15 Best Italian Restaurants near San Juan

“Best Italian food I’ve had in a long time! Great prices and great customer service!“

“Absolutely wonderful dining experience at Olive Garden in San Juan! The food was fresh, flavorful, and served hot. The pasta was perfectly cooked, the sauces were rich and delicious, and the unlimited breadsticks and salad never disappoint.
The staff was friendly, attentive, and made sure everything was just right throughout the meal. The restaurant is clean, comfortable, and has a warm, welcoming atmosphere. Highly recommend this location for a great Italian meal with family and friends!“

“Great dinner! Meatball appetizer was delicious and the knots. Fettuccine Alfredo has good flavor. My wife had the Cheese manicotti and it was superb! Service was great!“

“After being discharged from the hospital, I stopped at Olive Garden 222 W Highway 83 McAllen and had an amazing experience. Despite not being dressed appropriately, I was treated with kindness and respect. The atmosphere was welcoming, and the server was attentive and compassionate, even offering assistance when needed. This was one of the best service experiences I have ever had not to mention the food service was amazing too.“

“Milano's is another hidden gem. The wife and I are valley natives and have never been here. We thought we'd give it a shot on date night and ended up having the place all to ourselves. We stopped in on a Friday afternoon around 6:00. Walking in you can tell this restaurant has been around for quite some time but is maintained and kept at its original theme. We were greeted immediately and seated immediately to our preference. We started off with an appetizer which we try not to do but our willpower wasn't doing so great today. They started us off with some fresh bread with the herb herb and garlic oil that is usually served with it. Then we requested the calamari which was well served, well battered, nice and hot. After a careful review of the menu we decided to order something that we were familiar with in order to compare with other locations. My wife ordered the tour of Italy which came with alfredo, chicken parm and lasagna. I ordered the pasta casino. My entree was a pick your own pasta so I picked angel hair and then the rest was whatever the recipe was. It was not bad at all and had great flavor but could have used a little more of the sauce. The wife's tour of Italy was okay as well. She stated the chicken parm cutlet was hot, was fresh and tasted alright. Her Alfredo had good flavor but lacked a little more sauce. The most surprising was the lasagna. The presentation was very disappointing but the flavor was actually very good. Again as I mentioned we were trying to compare the foods that were familiar with with others and the lasagna is a big one because it is usually layered this one wasn't so much. It was surprisingly tasty though. All the food was fresh, portions were so so and entrees took a bit getting out so I'm assuming everything was cooked to order. That's definitely not a bad thing. The service was okay, we didn't get very much attention and occasionally waited to have our drinks refilled. It could have been worse but could have been better because they didn't have much of a crowd. I did enjoy the decor. They have different sections with different Italian themes. This would have been a much better visit had we not been fighting off a fly the entire time. I think I was able to kill it towards the end of our meal. All in all it was an okay visit and the wife and I enjoyed each other's company in the quiet setting with light Italian music playing in the background.“

“I love this Italian restaurant. A little pricey but food portions are so generous, fresh and delicious. Their bread needs a revisit. It does not match the rest of the menu for flavor or freshness. I have several favorites but love the Pancetta Carbonara.“

“Listen y’all if you want the best coffee in town come to 7 brew!!! I love how polite and happy they always are and they always make my morning brighter! Thanks guys!“

“Went Mon. Evening to take advantage of BOGO Mom's meatballs & spaghetti special. We noticed wine bottles were 50% OFF & all 3 couples decided to order 1 bottle of wine each couple. We were shocked when Mario, Assist. Mgr., informed us we couldn't order under both of the specials. We told him we didn't see that indicated for wine special. He told us he would allow it this time. We were flabbergasted. Thankfully, our server, Oden provided great service & our meals & hot bread were EXCELLENT!“

“Last night we had dinner. First we got there without reservation and the smiley hostess asked us if we wanted to sit on the bar, we said yes. The bar tender is a great guy, he works like crazy, smiling and taking care of business and customers. The food took a little long to come but it was delicious, we had Alfredo pasta and lasagna, both great taste. At the end tiramisu to go, it was really good. Clean, friendly and tasty place, We’ll go again!!!!“

“I wanted to write a review to acknowledge our waitress Victoria! She is the sweetest waitress I've ever had. You can tell she loves her job and if she doesn't, you would not be able to tell haha. She was very patience with our indecisiveness as well as our kids. Hopefully she's promoted one day. Treat her well!“

“Muy buena comida, pizza, pastas y ensaldas deliciosas, los postres necesitan mejorar mucho“

“Tried this pizza for the first time today, so freaking good. Thin New York style pizza, I like to throw mine on the stove top for an extra crisp bite, they are my new go-to pizza joint. Dominos just lost a customer lol.“

““Best stromboli in town”. Ok, I’ll be the judge of that.

Great cozy atmosphere. Really top notch. Stromboli was big and great crispy dough. Good service. Reasonable prices. I even got dessert. 4.4/10, but this could be raised once I try the pizza“

“Está rico y tienen buena atención felicidades muy pocos negocios cono este.“

“This was my first time visiting and I'm so happy I did. The food was fresh and delicious. The restaurant was very clean and service was fast. Everyone was very courteous and welcoming.
The atmosphere was very relaxed and cozy.
I will definitely be back soon!“