32 Best Bakeries near Selma

“great service! 👍 staff is always so helpful!!!“

“Strawberry shortcake was excellent. Customer service not so great as workers were gossiping as I walked in, was not greeted and essentially waited for them to be done to get my order. Two of the workers were actually working while a third girl was standing doing nothing and talking to the other workers. I was also the only customer in the store at the time. Overall great cake not so great service.“

“What can I say. I am impressed with Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop. I live out of town currently and I ordered a pie for delivery online and I messed up not only the delivery time but forgot to add a note for the recipient. Completely my mistake. I called the store and Katie answered the phone, actually she answered every time I called (3 total LOL) I received a happy greeting and Katie was delighted to help me correct my mistake. She made me feel like a friend, not just a customer, and I truly appreciated all the help! Definitely recommend. Thank You Katie!“

“everything here is freakin delicious“

“I've been trying to stop in since the grand opening. The stars aligned today, finally, and I was able to check the bakery out. I decided on a Tomato Basil scone, a brown butter chocolate chip cookie, and, thanks to Heather helping me narrow it down, a loaf of asiago & pepper. The scone did not last the 5 minute drive home. The cookie was warmed in the microwave for maybe 10 seconds and then devoured. These will be the things I crave when the bakery is closed! Just phenomenal! NOW....a little different review. Heather is the SWEETEST human ever. She let this adult-conversation starved SAHM just ramble on about nothing and everything. And, you know how you can just tell when someone is humoring you (for the business) and will immediately call their significant other to tell them about the super weird lady who wouldn't shut up and looked like death warmed over? That is not Heather! Such a sweet human and I wish her nothing but success for many, many years!!“

“The Williams cook and bake with love, and you can taste it in everything they make! It’s a little out of the way for many, but their delicious, homemade fare and kind, caring service always makes it worth the effort to go eat there.“

“Truly an amazing establishment that support their community with fabulous food! Words cannot express how grateful I am and so blessed that you care! 🤗“

“I have been taking Crumbl to all my clients for almost a year now and have been visiting this store the whole time. I have gone to other stores in San Antonio & Kyle and I shared with the team there in New Braunfels that I will ONLY go to them. Not only are you greeted with big beautiful smiles and warm welcomes, but they truly care about their product. Amanda is an absolutely sweet person and I love being able to work with her team in a way, being that they know my face and name now!“

“Best customer service I’ve been very pleased with the service I get at every visit very friendly lady that is always happy and fresh hot pretzels“

“For several years I have purchased cheesecakes from the bakery for my youngest daughter’s birthday. She loves the taste of the Old Fashioned original cheesecake. The storefront is a no frills no nonsense setting. This is because the bakery is a commercial operation. They supply their tasty treats to numerous restaurants in the San Antonio and Austin area, but they make time to serve the private customer as well. Just understand that they are a commercial operation. But believe me when I say the tasty treats are worth the trip over into the business park where they are located.“

“Chef Amber does a great job listening to her client’s requests and any allergy concerns. Her baked goods look good and taste great. Orders are always on time for pickup or delivery.“

“It's a nice place, but if I drop into a neighborhood (or any) coffee shop on a Sat a.m. I expect a Sat a.m. "coffee atmosphere" - quiet, laid-back. Suddenly in comes a bunch of pre-teens, cackling and shouting. Too many parents make the mistake of assuming that we all want to see and hear their kids: teach them to recognize and respect quiet. Otherwise, as I said, a nice and convenient spot with a good selection for coffee and low-dB conversation.“

“My daughter's cake was so beautiful! The flowers looked so REAL, the cake was moist and the flavor was delicious! And it was all from scratch! Simply Amazing!! The customer service is Top Notch too! I will definitely be a repeat customer!“

“We love this place! The donuts are always fresh and they have so much to choose from. Staff is very friendly!“

“The lady that runs this location is awesome. She is always very friendly. The have the best boudan kolaches.“

