“I moved to the area in fall 2023 and this was the first or second place in Broadway my now wife and I got food from. I've ordered from here maybe 4 times so far and every time it's been great! The staff is always friendly and it seems pretty clean in there.The most recent experience was on Valentine's Day. I was looking for something in particular and didn't see what I was looking for on the app so I called the store. I don't remember the associate saying her name but she was very friendly! I had a special request that required me calling in the order and that associate as well as the one who waited on me when I went to pick up my order were also friendly!Every time I've ordered the associates have been friendly and the food has always tasted great!“
“Great pizza & dessert pizza too.... Very big pizza pies with flaky buttery crust, very heavy/filling/pizza...they have JUMBO SIZES TOO! We always have plenty of leftovers to eat off of for the next few days!Vegetarian options: They have a great veggie pie except the mushrooms from a jar, don't prefer that kind of mushroom“
“We have ordered many times from this place and diff times of the day, morning to past 10pm. Their food is tasty, well prepped, lots of toppings on the pizzas and yummy garlic sauce. We love their friendly and super efficient staff.They always make an effort to wow us, either with free sauce or dips, or walking out the store to deliver carry out items with big smiles and appreciation. Try out their food and tip them well because they're fantastic!“
“An awesome experience, like it has been for the last 25+ years that I can even remember! The service is excellent, the pizza is hot and fresh, and the pricing is beyond reasonable. I tend to forget about this place, so I will make sure to remind myself that we have such an amazing pizza parlor right in Timberville!“
“Thoroughly enjoyed my quick stop here on my road trip! Pleased to say this I haven’t had a pizza this good in forever- and that means a lot to me.The gentleman was so kind and helpful as well.Loved the ambience of the restaurant.Will definitely be coming here again!“
“Godfathers is my fave....having grown up in Omaha in the 1980's!! Finding this Godfather's...just off I-81 on my way back to the DC Metro area has been wonderful. I called in my order about 40 miles south of New Market and the pizzas were waiting for me as I walked in, perfectly made, just like I remember from my teenage years!!“
“I came from Ohio just to try this place... not really, just visiting friends. ?I do look forward to coming here on my next visit though!The pepperoni pizza with hot honey was absolutely amazing! I tried making one like it at home and it sucked... so try theirs... it's better than you can imagine!The Ax throwing was surprisingly simple and just a lot of fun.We had a bunch of other food we really enjoyed, but their beer menu was good enough that remembering details is a bit blurry... except for that hot honey pizza, that was awesome!Kid-friendliness: Kid's are allowed... but I wouldn't recommend bringing more kids than adults“