50 Best Pizza Restaurants near West Mifflin

“I Actually stumbled upon this place accident. It was the day before Christmas Eve And the only place That was open within A 40 minute drive. The owner was concerned about making my pizza fresh, even though I had to be his last Customer of the night.
I’m a small girl, but there were only two slices left of that medium pepperoni pizza by the time I got home. Perfect, thin crunchy crust And their sauce had a slight kick to it, but I wouldn’t consider it spicy Or too hot. I don’t know, but it was really good and I’ve been thinking about it for Days.“

“I have been going to this place since I was a kid. After a visit to Kennywood we would always go for pizza here. The original owners we some of the nicest people I had met over the years and their daughter is carrying on the tradition . She always greets everyone with a smile and is super friendly :) My family and I love their square pizza and usually asked for it to be baked alittle longer for extra crunchiness. My 6 yr old grandson loves their pizza and always ask for it when he a over . The sauce and cheese is always the right amount, the pepperoni is yummy too !!! All around every visit here is always a positive experience 🍕😋🇮🇹“

“Delicious kennywood style fries and fresh charbroiled hamburgers French bread pizza was awesome also and was delivered fast and hot“

“great place great food love it“

“This was my first time I have had Pizza Bistro, and I can say that I would definitely order again. My Aunt was one of the winners of a specialty salad on one of your Facebook posts. Since she wanted to pick up her salad for dinner I decided to order pizza and the garlic breadsticks. They were delicious. Pizza was cooked perfectly, and the breadsticks were warm and garlicky ,definitely one of my favorites . I can definitely say that your Facebook advertisement made me a customer !“

“A really solid pizza joint in the local space with a good number of options, though I've time and time again heard that the pizza is the real treat. After having had it, I can certainly see why!

They do a big, cheesy, and greasy pizza. Though, if that's your fare, they do it up brilliantly. For my mother, that's the best kind of pizza, and I tend not to mind. So, it was definitely a welcome experience. It places a much closer stop than Monongahela for her personal choice of pizza.

It's one of those rare places where I think their cheese pizza might be their best pick, unless you're a fan of a lot of veggies on your pizza, in which case onions, mushrooms, peppers, and the like might really sell you. The Greek pizza is also good, though that's more my mother's choice than mine.

I'd definitely recommend stopping on by if it sounds like your kind of place!“

“Support Local Pizza. I’ve ordered 10+ times this year and only had one error which they corrected. Pizza is good, consistent which is what matters. This location serves wings. Delivery is fast. My only complaint is that paying cash is cheaper than card, We’re not living in the 90s and I don’t always have wad of cash to pay for modern pizza prices.“

“This tiny spot has a minimal online presence, and not a lot of accessible information besides the number to get some pizza. In investigating local Pizza places around Pittsburgh, I had to ask myself, where does the name Boonda come from?Well, wherever it comes from, it now belongs to a place that makes awesome pizza - and other food.Trying out their stuff, I got Pepperoni Rolls, Garlic Parm Fries, and a large Pepperoni pizza for myself and the family. And a couple other things for another family member.The price was very competitive, and the food great as well.The hand tossed pizza is thin, but not too thin, with a good sauce-cheese ratio. It is definitely a greasy pizza, but not too greasy in my opinion. Then again, I like pizza whether its greasy or not, I just think they're two different tastes. The pepperoni was awesome as well, crisped, flavorful, and ratioed excellently.The pepperoni rolls were also very good. You get a lot of them, and my only constructive criticism is maybe they should come with more sauce. But, they were fresh, had ample crust to them, cheesey, and absolutely loaded with pepperoni. Perhaps a bit zesty for some, but I liked it - along with something unique in the bready flavor of the crust.Last for me were the garlic parm fries, which were some of the best I've had around. Most are often too oily, use overcooked fries, or a combination of both. These ones came fresh, golden, and with the right amount to coat and sit at the bottom of the tray. They softened up for sure in the garlic parm, but still had some crunch to them.Knowing that they are close enough both to pick up myself, and to deliver to my place, I think Boondas will definitely be a regular. It was a rare win from the whole family.“

“thank you for your generosity in giving pizzas for the holidays..God bless“

“Pizza was soooo good! The staff was so nice and the restaurant was clean. Sandi was super nice and didn't get impatient with us when we were figuring out what all we wanted! We will return!“

“Awesome food. Excellent atmosphere. Jackie one of bartenders is very nice and intelligent. 5 Stars“