“Yes, I would recommend them, but they lost me as a customer on Monday. A couple of weeks ago, I was having a baker's crisis. I had a particular order for a cake, and I could not remember where my cake pans were because our shop typically specializes in cupcakes, so I went to an over-the-top cake shop to get some cake pans. Before I purchased them, I asked the young lady if I could return them because I might not need them if I found mine. She said yes, so I went ahead with the purchase. Luckily, I was able to find my pans. So, on Monday, I went back to the over-the-top cake shop to try to return them. Before looking inside the bag, the lady behind the counter told me loudly, "Oh no, we will not take any returns." I honestly thought she was joking with me at first. LOL, but it turns out she was not. She proceeded to show me the receipt that clearly stated all sales are final. I apologized and told her. Unfortunately, I did not look at the receipt because I asked and took the young lady at her word. She asked me for the young lady's name, and I said I did not get her name because I did not assume she would give me the wrong information. I said, okay, I understand, and shame on me for not getting the details. But is there a way I can get a store credit since I buy most of my supplies there? Without hesitation, she said we won't do that either. I struggled with that because these were unused cake pans, and the labels remained intact. They have cake pans on shelves that they could have quickly restocked. I struggled because I bet many small businesses or self-employed bakers purchase our supplies there, and most of us do not have the luxury of spending money unnecessarily. At this point, it is not about the pans but the principle. Again, I understand their position if the items had been opened or used. Today, most reputable businesses have a return policy and not a Gotcha practice. So, I will return to ordering my supplies from Amazon, which is much more convenient for me. I would like to support local businesses if possible. But not when that support is not reciprocated. So buyers, beware!“

“LOVE the gooey butter cake! Reminds me of cakes we would get growing up from St. Louis. Wow, so yummy!!!“

“Small shop, but excellent service and quality.“

“If I could give Steve more than 5 stars, I absolutely would.

Steve is not just a baker—he’s a baking legend here in New Braunfels, Texas. His sourdough is beyond amazing, but that’s just the beginning. The blueberry scones? Absolutely to die for—light, flavorful, and perfectly baked. And those sausage-stuffed rolls (kolaches, I finally remembered the name!) are warm, savory perfection.

But what truly sets Steve apart is the heart he puts into everything. When I was preparing a post-wedding brunch for my son, Steve made fresh bagels on his day off—just for us. Then, he personally delivered them so they’d be hot and fresh for the big day. Who does that?! Steve does.

From start to finish, everything was effortless—ordering, payment, and the incredible service. Steve went above and beyond in every way.

Thank you again, Steve! 🙌“

“Used them for a teacher luncheon and they delivered to our school. The elevator was broken and the two ladies carried trays and huge coolers up 2 high flights of stairs at least 7 times up and down. I get exhausted going up once. They had the most pleasant attitude.The food was delicious and the presentation of the trays and warmers was perfect! The next day they came out and picked everything up. Thank you Liz and ladies for your excellent food and service. Will definitely call you guys again!!! I'll make sure the elevator is working! 😉“

“the food was impeccable and so was the service. we were given extra special service to our blind community that went there to eat. they were very patient, friendly and very efficient. it was my first visit there and I definitely will go back again! kudos to all the employees that make that restaurant special!👍👍😊“

“Delicious and BEST cookies ever!! ♥️“

“These cupcakes are the best! Especially the chocolate cupcakes. They are moist and delicious!!! The salted caramel should not be passed up either. They are moist, fluffy, and loaded with salted caramel flavor!“

“Consistently delicious and fresh“

“For our Anniversary in 2022, my wife and I decided we wanted to get a cake to celebrate. We both like old-fashioned butter-creme icing, and not that new light, marshmallow-ish stuff that bakeries put on cakes today. We wanted a layer-cake with thick butter-creme filling, as well as icing on the outside. Emily's Cakes came through for us. The cake we got was more than expected and was absolutely delicious! We're planning to order another one this year, if we haven't waited too late. We need it by Sunday of next week 7/14/24. Is that even possible?“

“They did custom cookies for my wedding that were a huge hit! Thank you so much for helping me add a personal touch to our big day. The guests ate them all before I could get a good picture which is always a good sign. They were cute and delicious.“

“I was in bed last night and heard a strange noise coming from the kitchen. Walked in to find my dogs scratching their way into the Bark Avenue Bakery treats! They love them. They wake up in the morning and lay down next to the pantry waiting for their treat. By far the best treats out there and by the way my dogs are acting, we can tell they think the same!“

“I found Little Muse while looking for a catering company for my friends’ 50th birthday party. I knew I needed a cocktail hour treat, dinner and a cake. Little did I know I would find all of that with Little Muse. They provided the most delicious food from start to finish. The setup and and attention to detail was amazing. Their warm and calm demeanor was a blessing at the event. Everyone loved the food. I could not have asked for better. Thank you so much Little Muse and I would love to hire you again one day!“