8 Best Mexican Restaurants near Bethpage

“Amazing amazing amazing, I was out here working and decided to try, from the looks of it you would expect negative thoughts but the lady who took my order was beyond friendly, walking me through the menu and recommending me her favorite which she did , told her to order for me, I got 2 big tacos FILLED FILLED with chicken and some amazing beef idk the name, the rice was the softest and best I had, and the beans which I hate were actually great! Her son maybe 10 works the register and has better customer service skills then most people it was amazing!!! Definitely a hidden gem!!!“

“Best Mexican food I've found yet. Chips are always warm and never over oily, vegetables for the Pico are always fresh, and the service is fast and helpful. Dining area is clean and bright/lively. Personal favorite dishes are the mini chimis, chicken chimichanga, and taco salad. Also the price of the food is awesome too.“

“Atmosphere: 5 starsFirst thing I noticed was the furniture. They have the same furniture as Hartsville Taco Co in Hartsville.Food: 4 starsChips & Salsa: Chips were warm and fresh. Salsa was great.Mexican Chicken Soup: Great and lots of chicken.Enchiladas: Warning, they use “cheese sauce” not real shredded cheese. The chicken enchilada was good. The “steak” enchilada was good but the “steak” had almost a hamburger consistency.Tacos: Shredded chicken tacos were okay. The chicken was very wet which made the taco shells soggy.Service: 5 starsOur server was very attentive.“

“First time trying this restaurant. Dinner was delicious and the waitstaff and manager were all very kind!! I had a great time and really enjoyed the experience. I got a chimichanga on the house which was so sweet! I highly recommend and will be back!“

“If you've decided you just want Mexican, this is a good option. The menu is familiar, their food is fresh and hot, and the wait time is reasonable. Polite staff, relaxed atmosphere, it is sometimes a bit crowded around dinner time but I haven't had to wait for seating.“

“Food was amazing. Great taste and it was cooked just right. The service was really on point. Chevo was our server and he gave us the best service I’ve ever had in a Mexican style restaurant. It is very inexpensive and you will not even be able to finish the food. It was so much.. will definitely come back..“

“I love this restaurant more than most other restaurants around. But lately the management has been over seating the restaurant for the amount of employees they have - and it is not fair. You can’t put two waitresses covering an ENTIRE restaurant while also being their own bartenders. Garcias almost always has 10/10 quality control on cocktails and food, but you can’t maintain that when you put too many people in a restaurant for your employees to serve. They’re only people, not Gods. When we went in last our poor server was running around like a mad woman while being treated poorly by customers because she couldn’t keep up. Most likely being tipped poorly on top. We didn’t get drinks for 25 minutes and it was not her fault. Not fair. I will keep coming back to Garcias because it’s my fav but yall - STOP over seating your staff! People can wait or go somewhere else!“

“If you’re looking for an authentic Mexican food truck this is the one. How many food trucks carry tamales on their menu?! The food is of great quality, made to order fresh and of hearty portions. The steak tacos are flavorful. Recently I had my tamale fix and will be returning soon for a steak torta.“