“We make the 45 min drive to get our pizzas. These are the best pies we have ever had. We love Pizza Lupo!!!“

“First of all I’ve eaten here many times over the years but when you pull in it seems like you’re pulling into a garage area but the food is definitely worth it square cuts with the pepperoni sausage the usual pizza condiments a lot of people like it around here in this area I’m sure you will too. It’s been here since the 50s. It’s a Pittsburgh secret a bit hard to find a little bit out of the way. Old school square cut Sicilian pizza 🍕 The Whole place is contained in a Garage. Very Unique. Go out of your way and Check it out.“

“great food and very friendly service.“

“we just moved to the area and have tried a few local pizza places...they've all sucked! 1. we got so SICK after eating it. 2. the pizza was okay, but the calzone was raw...like more raw dough than cheese!!! 3. just tasted like cardboard. 4. over priced but not atrocious. well tonight I REALLY REALLY wanted good pizza! I contemplated driving an hour and a half to get a pizza from a place that I KNOW is safe! I stead I took the chance with Pasquales. seriously the best pizza I've had in the LONGEST TIME. it was so fast, I honestly expected it to be horrible. but it was delicious! I usually can barely crush 2 pieces...I ate 6.. I do feel sick but that's just because I ate way too much!! the sauce has flavor, it's well seasoned. the crust is buttery and delicious. you can actually TASTE the garlic! they don't skimp on seasoning which is so nice! this is our new go to for pizza!!!“

“I AM VERY PICKY ABOUT MY HOAGIES THEY ARE SO AMAZINGLY GOOD, THE STONE OVEN PIZZA COULD NOT BE BETTER TASTE THERES NOTHING BETTER FOR REAL. THIRD TIME AND WE WILL FOR SURE BE BACK. MANY MORE. LOVE THEM. GREAT JOB. wendy Wendy Denlinger Gallagher“

“We just had a great meal at mama meatballs pizzeria. The owner and his family were great and the pie is a contender for the best pizza in the east Pittsburgh area. Everything but the salad was homemade.“

“Ordered tonight for the first time, everything was delicious! can’t wait to order again!“

“Spirit books some great shows, usually a lot of up-and-coming bands or rave-esque that can't be missed. Pizza is great. The queue gets tedious sometimes; there's been a couple of shows where I've still been waiting to get in while the opener starts. Not sure what the deal is there.“

“This is God's pizza! Pizza by which all others are judged. Pizza all pizzas aspire to yet never achieve. To eat this pizza is to ruin all other pizza on the planet. You will forever hang your head at the thought of another's pizza.“

“Great food :) Fantastic staff!“

“I've been to the Millvale store quite a few times. Just like today. I try something different every time and I'm never disappointed. The flavors of the different menu items are delicious. The staff is always friendly. The one little lady who works there is always so bubbly. If you're looking for something different, something that isn't frozen pizza, or something that feels like comfort food, this is the place. If you haven't tried them yet, I highly recommend paying them a visit.“

“Amazing pizza!!! The slices are gigantic! If you could eat 3 pieces of their pizza, you may need to see a cardio doctor. Well worth checking out! You won’t regret it!“

“So worth the 45min drive“

“Amazing sicilian pizza--delicious garlic-y sauce and crust with perfectly melted cheese. Also, if you're Type A, you'll love the Topping-Slice pricing matrix on the big screen. The prices are so good you'll be leaving happy even if its not your favorite pie, but I'm willing to bet you'll love it. What a gem at the Junction!“

“The best Pizza in Morningside, and one of the best in the Pittsburgh area,“

“We had a wonderful dinner tonight! And enough left for lunch tomorrow.“

“Had their New York style spinach pizza it was the best pizza I ever had. If you’re ever in Pittsburgh, I recommend to stop there and get the spinach pizza.“

“We came in on a Friday night during Lent when most pizza places are hours behind. You could definitely tell that it was busy but our pizza came out perfectly cooked and in a timely manner. Everything was delicious and the staff was very helpful and polite. We most definitely will be returning for dinner or lunch at another time.“

“The food is beyond fabulous. The owner was welcoming and kind. Food was 10/10 - we had a gigantic pizza, wings, gyro, and French fries.“

“Everything is amazing The fresh baked Italian bread is to die for The soups, pizza, hoagie, ravioli all outstanding“

“Food is amazing and they are always friendly, and their delivery is always fast and efficient.“

