By The Fire Pizza
$ • Pizza, Food Trucks, Italian Book a table: 7:00 PM 7:15 PM 7:30 PM MoreAbout By The Fire Pizza
Customers' Favorites
Jerk Chicken with Pineapple
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
Spinach Artichoke Pizza
BBQ Chicken Pizza
The 3 Meat Pizza
Brick Oven Bread
Steak and Cheese
Margarita Pizza
Supreme Pizza
Alfredo Fries
By The Fire Pizza Reviews
190 ratings
Share your opinion about By The Fire Pizza
We had the Spinach Artichoke pizza and a cannoli - both were delicious! I'll def go back! The staff was great and service was fast.
There’s alot of pizza restaurants in Columbia but I find myself coming to By the fire pizza a lot more often lately. It’s not only convenient because of the location but the food quality is great! I can tell the pizza is made traditionally and authentic as possible with the Italian brick oven style pizzeria. It’s very peaceful and the atmosphere feels like you can still dress casual, but yet there’s some class to the place. I highly recommend it! 🍕 🥗 🍻
Finally made it to By the Fire Pizza and it was amazing! The place was very welcoming, clean, the bar was beautiful, and the restrooms and everything was new and very well designed! Now to the most important part is the food and it was so delicious, our mozzarella sticks had so many cheese pulls, the Greek salad and the pizza are absolutely the best in Columbia! My husband and I enjoyed the draft Peroni’s and the kids loved the claw machine and Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtle arcade....read full review
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 4 - 9PM |
| Thursday | 4 - 9PM |
| Friday | 12 - 9PM |
| Saturday | 12 - 9PM |
| Sunday | 12 - 9PM |
By The Fire Pizza is a restaurant that has received overwhelmingly positive reviews from its customers. The pizza is described as absolutely delicious, with fresh ingredients and a great crust, especially the Three Meat pizza which is a top favorite. The wings are praised for being cooked perfectly and having an awesome sauce, made in house along with the Strawberry Gellato and cannolis that taste just like New York. The Brick Oven Bread is also amazing. The service is highlighted as friendly, outstanding, and attentive, with smiles and laughs throughout the meal. The atmosphere is quiet and relaxing, with light jazz or classical music playing. While the pizza may not quite match the standards of the best pizza in Connecticut, it is still considered very good for the area, one of the top spots in town, and worth visiting again. Customers also enjoy the cheese pizza and caesar salad, noting the salad has a bit too much dressing for some, but many others love it. The staff and owners are always friendly and nice, creating a warm and cozy environment. The restaurant offers a range of delicious dishes, including pasta with meatballs, which are packed with flavor and clearly handcrafted. The spaghetti sauce is perfectly made, not overly sweet, and the Alfredo fries are really good. Overall, By The Fire Pizza is highly recommended for those seeking great food and a chill vibe, making it a favorite spot for many.