New York City Pizza
$$ • Pizza, Italian, Gluten-Free
Hours:
45 Pembroke Dr #105, Hilton Head Island
(843) 689-2229
About New York City Pizza
Customers' Favorites
New York City Pizza Reviews
Share your opinion about New York City Pizza
We were told we could use Spinnaker dining coupons and showed the server that we had 3. This was our last night so we wanted to use them all. After we ordered $75 worth of food they proceeded to tell us we could only use one so we got stuck paying $50. That was really poor business and will let everyone we can know. We will not be back.
Timing of food to the table was horrible. Half the table received their food 20 minutes before the other half. Server was not attentive and rude. The pizza was good!
We were in town for a week and on our last night ordered a pizza to our hotel. Wow! I wish we would have known about it before we had to leave. Whoever makes the crust, keep it up! Amazing pie and fast delivery. We had it for breakfast too! Thanks!
Menu
Hours
| Monday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Tuesday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Wednesday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Thursday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Friday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Saturday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Sunday | 11AM - 9PM |
People in Hilton Head Island Also Viewed
New York City Pizza provides a casual dining experience with friendly service from the staff. Known for its flat pizza that you fold over and eat, it remains one of the most popular spots on the island, offering a taste that closely resembles authentic NYC pizza. A must-try is their homemade vinaigrette and delicious cheesecake. The restaurant's inviting atmosphere makes it a favorite for those craving a genuine NYC-style slice. Recent reviews highlight that while the pizza is good, some dishes like stromboli can be bland or overpriced, and some customers found the pizzas greasy or undercooked. The chopped salad often lacks advertised ingredients like olives and is mostly romaine lettuce. The pasta bolognese is noted as pretty good. Many customers enjoy takeout, especially the Buffalo chicken sub, and praise the fast service, with delivery times usually around 20-30 minutes. Overall, it remains a go-to spot for pizza, with some noting the crust and fast delivery as highlights, making it a convenient choice for a quick bite, although some customers have experienced issues with service when dining in.