“The best pizza we have had in Pittsburgh! Had the Italian Hoagie too- delicious! Place was super clean and folks were friendly. Look no further!!“

“Just brought my family on a Monday night . Calzone was excellent as well as the Italian Hoagie. My family was visiting from Michigan and said pizza and sauce is the best . So happy we came here . The owner is super friendly.“

“KATIE MY ONE OF THEE BEST GRILLED CHICKEN SALADS I HAVE HAD IN A LOOOONNNNG TIME !!! DEFINITELY WILL RETURN !!! THANK YOU KATIE ! I just called and thanked you personally!“

“Really good pizza. The crust is fantastic. They always give generous amounts of toppings. I’m a big fan of the spinach and tomato pizza. Wait time for orders are usually around 30 min for pick up, but always hot and fresh. There is no dining in, plenty of parking available.“

“I came here with my dad and got the chicken piccata, which was delicious! It was served with assorted vegetables which I actually liked versus the pasta. We will be back!“

“Efes pizza has incredible delicious food . Tonight, I ordered pizza and Mediterranean dishes for my daughter birthday and everyone absolutely loved the food . Putting Kebab on pizza is such a genius idea :)) The pide, hummus ,Tobuleh and mediterranean salad were all amazing . Everything was prepared hot , fresh and incredibly fast .
Thank you so much to everyone working at Efes . You are definitely our favorite place . I highly recommend it to everyone 👍👏“

“Beat pizzeria in town“

“We had intended to stay and eat our pizza, but my wife dumped her soda all over herself and we took it to go. The restaurant is great, staff was very nice and the pizza was amazing! We will definitely be back again!! While we were there, they bought a homeless man some slices and a drink. The love is in their food and helping others. ❤️❤️❤️“

“We were in town for a baseball tournament and we ordered pizza and wings. Let me tell something. I have tried wings from just about every place I go to and these wings were easily top 3 all time. Cooked perfectly and crispy. The smoked wings were Amazing!!!!! Thank you for the great food and if we’re back in town we will be ordering from you!!!!“

“Yinz gotta try here!! I absolutely adore this pizza shop! Their slice is simply divine. The prices are super fair, and in my humble opinion, they serve oNe of the best Pittsburgh-style pizza I’ve ever had. It’s not that overcooked, crispy cardboard stuff. This slice got this delightful, fluffy, tangy, and sweet sauce with the perfect cheese that still holds its shape like a champion. Zero flop in the fold. And let’s not forget the generous size of the slices - they’re as big as your head! A few months back, a friend from PGH LIVE MUSIC made a post about this place, and I’ve been eagerly waiting to try it ever since. It’s definitely a hidden gem in the world of underrated pizza superstars.“

“They are very nice and helpful. Great asset to the community. The owner is such a nice guy“

“I heard about this place on 100.7 star radio station for their Best Pizza in the Burgh pizza contest. They brought their Gluten Free pizza! So the next day Saturday Feb 7th, we drove from Hopewell twp, Beaver County...1 hour away to try their gluten free pizza. Let me tell you all who read this...it was, by far, THE BEST GLUTEN FREE pizza EVER!! We bought a whole pizza to eat there and bought one to take home AND 2 g.f. bread dough balls. This gluten free pizza is THE BOMB!!!! We need a pizza shop like this out here in Beaver County!!!! The staff was super nice and accommodating! I only wish this place was closer to us cuz we'd be ordering from there every week! Kudos to the owner and his mother who came up with the amazing g.f. pizza dough, its a WINNER!!!“

“Late night eats! Delicious! We got the BBQ chicken pizza and it was perfect to hold us over till breakfast! Great customer service and easy ordering! Will be back!“

“My husband is in the hospital, and wanted me to bring him some pepperoni rolls. I took a chance and had them delivered to my work, so I could take them to him right after I left. Let me tell you, he was lucky to get any!! They were delicious, I couldn’t keep away from them( he did get the major portion) Keep up the great work, great food, wonderful customer service.“

“I order from Fat Angelo's often. The customer service, owner, workers and pies are top tier. I ordered wings for the first time, mmmm wasn't a hit. A bit disappointed. They were dry, hard and tasted refried. I'll stick to the pizzas.“

“food was great. it was our first time. definitely will be back.“

“We were a family of 10 and we came while it was not busy, they sat us immediately our server was great! I think his name was Shaine or something . But he was very attentive and understanding . Our food was great! First time here and definitely will return . Reasonably priced as well“