18 Best Pizza Restaurants near Lake Ariel

“We went for the first time this weekend. we loved it. The food was amazing and we really liked our server. I wish I remembered her name. She was on point. The band was great and we stayed way longer then we intended to because we were having a blast.“

“Wooooow What a Gem! This pizza was exactly what I wanted tonight. Very large, yet thin slices. A very solid mastery of pizza fundamentals. The prices were fair and the food was great. The shop itself is not huge, so maybe don’t plan on showing up with 20 guests, but there are a few tables outside. The shop is impeccably clean and the staff were very friendly. The food was ready exactly when they said it would be. Try a specialty pizza! Oh, and cash only, with an ATM on premise.

Parking: A little tight if on a busy night.“

“Awesome food and we got to see a great live band!“

“Great service, great food. I have never been disappointed when I order from Riffs. I try to make it at least once a week if not more. They are like family. Keep up the good work.“

“My family and I absolutely love Gretchen's Grotto. The staff is the absolute best! They are always friendly and kind. We love the quality of their food, the many menu choices and the extremely generous portion sizes. Gretchen and her wonderful team feeds us at least twice a week. I highly recommend them!“

“Had the pierogi for the first time for our Christmas Eve dinner and they were excellent.“

“I haven’t had Royal Pizza in a while so I decided one night to order it. It was delicious: it’s become my favorite local pizza“

“I have been eating Ferri's Pizza since I was a kid ( currently 50 ), this is my all time favorite pizza, totally unique taste & always consistent, never changed in my 50 years of life. The inside of the shop is a totally awesome step back in time, I'm totally huge on nostalgia. Definitely 5 stars from me!!“

“Best pizza in town! Only bad thing is the station they’ve chosen for Christmas. WAY too religious! YIKES! Playing Christmas music is one thing, but Sirius XM Christmas Spirit is not appropriate for a restaurant.“

“I had the pleasure of dining at Peanut Bar for the first time last night, and it was an absolute delight. The restaurant is beautifully decorated with a modern yet welcoming atmosphere. The staff were incredibly friendly and attentive, and the food was simply amazing. I started with the Buffalo Chicken Empanadas, which were crispy and flavorful. For my main course, I had the Gnocchi in a vodka sauce, and it was hands down the best gnocchi I've ever had. The gnocchi were perfectly cooked, and the vodka sauce was rich and creamy. But the star of the show was definitely the meatballs. They were so tender and juicy, and the flavor was out of this world. I'm not exaggerating when I say they were the best meatballs I've ever had in my 33 years on this earth. I had a wonderful conversation with the owner/chef about his passion for making delicious food with simple ingredients and innovative techniques. It's clear that he cares deeply about providing a great dining experience for his customers. If you're looking for a place for great food, great atmosphere, and great people, I can't recommend Peanut Bar enough. It's a 10/10 in my book.“

“Everything at Leonor's is so delicious. It is our goto place for a dinner out.“

“pizza was amazing. my first time ordering too ..“

“My recent visit to this Italian restaurant was nothing short of exceptional. From the moment I stepped in, the welcoming ambiance set the tone for a perfect evening. The décor was warm and inviting, creating a relaxed atmosphere ideal for families, groups, or anyone looking to enjoy a great meal.

The service was outstanding—honest, friendly, and prompt. Emily made us feel like valued guests, offering recommendations with genuine enthusiasm and checking in just the right amount without hovering. Her attention to detail and willingness to accommodate our needs, adding personal recommendations with a personal touch that truly elevated the experience.

The food was the star of the night. Each dish tasted freshly made to order. From the homemade pasta to the rich sauces, everything was crafted with care and precision. The ingredients tasted incredibly fresh. The chicken parm was juicy! It was clear that the chefs are passionate about their craft, putting heart and soul into their plates.

Overall, this restaurant provided an incredible blend of delicious Italian food, outstanding service, and a welcoming atmosphere that made us feel right at home. I can’t wait to return and highly recommend it to anyone seeking a family-friendly Italian dining experience.

And the drinks were really good too!“

“Best pizza in Carbondale invmy opinion..“

“We will definitely go back again. Very clean restaurant very friendly service and the food was absolutely delicious.“

“Delicious food, kind staff, great atmosphere. Still thinking about those barbecue ribs 😋🤤“

“Order my dominoes pizza today and it was the great pizza for me and my family dominoes never let us down I give them a rate of five star great staff and thank you dominoes“

“I have been going here for a number of years now. I am old school and enjoy the diner experiance. The senior service staff are outstanding. I have noticed latley the new younger servers are full of attitude and just nasty.
I really enjoy the origonal section with the train. I noticed latley when you arrive for a meal the staff shoves you into the new section without asking you if you would like to sit in the diner side. When you tell staff you would like to sit in diner side they get all bent out of shape
I go to the restaurant for the experience not attitude. The service staff up front all stand around and talk and not help the customer. I was in a few weeks ago and a greeter was putting napkins around silverwear and has a nasty attitude because she did not want to let me sit in the diner side.
Its sounds infantile but its the experience of dining. I have cut my amount of time going there now because I am tired of the negative attitude with the young servers. Give me a senior server anyday. They know there job well.

I thought the business should know the customers side.

I enjoy the food.“