Italian Restaurants near Stillwater

“Unbelievable!!! Arguably the best restaurant that I’ve eaten at in years… and I live in NYC!!! The vibe is perfect and the food is amazing. I’ve eaten here 3 different months and 3 completely different menus… and each time was awesome!! Highly recommend!!“

“I just had one of the BEST Sicilian pizzas i've had in a very long time! It's my favorite type of pizza and a good one is difficult to find. The owner gave me a discount because he wasn't satisfied with how it came out...if this was a "bad" pizza, I am looking forward to a good one!!!!! Great tasting dough and loved the sauce! Staff was excellent as well!! Can't wait to go back!“

“went to bridal shower on a Sunday first time there food was so good . Went back on Wednesday to order take out dinner awesome food“

“Legit Italian food. First time at a taste of Italy but, not the last. Atmosphere was great, our server was fantastic and the food was amazing! The prices were very reasonable for the food that we got. It was hot, prepared perfectly and the presentation was great!“

“My husband and I happily drive 45 minutes here for their amazing vegan food. The vegan pizza is so great, and they always have an exciting vegan dessert option—like lemon blueberry pie, Oreo cake, chocolate pistachio pie. They put a lot of love into their vegan food (rare for this area) and we so appreciate it!“

“Took my mom and aunt for an early mother's day meal man the food was really good ? and the price well almost like olive garden prices but soo worth it. And Lisa was really friendly and helpful and polite with service.Wheelchair accessibility: There's parking for the handicap ♿️.“

“Food is great. The fried stuff is a bit inconsistent, but the subs and wings are great every time. Staff is what you would expect, teenagers mostly and not very friendly but the food makes up for it. It’s a little pricey as well but they don’t cut corners and the food tastes the same as it did 15 years ago. Definitely worth the price and I would recommend Romeo’s over most other local options.“

“The food is good, I love their Sicilian with extra cheese, cheese steak Stromboli, among many other choices. We've encountered the wrong order 3 separate times when picking up takeout. But they compensated and apologized. They have a huge dining area and a great location close to our home.“

“This is our pizza place! This Original Italian Pizza (OIP) has the best food to our liking. The Original Italian Pizza's in all locations are not related! We did not know this until last year. This OIP has a FANTASTIC lunch buffet!!! They usually have a main dish, a few different pizzas with different toppings, small salad bar, garlic knots, steak and regular Stromboli and more daily(call for business hours and if they have indoor dining; usually on the weekends they are open for indoor dining with longer hours and during the week for a few hours during the lunch buffet but during the week after those hours they only do takeout and delivery) We love so many of their dishes, pizza, Sicilian pizza, steak and regular Stromboli and subs . The only thing I did not care for was instead of fresh vegetables on an antipasto they put the vinegary vegetable mix out of a jar maybe to save time and money? We head to OIP in Berwick, Pa several times per month, we love their food, service, and rustic ambience dining area. Plenty of parking and conveniently located by Giant supermarket and Sheetz;located across from Dollar General.“

“What luck to have stopped in Bloomsburg this evening to enjoy soup and salad at the Olive Garden. My server was excellent and the only minor issue was my breadsticks were not as soft as I expected them to be. I’m sure it was maybe due to arriving after the dinner rush was over. However, I would not hesitate to stop here again on my next travel day!“

“They are GREAT! Delivered ON TIME, pizza was nice & hot (& good!)“