store. Even all the employees are very nice.“

3.6 Good143 Reviews
Cold Stone Creamery Ice Cream Shop • $$
6509 Robinson Centre Dr, Pittsburgh

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Chipper - Ready Now
Birthday Cake
Cold Stone
Cookie
Oreo

“EXCELLENT! Brooklynn, the pretty little girl who waited on me, was sweet and nice and friendly, and patient with me while I decided what I wanted. She let me sample some and I chose the coffee flavor (soooo good) with pecans, caramel, and marshmallow. Decadent! It was even interesting and fun to watch the preperation process. The price was appropriate. The service was GREAT! My server Brooklynn looked like she really enjoyed her job. Don't see that much anymore. It was refreshing to see such good behavior and get respect from a young person these days. Definitely go back and HIGHLY RECOMMEND!“

3.5 Good151 Reviews