12 Best Italian Restaurants near Fishersville

“The food would be 5 stars if they didn't use marveled rye cuz it has fennel in it and I hate fennel. Other than that everything was phenomenal. Food was delicious. We made a mistake and had to correct on the fly. The staff at the front was young and they were so patient with dumbness. It paired wonderful with the wine at barren ridge down the road.“

“One of the best in Stuart's Draft. We got meals to go - 100 year old Mum and her 98 year old sister can't get up out of restaurant chairs. We got what auntie recommended and it was great. Thanks Salzone's for accommodating our special requests.Dietary restrictions: Mum doesn't like American cheese and they were happy to substitute another cheese!“

“A very nice local Italian restaurant! We stopped by when visiting family. I had the Soprano Burger and thought it was pretty good! My husband got the chicken Calabrese. He thought it was good as well, as did I. Melissa was great. She was able to take care of us along with a couple of other tables plus order pickups with no issue. Highly recommend this place!“

“Eat here at least one a month while in the Staunton area...The world's largest antique mall, and I mean the largest, is located less than a half mile away...You can spend all day here but plan on at least two hours to walk all the "streets."“

“I've NEVER had a bad meal from here. Always fresh. Fast delivery times & always friendly.Great people, great food with a homemade taste. Calzones are to die for!! Subs are top-notch & pizzas are way better then chain pizza restaurants.Thanks! - from a satisfied customer ?“

“Waitress was kind, attentive, offered refills. Bread was warm and crispy. Alfredo was creamy, but it needed a lot of salt, there wasn't much cheese flavor or hints of garlic (minus one star). Fettuccine was perfectly aldente. The sausage had a good fennel flavor but was in a casing like a brat. The tiramisu was perfect, absolutely perfect. There are several dessert options. There was no one else in the restaurant at 530pm. ?‍♀️ By the time I left, there were 3 tables seated and there had been several to-go pickup orders.“

“Best Pizza in Staunton. If you go to the restaurant the service is great, and it has a full menu for your Italian urges. The effort goes into the food not the building, so it is not what I would call fancy, but it is clean and comfortable. They will deliver whatever is on the menu, and I have often ordered 12-15 large pizzas with no issues“

“Big fan of this local spot! Pizza is excellent! Cheesy bread is a fav! Staff is always friendly and attentive. Cool vibes, great ambience! Love when they have local musicians entertaining the crowd! Owner is usually walking around and checking on guests. They regularly support local non-profits! Good people, good place!“

“I never bother to leave reviews, if I like the place I like it, I’d I don’t I don’t. The bite(s) I had of my girlfriend’s penne alla vodka was immaculate; quite possibly the best I’ve ever had. My pizza steak wasn’t as packed with meats as I would’ve preferred but the flavor was simply incredible.“

“We went with a larger party and everyone enjoyed their meals.The angel hair pasta circles were by far the group's favorite. The greek salad and panini's were well received. The margherita pizza didn't seem to quite match the level of the rest of the meals. It wasn't bad, just not outstanding.“

“I do love this place it is one of my go too. Few issues the wings man always over cooked always .. the wooden bench seats are awful ..other than that the food is great sometimes and good anthor but it's always good . Love the pizza . The ppl are alwaysgreat to me love the staff please make cheese bread .“

“Food-The sub was the bomb! No gristle, gristly (did I spell that right?) pieces!! I asked for the cheese steak hoagie without the cheese, add lettuce, tomato and light mayo. That was delicious!!Service- the lady that answered the phone was awesome! Kind & courtesy!Atmosphere- needs a major overhaul! Meaning it was decorated by the original owner in 199something....“