Long Island Cafe

We had a beautiful evening to sit outside and enjoy fresh local shrimp and flounder. From the moment we approached the hostess stand, we were treated like family. Our server, Lynn, was friendly and thoughtful and went above and beyond to serve us. We often eat at Long Island Cafe, and it's always a pleasant experience, but we've seen some great changes lately that are making the experience better. If you haven't been there recently, you'll have to go back for the local shrimp! Definitely order the hushpuppies, and don't forget dessert!

Local and very personal service. Enjoyed so much we made another reservation before leaving.

Food is good. We ate outside so ambience is traffic rolling through parking lot. Noise level is not too bad; might be louder inside.

Excellent food and service, with generous serving sizes (half will be tonight's dinner). Very busy and loud but enjoyable!

We have been customers of Long Island Cafe since it opened many years ago. We have always found their food delicious and all the staff members friendly...until this past weekend. We made our usual reservation for the dining room and not the bar. A waitress tried to seat us in the bar. We asked not to eat in the bar. As we were being seated in the main room, the manager rudely told us that seating location is not guaranteed. Service and food were outstanding as usual. The only thing leaving a bad taste in our mouths was the unwelcoming words from the manager.

Always great food, fresh and prepared as you request. The staff is quick and efficient, I always look forward to a wonderful meal here.
Me and my family have been eating here and enjoying that wonderful food for over a year. I have never been disappointed.

As a New England’er (aka a Yank), you can’t get a better chowder even in the North. Food is fresh, creative and delicious. It’s a hidden gem - don’t let the shopping plaza deter you from enjoying incredible taste for your pallet.

Hit and miss spot. Drinks and calamari were good, salmon served cold and burger was very lame. Not worth the money.

Cafe Style Family Fresh Seafood!

Went on Saturday night when very busy. Our server left a lot to be desired. Ordered appetizers and he forgot to place order, when reordered center was not cooked. Wife not a seafood lover ordered Hamburger to pink to eat. Will probably not go back.

Tasty, and reliably good food/service. Consistently pretty wonderful.

I've been to LI Cafe many times that were wonderful. This time, no so much. Specials not on regular menu were obscenely over priced and we were not on informed before ordering. Also the service was very slow.

Overall a good experience. Service was rushed. Main course served too soon. Still in the middle of soup and salad. Never offered bread. Staff more interested in flipping tables.

Host was not very friendly neither was the server. She seemed to be overwhelmed with het tables.

Always a great meal. Our server, Reed, was attentive and wonderful! One of our favorite places in town.