17 Best Pizza Restaurants near Hawley

“Best Breaded Chicken Cutlets around!“

“Our family really enjoyed Reno's veggie pizza! We are looking forward to going back! Thank you so much!“

“this place is great. over the years it's been many different names like the Hoagie Hut and Dam good Food and it was also one a Subway. All those paled in comparison to the folks running it now cuz they are super nice folks and the menu is great! Highly recommended“

“Best cauliflower crust I’ve ever had!!! Cannot recommend them enough!!! Five stars!!“

“Ok, if you’re looking for a sandwich that will likely turn into tasty leftovers , get yourself the CHEESESTEAK SPECIAL.. As a guy from Brooklyn,, who knows what good cheesesteaks taste like, this one is realllllly good.. AND A LOT… 5 stars… never “

“Restuant and food is excellent….service is off the charts“

“Great pizza, good wine, excellent service !“

“My family and I absolutely love Gretchen's Grotto. The staff is the absolute best! They are always friendly and kind. We love the quality of their food, the many menu choices and the extremely generous portion sizes. Gretchen and her wonderful team feeds us at least twice a week. I highly recommend them!“

“First time coming here with my family. We enjoyed the food and the prices weren’t too bad. The servers were nice and made sure to check on us.
The only issue I noticed was neither of the doors in the female bathroom stalls locked.“

“I spontaneously stopped in with my dad when we stopped in the parking lot to stretch our legs from a long drive.It was the perfect new york style pie, nice and light with a good ratio of sauce and cheese. I really enjoyed it! Will be back again!“

“My Mom and I ate here last night. The food was amazing had a Reuben Rider which is turkey, swiss cheese and pickled red cabbage on toasted rye had a side of thousand Island dressing. Really enjoyed it it was something different. Mom had a grilled hamburger and mashed potatoes. Great food great choices I recommend everybody try it. Will be going back.

Vegetarian options: There are many options but they will work with you Just ask for an option of food your looking for.

Parking: Lot's of parking either side of the building

Kid-friendliness: Good food options

Wheelchair accessibility: There is a big beautiful ramp in the back. An a very nice ramp in the front. Easy access.“

“My recent visit to this Italian restaurant was nothing short of exceptional. From the moment I stepped in, the welcoming ambiance set the tone for a perfect evening. The décor was warm and inviting, creating a relaxed atmosphere ideal for families, groups, or anyone looking to enjoy a great meal.

The service was outstanding—honest, friendly, and prompt. Emily made us feel like valued guests, offering recommendations with genuine enthusiasm and checking in just the right amount without hovering. Her attention to detail and willingness to accommodate our needs, adding personal recommendations with a personal touch that truly elevated the experience.

The food was the star of the night. Each dish tasted freshly made to order. From the homemade pasta to the rich sauces, everything was crafted with care and precision. The ingredients tasted incredibly fresh. The chicken parm was juicy! It was clear that the chefs are passionate about their craft, putting heart and soul into their plates.

Overall, this restaurant provided an incredible blend of delicious Italian food, outstanding service, and a welcoming atmosphere that made us feel right at home. I can’t wait to return and highly recommend it to anyone seeking a family-friendly Italian dining experience.

And the drinks were really good too!“

“We will definitely go back again. Very clean restaurant very friendly service and the food was absolutely delicious.“

“Our host recommended Carini for dinner and it did not disappoint! Food was hot, seafood plentiful, portions large, and overall delicious. We had hot antipasto, chicken saltibocca, zuppa di peche. and homemade gelato to finish the meal. We took leftovers home. Our server was polite and attentive managing a busy dinner by herself! A great experience!“

“Excellent margarita pizza the wi gs are outstanding !! The best ever“

“Great food. Personal pizzas were fresh and delicious. My 5 year old son who is a picky eater loved the spaghetti with a meatball (which was huge) and ate it all. My son also dropped a small toy down in between the booth seats and the wall and we could not reach it, the amazing gentleman working the front was kind enough to come back and pull of the booth seats so we could retrieve the toy which he didn’t have to do (we had just assumed the seats could not be moved and accepted the fact that the toy had been lost) So a huge thank you to the staff for going above and beyond and being great people.“

“I have been going here for a number of years now. I am old school and enjoy the diner experiance. The senior service staff are outstanding. I have noticed latley the new younger servers are full of attitude and just nasty.
I really enjoy the origonal section with the train. I noticed latley when you arrive for a meal the staff shoves you into the new section without asking you if you would like to sit in the diner side. When you tell staff you would like to sit in diner side they get all bent out of shape
I go to the restaurant for the experience not attitude. The service staff up front all stand around and talk and not help the customer. I was in a few weeks ago and a greeter was putting napkins around silverwear and has a nasty attitude because she did not want to let me sit in the diner side.
Its sounds infantile but its the experience of dining. I have cut my amount of time going there now because I am tired of the negative attitude with the young servers. Give me a senior server anyday. They know there job well.

I thought the business should know the customers side.

I enjoy the food.“