24 Best Pizza Restaurants near Tobyhanna

“Honey hot pizza 🍕 is great. All the dinners are best in the area. Chicken parm, the antipasto salad is 10 out of 10. Highly recommend.“

“awesome experience Leila is the best !!“

“If you are From NJ/NY and are tired of the bad doughy pizza in the Poconos then you gotta hit this spot up! When I’m in the mood for pizza I don’t consider another spot.

I’m from NJ originally so the food out here was lacking flavor big time for us but
We absolutely Love this Pizza.

If your in this area and in the mood for pizza then this is your next destination 💯%

💪🏼“

“Pizza was delicious. I really enjoyed the sauce. Crispy crust.“

“I moved to the Long Pond area earlier this year and upon doing so I’ve tried a few different takeout restaurants but NOTHING compares to AJ’s food and customer service! From the pizza to the cheesesteak (phenomenal by the way), this place is in a league of their own! Hands down. Very kind staff as well. Owner is very personable and has even made a couple delivers to me. Highly recommend! Enough to let you know that this is the first restaurant and/or food review that I’ve ever posted. -Ryan“

“I haven’t been there yet, but after hearing this lovely story of how wonderfully honest and kind the owners are and hearing so many stories of how delicious the food is I will definitely be stopping by!!!“

“Ordered a white stuffed pizza yesterday. Suggestion: More mozzarella cheese in the crust, thicker crust, cooked a little longer so the crust is crispy! Put it on the menu, and name it after me LOL“

“Whether you are heading to the Crossings in Scotrun, PA, the Mt Airy Casino, Great Wolf Lodge, working near or traveling through, Nick’s is a must stop! A great business model with a true sense of running a successful business while serving awesome sandwiches, soups, breakfast 8 am, using fresh ingredients and a kitchen staff eager to prepare great food. One cheesesteak, sauce on side, on a fresh semolina roll, substantial meat, cheesy with nice flavors. The Italian sub, piled high with select Boars Head meats on same seeded roll was so big, it satisfied my hearty appetite. The chili and crab soup were totally delicious, well seasoned and hearty. At $6.99 for 12 ounces (bowl), they both satisfied us as an appetizer or lunch. The soups change daily! It was a delight talking to the owner who takes much pride in the 7 month old deli. I’m happy they landed in this part of the Poconos for residents and travelers to enjoy! We’ll definitely return to try the pizza and a pork Etta sandwich. Open every day but Sunday.“

“Best food, nicest staff I’ve found in quite some time. It is indeed a pleasure to eat there.“

“Never a disappointment when it comes to great food. Always a good meal no matter what you order.“

“Excellent Italian food. Family friendly.“

“I was a auto mechanic at ray price ford on 940 near mt pocono in 1992 when I first met Roberto he made me a cheesesteak that was out of this world and now I live in Hanover Township and I still go there with my family for dinner and that cheesesteak hero I rate him a10 Nick Nipitella 👍👍👍🍺🍺“

“Me and my family were visiting Great Wolf Lodge. With the horrible pricing on all the food there and our quite a big party (16 people including children) we looked for a local restaurant to support. We came upon this place as it was super close. We went in tonight and had the best service ever. All 16 of us were treated as family. The food was wonderful! The service was even better! The two cooks handled our huge party like the BOSSES they are. We will be back! P.S The Tony’s Cheesesteak with Mayo and the sauce on the side is to DIE for. 😋“

“Our Favorite Restaurant. Delicious & Plenty of food. Deserts are Amazing!!“

“I’m a New Yorker and I recommend this Pizza 🍕 spot.
Clean environment to dine in
Hot fresh pizza
The Garlic knot is great and very garlicky indeed as should be with raw Garlic 🧄
I’ll dine here again when out here and in need of a slice or two.
Not forgetting all the pepper flakes and herb jars all filled to the top to add to your slices if needed.
They also have beers 🍻 and different juices and soda at cold to enjoy of your choice with your meal.“

“Roadside catered our wedding at The Venue at Carley Brook and the food and service was outstanding! Our guests raved about the cocktail hour appetizers and the dinner. The service during the cocktail hour was especially great as there were always options being passed out by staff. Coordination was a breeze and the prices were reasonable. We will be stopping by the restaurant for some more food this summer!“

“Great food! Great staff! Love the garlic knots!“

“The pizzas are fresh, made to order. They call them personal pizzas but it's large enough to share. She wasn't bashful with the toppings or cheese either. A really good deal. About $11 with 2 toppings. Their prices are really good, especially compared to everything else.“

“We had dinner here after a fun-filled day at Aquatopia (highly recommend). I called ahead for seating for 12, and the staff had our space ready to go when we arrived. We had the family special with 2 cheese pizzas and wings (what a deal!), as well as their renowned Big Mike’s pizza. It was the best pizza we’ve ever had - crispy pepperoni, fresh basil, crushed red pepper, and a honey-inspired seasoning topped it off. Friendly staff and great prices - less than $90 to feed 12 hungry kids and adults! The place seems have a new name. We typed Mountain Pizzeria in the maps app, but the actual name was Bubba Jay’s.“

“Food was very well prepared and our waitress Hellen A. Was very attentive and kind hearted to my family and I, we are very much appreciative and will be recommending her and Sortino’s to many of my friends in the area of the Poconos“

“By far best pizza in the Arrowhead lake area!“

“Great place. It was very clean and the staff was very friendly. I love their specials.“

“One of the Best restaurants I’ve been to in over 6 years living here!“

“Late post, but had to give credit where it’s due! Domino’s came through on my June 24th delivery. I had an issue with my order, and the team at Domino’s went above and beyond to make it right. Not only did they quickly address the mistake, but they also handled everything with kindness and professionalism. It’s rare to see this level of customer care these days, and I truly appreciate the effort they put into making sure that my son was satisfied. Thank you for turning the experience around and showing what great service looks like!“