17 Best Pizza Restaurants near Hawley

“Sandwiches are sold by the pound, our you NUTS? So your saying my guarantee is I'll NEVER get ripped off and I can order it heavy or light? I like this idea. Not conventional but maybe everyone should follow suit here. This is something I experienced in Florence by the way. so if the quality is there, then quit your whining, and LOOSEN UP I say! Publishing fixed prices with the way the cost of food goods are fluctuating like gas prices is a huge waste of time and money for small business! A small business owner who usually doesn't have enough time in the day as it is, should simply adopt the concept. It probably saves a ton of money and time, I get it, I applaud the notion! Everything was wonderful!“

“Our family really enjoyed Reno's veggie pizza! We are looking forward to going back! Thank you so much!“

“I just want to say the sandwich I got today was amazing!!! It was so good I had to find their page and write a review…. I had the Wilsonville and man was that sandwich amazingly delicious 🤤 I will definitely get it again for sure!! It had chicken cutlet roasted red peppers and fresh mozzarella cheese with a balsalmic dressing so fresh and delicious!! WELL DONE LAKESIDE“

“best pizza around the area! we went for the first time this Sunday great service friendly staff and great food!!!“

“The food was excellent. Loved that it came with Salad and Bread.
It was a bit pricey. I thought. The portion was okay.
The service got a 3 because I called ahead to be able to pick my order.
When I arrived the lady answered the phone before greeting me. And had me wait standing there while she took a 5 minute phone order.
If I am there in person she could have placed them on a brief hold and given me my food and charge me so I could be on my way.“

“Restuant and food is excellent….service is off the charts“

“Food is delicious!! Pizza is amazing and peanut butter pie is oh my goodness!“

“I’ve always gotten a good slice or pie from here but the hours are not consistent at all. For example, I wanted to grab a couple slices today after work and 330 in the afternoon closed. Hours on the door say it’s supposed to be open so does googles hours.“

“It's Papa John's. It tastes the same every where. Is there better local? Yes. But sometimes you want consistency. Sometimes you want 2 pizzas and wings for 20 bucks. Don't listen to haters. It's mechanized mass produced perfection. That's why it's a national chain and your local favorite isn't.“

“I can't be happier to have this really tasteful restaurant here so close to our town! The unique style and food favorites give Mosey's a new flair to this area. It will be our regular stop for us!“

“My husband and I went for pizza tonight. This was our first time here. Just the aroma when entering was enough to make you mouth water. The atmosphere is so nice. The building is beautiful and esthetically pleasing. A soft relaxing ambiance. The pizza (extra cheese, mushroom, onion and garlic NY style) was amazing!!! The crust is thin with a nice crisp. The sauce was seriously on point. One of the best pizzas I have ever had. We will be back!“

“Great and extensive menu but my favorite food is their scrapple! Love the trains running around the ceiling.“

“Friendly staff, and the best pizza in Honesdale!“

“Excellent margarita pizza the wi gs are outstanding !! The best ever“

“mom and me where there today for lunch the server was great the pizza was DELICIOUS the unsweetened tea was good“

“John’s Italian is excellent! The pizza is absolutely delicious with the perfect crispy crust. The Stromboli is huge, crunchy on the outside, and packed with flavor. The service is always friendly and welcoming.

What made our visit extra special was the kindness of the staff. My two kids each donated a dollar to support autism, and the ladies working there surprised them with two huge cookies as a thank-you. Such a thoughtful gesture that meant a lot to them. Great food, wonderful people, and outstanding customer service. We’ll definitely be back!“

“Yesterday, I ordered food for my children and I. I ordered the five cheese with breadsticks. When I got home they gave me the wrong thing. I called today and explained the situation and was given a replacement today, i added a hawaiian pizza, with ham pineapple and added onions and other items to my order today. When I got home it had ham, pineapple, bacon, green peppers and onions. I was clearly upset because my order was made wrong again and when I called the manager would not speak to me because he was "busy". I drove back because I was really upset that my orders had been messed up two days in a row. I walked in and asked that he please remake my pizza. The manager tried to fight me on this. I spoke over him because when I looked at the menu peppers do NOT come on a Hawaiian pizza. He told me to leave the store, I said no I was not leaving I wanted my order corrected, or my money back. I again explained, this time I was very upset, I didn't feel I was asking for too much, that I specifically asked for ham, pineapple and onions. He nor I mentioned bacon or peppers. I hate bacon and peppers, and I had just been told to leave the store because they clearly messed up my order! I was told I was banned from the store and that I was acting like an "animal" by the general manager in front of other customers, because I had gotten upset. I told him I was not leaving until I got my money back and he called the police on me and stated that I was "going to jail". I asked him for the owner's contact information or his boss's information, because I know he does not own the store. He would not tell me. I let him know I would be contacting the corporate office. When the police got there I explained that they made my order incorrectly and I came in visibly upset because my order was wrong the day before as well. I told her I wanted my money back. When she spoke to the manager he stated that he was busy, it was clear he was overwhelmed but good customer service would have been to remake my pizza or offer me a refund. Try to rectify the situation, not ban me and refuse me a refund because I was upset over the mistake. This whole situation could have been avoided if the manager owned their mistake and just agreed to make the correct pie or give my money back before the police were called. I did receive a refund but was told that I was no longer allowed in the store. My son is autistic and only eats certain foods, his favorite food is domino's pizza so I am highly upset that we are no longer welcome there because of a mistake made by the company.“