Bennigan's
$ • American, Irish Pub, New American
Hours:
603 West, I-20, Monahans
(432) 251-6236
About Bennigan's
Customers' Favorites
Bennigan's Reviews
Share your opinion about Bennigan's
Last time I came here I ordered the passion fruit glazed pork chops. What I got was over cooked, dried out, thin, unseasoned chops with a small ketchup tub of what I presume was the glaze.
This time I ordered a burger. Never asked how I like it cooked. It came out dry, way over cooked to the point it was flavorless.
I got a drink when I was seated, after I finished it, I waited 20 minutes before going to the bar to get a refill. Finally the food came out and it was...read full review
Service was so awful. Waitress didn’t put in the order correctly and every persons order was wrong and she looked at us like we were stupid when she’s the one who messed it up. Even told us “ oh I put that in wrong with the order…”. Food took forever and there was no one in the restaurant. The check was messed up because she charged wrong and as we waited for her to fix it, she stood there talking to other waitresses and laughing. Just really disappointed overall....read full review
Had a great time! Appreciated the service from our waiter, Jordin. The food and dessert were delicious. Would recommend everyone I know to eat there. We had a wonderful experience all around.
Ratings
Menu
Hours
| Monday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Tuesday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Wednesday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Thursday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Friday | 11AM - 11PM |
| Saturday | 11AM - 11PM |
| Sunday | 11AM - 10PM |
People in Monahans Also Viewed
Bennigan's offers wonderful food and great service in a cozy, inviting atmosphere that combines comfort and nostalgia. The restaurant has a classic pub feel, making it a great spot for a casual lunch or a laid-back dinner with friends. The new Chicken fried steak on the menu is very good, and the bread pudding dessert is a must-try. Recent reviews note that the food is served hot and that dishes like the famous Monte Cristo and Kilkenny’s Country Chicken Wrap are flavorful and generous in portion. However, some customers have experienced long wait times for food and inattentive waitstaff, with instances of servers socializing instead of taking care of diners. While the restaurant's floor cleanliness could be improved, there are positive mentions of exceptional service from certain staff members, indicating that the dining experience can be pleasant. Drinks are often refilled promptly, and food comes out fresh without a long wait. Overall, while Bennigan's has potential, consistency in service needs attention to ensure a better experience for all guests. It’s not trying to be overly trendy—it’s just consistently delicious, well-priced, and welcoming.