Although it's not for everyone, my husband and I go for the early dining because we're always traveling and don't want leftovers. The crab filet is great! 4 oz filet but always tender and cooked to order. WG salad and she-crab soup are also delicious. Sharing a crème brûlée flight is the perfect finish.
Adriena
It was not a comfortable dining experience and I must say that I believe race played a factor. Came from Atlanta to celebrate a birthday dinner. The waitress (Hispanic young lady) was avoiding us, never gave us refills, but was going to all the tables around us. We had to remind her numerous times of requests. Pros: Prime Rib Wild Mushrooms Stuffed Mushrooms small plates Bread and Butter Chocolate Mouse in cup (good but a bit salty) Smash Burger and fries Cons: Ribeye (Cold) Onions, cold and the smallest amount for a big price Mashed potatoes (stiff and cold) Baked Potato (not fully cooked) Creamed Spinach (cold) Beet salad, not enough whipped goat cheese and way too many pistachios The waitress seemed to have an attitude because I said my food was cold. It was clear my food was done first (cooked medium) and sat til the rest of my table received well done meat. I boxed up MY WHOLE MEAL and ate something different once I left this establishment. The manager snd owner came over but they both seemed very awkward which is why I never told them I was a food blogger or that I didn't like my food (entree) at all and was very disappointed as STEAK is my favorite food and what I review in every city I visit. I would definitely not return nor recommend to my readers.
Denise
We had such an enjoyable meal at Wise Guys. We had the early bird special and it was wonderful. The absolute best part however was our waiter. I wish I could remember his name but he was kind and efficient and extremely knowledgeable about the courses. He made the dinner as enjoyable as the food itself.
Charlotte
We enjoyed our dinner. The menu selection was broad, and the food was really good. The wine selection was also good. Our server was friendly and helpful, also knowledgeable. 
Wayne
Overall one of my favorite places. Calamari and shrimp appetizer tasted floury, which is not the norm from when we've had it before Staff apologized, but didn't take it off the bill. Everything else was good and up to par
Winealot
Scallops with mushroom risotto was the best I have ever had. Restaurant is cozy and romantic. Service was excellent. We will definitely visit again when we return to Hilton Head in the future.
Gary
First, our server and associates were great. She constantly checked in with us. Brussel sprouts app was delicious, shrimp and calamari was crispy but minimal substance. My NY strip had to much grizzly for the price, wife's pasta meal was great. Creme bulle flight was great and really enjoyed the expresso martinis.
Vincent
We had a good meal. Our server did a nice job of helping the vegan in our party to a really good meal.
Stephanie Hise
Great menu aspirationally but the execution was poor. Salad, entree and bread arrived at the same time. Food was so spicy it could not be eaten ( despite the fact we like spicy food it actually had me coughing). To top it off they didn’t mention a sharing charge but did remove it after we shared concerns. Drinks took a bit and were honestly a bit flat and took a while. For a nicer restaurant overall it was underwhelming.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 2
Marcia
Food was delicious. Service was friendly. Will definitely eat here again for a special occasion!
We come to Hilton Head annually and Wise Guys is a top choice for dining. This time missed the spot a bit. My filet was a bit dry and the shrimp appetizer was lacking sauce. However, the warm Apple crumble with ice cream left us very satisfied at the end of our meal. Service was excellent. We will be back next year.
Brianna Negrete
Great place for a nice dinner especially when celebrating a special occasion. Food was delicious and the service was wonderful. I recommend trying the cheesecake for dessert.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
lori
Delicious food, gorgeous ambiance and warm, friendly and efficient service. We had dined at the bar a few nights before (Amanda is the best!) and enjoyed dinner so much that we came back with some friends that had joined us on our trip! Wiseguys will always be a part of our trips to HHI from now on! We sat at a 4 top in the bar for our second visit and again, everything was perfect. Thank you for a lovely night!
