6 Best Pizza Restaurants near Tannersville

“The absolute BEST PIZZA!! But was it just pizza? No, no it was so much more than a slice of pizza. I was dancing in the restaurant while whole heartedly enjoying the slice of one of the best slices of pizza I have ever had! I barely made it to the table before the slice was in my hands! We ate in the restaurant but ment to take it to go! If that’s not an indication of how good the pizza was I don’t know what else to say. Before I could leave out of the door into the snow to let the employees finish cleaning without my dancing and mmmmm’s being a distraction I am walking to the exit with pizza still in hand because I could not put the slice down!!!! All the while calling a friend that lives nearby for him to order pizza for himself ! Would rate 10/10 already have recommended and trying to figure out any excuse to come back from Ohio immediately“

“I haven’t been there yet, but after hearing this lovely story of how wonderfully honest and kind the owners are and hearing so many stories of how delicious the food is I will definitely be stopping by!!!“

“We stopped for pizza after visiting Great Wolf Lodge. They treated us like family!!!“

“Me and my family were visiting Great Wolf Lodge. With the horrible pricing on all the food there and our quite a big party (16 people including children) we looked for a local restaurant to support. We came upon this place as it was super close. We went in tonight and had the best service ever. All 16 of us were treated as family. The food was wonderful! The service was even better! The two cooks handled our huge party like the BOSSES they are. We will be back! P.S The Tony’s Cheesesteak with Mayo and the sauce on the side is to DIE for. 😋“

“Bea is wonderful! She was so kind and helpful with my order.“

“We had dinner here after a fun-filled day at Aquatopia (highly recommend). I called ahead for seating for 12, and the staff had our space ready to go when we arrived. We had the family special with 2 cheese pizzas and wings (what a deal!), as well as their renowned Big Mike’s pizza. It was the best pizza we’ve ever had - crispy pepperoni, fresh basil, crushed red pepper, and a honey-inspired seasoning topped it off. Friendly staff and great prices - less than $90 to feed 12 hungry kids and adults! The place seems have a new name. We typed Mountain Pizzeria in the maps app, but the actual name was Bubba Jay’s.“