15 Best Italian Restaurants in North Myrtle Beach

“Dylan was exceptional, charming, delightful, explained everything about the menu and made suggestions. Server extraordinaire“

“Our first time after hearing amazing things ! This place did not disappoint , food was amazing ! The French onion soup was excellent, I had the crab stuffed grouper and my husband had the white fish, both were amazing and even though it’s not close to us in Murrells Inlet, WE WILL BE BACK !!!!“

“We had a party of 21 for Christmas party and the place that we had booked it at did not reserve us the right table or room so we left there and on the spur of the moment went to Benny's and not only did they accommodate us super fast they were awesome best Italian food I've ever had in my entire life“

“Highly recommend! Ask for Ashly. She’s amazing !“

“We loved our meals at Rapone's. You feel like family as soon as you walk in the door, but you're treated better than family. Our meals were so good, I forgot to take pics. I'll take them for my next visit because I'll definitely go again.“

“Delicious dinner and lovely atmosphere, cozy and not noisy like most others. This was our second visit… definitely going back. And ask for Olivia and is a terrific server. Just go!“

“4/18/25: “Mama Mia!” Our service was exceptional and our dinners so very delicious. We five family members raved about server Mia. She was delightful, attentive, and strikingly beautiful. Four of us ordered chicken parmigiana that came with garlic knots, crunchy Italian bread, house salads with tasty house dressing, and choice of pasta covered in a sweet and thick marinara sauce. Laura enjoyed her sautéed broccoli rabe and fried calamari. We’ve eaten here a few times and highly recommend this location for its Five Star service and guaranteed delicious Italian food with large portions at reasonable prices. Thank you Mia for being a highlight of our Good Friday visit!😀 - Laura & Mark VanValkenburg, The Bluffs on the Waterway“

“I cannot say enough good things about this restaurant. The owner and his staff are very friendly and always ensure that your food is cooked the way you like it. Customer satisfaction is very important to them. We have had their subs pizza and soups. Everything is reasonably priced. Good size portions and always fresh. I highly recommend stopping by and getting a meal there.“

“My wife had a horrible day of pain, ending up at three different dentist offices, then having her tooth finally pulled. For her post-extraction meal she chose Olive Garden. So let’s get to the point. Could it be the great meal, or the ambience, that keeps us coming back, I mean it is Olive Garden and I never recall complaining about their food or Dining area. OR, is it someone such as our Server, Miss Bella. She was kindhearted, delightful, attentive, and a complete joy to converse with. After a horrible day, the Good Lord sent us this young lady to bring smiles back on our face, and remind us it’s the little things that matter. Olive Garden, this young lady is a great reflection of what this world is missing. She represented Olive Garden very well. It was our pleasure, to have been served by such a sweet hearted person such as Miss Bella. To Miss Bella, if by chance you are reading this, Thank you. You made a bad day end with smiles, a lot of smiles.“

“Amazing food and amazing service. So glad we came here for our anniversary!“

“I just wanna say thank you to these guys for giving me and my family a delicious and affordable experience every time we come here. The owner is just the nicest guy ever and the waiters were very patient and fast with the service. Thank you guys! We will be back!“

“I got an Eggplant Parmigiana sandwich and it was delicious. While I was waiting a fresh Pizza came out so I had to try it. Again I was fantastic. I’m going back tomorrow for some more good food!!!“

“Steak & mushroom toasted with creamy Italian sauce, fried zucchini, tenders and pizza were all amazing today! Fast and efficient service and is now a new family fave. Glad our friends recommended us to try!“

“They have absolutely the best lasagna I have ever eaten!“

“We come to Benitos every year and the food is always delicious and the service is always excellent! We will be coming back next year!“