NY Pie (Nashville West)

Best NY Pizza in Nashville. Friendly service and quick

Ate lunch here for the first time today. We lived in NYC in the early 2000s and this is our first pizza experience in Nashville that felt kind of close to NYC.

The crust is fantastic, toppings are excellent.

The one down side was that we paid for soft drinks and most of the drinks in the machine were messed up. No Diet Coke, Coke, Dr Pepper, Root Beer, etc. It would have been nice for them to tell us that when we paid and we would have just gotten water. Our table was right by the drink machine and we watched every customer try to get drinks and then taste them and dump them out like we did.

Other than that issue, great pizza!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

One of the best pizza in Nashville. Must try. Will definitely order again. Order half of Margherita and other half of Garlic chicken. Both taste great. 👍

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Would rate 10 stars if I could! Honestly the best pizza I’ve ever had. I got half NY cheese and half margherita and it was so delicious and full of flavor. Fast, friendly service and chill atmosphere with great music! Absolutely recommend!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Best pizza around me

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The best. Scratches the itch completely for NY slices!

Food was fresh and delicious. Barely any wait time after we ordered.

Great pizza

The dirtiest I have ever seen this place. Shakers were empty. Napkins were out.

Best pizza in Nashville hands down!

I have a severe alpha gal allergy and can’t have any mammal products and worry a lot about surprise ingredients and cross contamination. Previous to getting sick I ate there often and loved the hospitality, polite staff and amazing pizza. Today I went and expressed my desire to still have there pizza and ask for accommodation. They assured me they would wash everything and prevent cross contamination. They treated me with kindness and respect and made me feel very assured. I was excited to see they offered anchovies and that is a protein I can eat and really enjoyed it. These guys are great. Long story short 10/10. Please eat here

I Go In and one of the Employees already know me by my name as soon as they take a look at me lol. He’s cool and the pizza here is absolutely great. I’m From NYC and this hits damn near home for me. Thank you for bringing me back home every time I come here. Always worth the trip!

I almost never write reviews but I HAVE to for NY Pie. I’ve been missing pizza from NJ/ NY since moving here for college and I couldn’t be happier I found this place! Super kind staff, tons of options in the front if you’re looking to grab a quick slice, and they get pies are in and out of the oven super quick. I’m so glad to have found a taste of home here and I can’t wait to bring my family! You guys are the best!

Pizza slice was ..not bad
But,the garlic knots 🫣those I am sure was missing something..those don't have butter,garlic or Parmesan was just the bread ...and then the power go off 🙀📴

TLDR: Delicious, authentic taste of NY pizza. I found my new favorite spot.

I grew up in NJ and always have had a hard time finding pizza even close to as good since moving away. Tried this place on a whim and was blown away. The crust is perfect. Crispy but also soft inside. The sauce and cheese were great too. They sell whole pies as well as a bunch of different kinds by the slice. The employees were friendly. It was a Saturday night and very busy with lots of orders. But even with a wait it was definitely worth it. My new favorite pizza place. Thanks!