11 Best Italian Restaurants near Stillwater

“If you haven’t, you need to! The vibe was amazing. The food was spectacular and the service was out of this world.“

“My dinner on Saturday evening was delicious. The service was first-rate, the servers were friendly and removed used dishes in a timely fashion. I would recommend Amici's to anyone planning to dine out in the Berwick area in the near future. Stacey and Joey and their crew are good, hard-working people. JT“

“5 ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ Stop in by chance on our way back to Boston from Indiana. Has soon as we walked in I said this is going to be a great meal!! The place is clean and smells Greeted with a friendly hello and a smile, we were sat within minutes, our waitress came right over and introduced herself. She informed us of the specials, answered all of our questions and made some recommendations based off our answers. I knew from the moment we walked in and I was wright Food was amazing, staff was knowledgeable and friendly it was a great experience and I will be returning“

“Pleasant to order from and the food is very good! We will be back.“

“The Olive Garden in Bloomsburg is my comfort food headquarters. I order takeout like it’s a habit I should probably explain to someone, and the shrimp tortellini is the reason.

I also want to mention the manager, Tamara, because you can tell when someone is running a place versus just being “on duty.” This feels like the first one.

The energy is calm, things move, no one looks panicked, and somehow everything keeps working. Which tells me someone is probably answering a question, fixing a schedule, smoothing something over, and mentally tracking five things at once, without announcing any of it.

That kind of leadership matters.

I’ll keep coming back. And yes, shrimp tortellini will continue to be involved.“

“They are GREAT! Delivered ON TIME, pizza was nice & hot (& good!)“

“A+ Always!!..Never had anything bad..Garlic Knots are the best!..Sweet sauce pizza is 👌“

“ordered through doordash-first mistake (no help from their customer service)but issue was quickly and kindly resolved by the establishment“

“Great food and nice people“

“Such a great place! Best pizza I’ve had in years! Also the best service I’ve had in years! Feels like being part of the family. LOVE that vibe!!!“

“Staff had amazing personalities! Small dining area but very nicely decorated and very clean . Food was amazing and pricing was reasonable . Only thing I’d change is the plates, they are huge and heavy , glad I would not want to be a waitress and Carry those all day .“