28 Best Pizza Restaurants near Shermans Dale

“I’m from NY, where good pizza (of all styles) can be found easily. This pizza is delicious and the best I’ve had in PA so far. Thin crust, light sauce, with an airy crust. We had pepperoni with mushrooms and sausage. Although the mushrooms were canned, they still had a good flavor. pepperoni and sausage were tasty.We also had the garlic knots which were delicious. They have just a small amount of garlic seasoning, which I liked. My boyfriend said they needed more garlic, so it depends on your preference. 12 decent sized knots in an order with plenty of sauce! Generous portions for the price.Only problem is, I can't find a menu anywhere to see what else there is to try here. We asked at the restaurant but they didn't have any. My boyfriend ended up just taking a picture of the menu wall. Other than that, it was excellent and I will be coming back anytime I want pizza.“

“Best sauce.“

“I don’t make it to Carlisle very often, especially to eat. I saw a review in the hoagie guru group and was in town a few days later so grabbed an Italian sub and was awesome! Came back last night with my kiddo for pizza and trust me, making the trip down more often! Awesome food guys, excellent service!“

“The best pizza in Carlisle!!!“

“1st time trying the pizza this evening 7/23/24... REAL pizzeria style pizza...ABSOLUTELY LOVED IT ❤️“

“Great food, and fast, friendly service!“

“We were asking family members who had the best subs in Carlisle. They said Brad's! We had their cheeseburger subs the other night and I came back to comment on how good they were. Nice burgers, not frozen patties. Very good rolls, fresh ingredients and just a great sub!“

“This place has great pizza and huge amazing salads. We were driving across the state and stopped to go to the gym after our workout we were very hungry and because I avoid gluten, we needed to find somewhere. The Pizza Grille was a surprising gem. The pizza flavors are all so interesting. We took home so much pizza but it was worth it. I would come back if we come through this way again.

Dietary restrictions: They have gluten free options“

“I went to mamma's for years. By the way, the remodeling was done by the original momma's, not the oners that's there now. Mimma and Rosario made the pizza shop from 1982-2018, the whole family took pride in what they did, and always gave too others.“

“My dad used to grab these subs for dinner many years ago when he worked in Carlisle, and now that I work right up the street in Mechanicsburg, they're definitely still a favorite lunch go-to! The staff are always friendly, and I've never been disappointed by a thing they've made yet.“

“Went here with a friend we got a xl pizza which is 18" and two fountain drinks it was $33 and the pizza was out in 12 minutes, and it was perfect the cheese was gooey, the crust was crispy and the service was amazing the employees are respectful. Go to new york for the views, go here for the best pizza I've ever had and I've been to NY and DC it is better than both of them it is simply beautiful. (Bonus they have cherry Pepsi)“

“I don’t get here often enough but when I do,they never disappoint! Great food,Fast friendly service“

“Still my favorite pizza shop in Duncannon and Perry County. I've been here consistently for the last 2 1/2 years and the food always measures up. The owner, and management are some of the most considerate and friendly staff I've ever met.“

“Thank you Lisa & Sam for your hard work in keeping Sorrentos going. My sub was delicious tonight.“

“This is the best Pizza in Carlisle. Reminds me of Pizza Shops when I was a kid. Friendly staff. I go all the time.“

“I had the maple bacon donut!!! it melts in your mouth!!!!! So fresh and delicious!!!“

“Food has always been outstanding!“

“We've lived near this place for years and didn't even know it was there. A road detour in place for a bridge replacement sends us past it pretty often now and we decided to give it a try. The inside is small and might not be much for eating in but the pizza was great! I can't wait to try the wings!“

“90% of the time, the food is great! But on April 16th, 2023, I got a delivery. The Fettuccine Alfredo was great, but the salad was AWFUL! I ordered a Grilled Chocken Salad and it DID NOT have any grilled chicken on it, it had NO croutons, & it had NO cheese on it! It was bland and awful!“

“I visited this pizza bolis because the Mechanicsburg location reportedly experienced a fire and closed down. Their pizza was satisfactory, although a bit oily. They do have a restroom, but it's accessed through the kitchen; I'm unsure about their policy on restroom access for customers.“

“90% of the time, the food is great! But on April 16th, 2023, I got a delivery. The Fettuccine Alfredo was great, but the salad was AWFUL! I ordered a Grilled Chocken Salad and it DID NOT have any grilled chicken on it, it had NO croutons, & it had NO cheese on it! It was bland and awful!“

“Stopped here before our boys football game and the food and service is AMAZING. Highly recommend.“

“I've been here twice and love the place. It's a smoking bar so just know that going in and if you don't like that go somewhere else. The food is great and the drinks are cheap! You can go there with $20 and eat and drink for a while. I'm not a super chatty guy but I sat at the bar and made some friends anyway because everyone there is super nice and love to make you feel at home.
There's pool tables, live music, and touch tones music. Love this place!“

“Great Italian food. Robust flavors!“

“I dont write reviews, but shout out to the guy with the red beard, A+ customer service. Absolutely made my day just by being a kind person and welcoming as I entered the store. This kind of energy and genuinely good customer service is hard to find these days.

Otherwise, never had any issue with this store. The food always comes out amazing and as ordered. Thank you to the whole team!“

“I had a wonderful time at Papa John's in Carlisle, PA. The workers are so kind, and they gave me an extra pepper in my box. Best pizza I've ever had!

Vegetarian options: Cheese pizza, veggie pizza, pizza without meat

Dietary restrictions: Red sauce, meat

Parking: Outside the store

Kid-friendliness: The workers were so sweet.

Wheelchair accessibility: There is a slope for wheelchairs.“

“amazing staff and great food“