Christine
Our steaks were cooked perfectly, salads are fresh. Thank you Chad and the rest of the staff for great service. We always enjoy dinner at Wiseguys
Phil
We went between 4:00-5:00 for their early bird special menu. The food was excellent. The portions a bit smaller but nothing too crazy with a reduced price. I was very pleased with the value and the service was 5 star
Although it's not for everyone, my husband and I go for the early dining because we're always traveling and don't want leftovers. The crab filet is great! 4 oz filet but always tender and cooked to order. WG salad and she-crab soup are also delicious. Sharing a crème brûlée flight is the perfect finish.
It was not a comfortable dining experience and I must say that I believe race played a factor. Came from Atlanta to celebrate a birthday dinner. The waitress (Hispanic young lady) was avoiding us, never gave us refills, but was going to all the tables around us. We had to remind her numerous times of requests. Pros: Prime Rib Wild Mushrooms Stuffed Mushrooms small plates Bread and Butter Chocolate Mouse in cup (good but a bit salty) Smash Burger and fries Cons: Ribeye (Cold) Onions, cold and the smallest amount for a big price Mashed potatoes (stiff and cold) Baked Potato (not fully cooked) Creamed Spinach (cold) Beet salad, not enough whipped goat cheese and way too many pistachios The waitress seemed to have an attitude because I said my food was cold. It was clear my food was done first (cooked medium) and sat til the rest of my table received well done meat. I boxed up MY WHOLE MEAL and ate something different once I left this establishment. The manager snd owner came over but they both seemed very awkward which is why I never told them I was a food blogger or that I didn't like my food (entree) at all and was very disappointed as STEAK is my favorite food and what I review in every city I visit. I would definitely not return nor recommend to my readers.
We had such an enjoyable meal at Wise Guys. We had the early bird special and it was wonderful. The absolute best part however was our waiter. I wish I could remember his name but he was kind and efficient and extremely knowledgeable about the courses. He made the dinner as enjoyable as the food itself.
We enjoyed our dinner. The menu selection was broad, and the food was really good. The wine selection was also good. Our server was friendly and helpful, also knowledgeable. 
Overall one of my favorite places. Calamari and shrimp appetizer tasted floury, which is not the norm from when we've had it before Staff apologized, but didn't take it off the bill. Everything else was good and up to par
Scallops with mushroom risotto was the best I have ever had. Restaurant is cozy and romantic. Service was excellent. We will definitely visit again when we return to Hilton Head in the future.
First, our server and associates were great. She constantly checked in with us. Brussel sprouts app was delicious, shrimp and calamari was crispy but minimal substance. My NY strip had to much grizzly for the price, wife's pasta meal was great. Creme bulle flight was great and really enjoyed the expresso martinis.
We had a good meal. Our server did a nice job of helping the vegan in our party to a really good meal.
Great menu aspirationally but the execution was poor. Salad, entree and bread arrived at the same time. Food was so spicy it could not be eaten ( despite the fact we like spicy food it actually had me coughing). To top it off they didn’t mention a sharing charge but did remove it after we shared concerns. Drinks took a bit and were honestly a bit flat and took a while. For a nicer restaurant overall it was underwhelming.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 2
Food was delicious. Service was friendly. Will definitely eat here again for a special occasion!
Restaurantji Recommends
We come to Hilton Head annually and Wise Guys is a top choice for dining. This time missed the spot a bit. My filet was a bit dry and the shrimp appetizer was lacking sauce. However, the warm Apple crumble with ice cream left us very satisfied at the end of our meal. Service was excellent. We will be back next year.
Great place for a nice dinner especially when celebrating a special occasion. Food was delicious and the service was wonderful. I recommend trying the cheesecake for dessert.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Delicious food, gorgeous ambiance and warm, friendly and efficient service. We had dined at the bar a few nights before (Amanda is the best!) and enjoyed dinner so much that we came back with some friends that had joined us on our trip! Wiseguys will always be a part of our trips to HHI from now on! We sat at a 4 top in the bar for our second visit and again, everything was perfect. Thank you for a lovely night!
Our steaks were cooked perfectly, salads are fresh. Thank you Chad and the rest of the staff for great service. We always enjoy dinner at Wiseguys
We went between 4:00-5:00 for their early bird special menu. The food was excellent. The portions a bit smaller but nothing too crazy with a reduced price. I was very pleased with the value and the service was 5 star
Loading...