10 Best Pizza Restaurants near Marshall

“We moved to the area 2 months ago and have been ordering a lot while we remodel. And I'm so happy they are the local pizza shop! The pizza is great, fresh breadsticks are pillowy soft. And my favorite thing is they follow special requests everytime. We are always asking for extra sauces with our orders. Some places act like giving you sauce will shut them down- even if you offer to pay for it. Anthony's has followed through every time and that's enough to keep me ordering! We are a sauce eating household and to actually find a place that will give you extra if you ask is rare! Loving this little pizza shop!

Update** still love this place! We have now become regulars of their garlic parmesan wings. Best around!“

“The food is very good. But my review is more about their hospitality. They r very polite on the phone. And they are one of the few that deliver. My husband does dialysis and is wiped out on these days I don't drive so for them to deliver is very much appreciated. Thank you so much!!!“

“Great pizza and friendly staff! Ask for Jarad, he likes to talk about crochet!“

“Love Teddys Pizza and of course the overall environment of the restaurant complete with great conversation, live in Winchester and drive 30-40 minutes. We typically get a large White "Caucasian Pie" with pepperoni - so so good! Remember it's, Life is like a box of chocolates - NOT was!“

“This was our first visit, and will be returning! The service was amazing, and the food was delicious! Everyone was so friendly, really happy with our experience!“

“Ordered takeout and this pizza is delicious! Prompt friendly service and a variety of options. My personal opinion, the best pizza place in the Canaan valley area.“

“Love the hot honey wings but definitely would have been better if I hadn't drove all the way back home to realize that my extra hot honey sauce wasn't in my bag :( too far to drive back but definitely will be making sure it's in there next time or just wait until we can eat at the restaurant again so I can fully enjoy my wings.“

“As a Mom who can’t keep her stuff together half the time with many feral sweet kids, PJs has always been a winner. This location here in Warrenton constantly gives the extra care and makes sure I am where I say I am. If they thought pool was closed they’ve called to make sure I was there and not home location. Visa versa as well! They have made sure to consistently deliver to the correct place and on top of that have been kind and have always gotten our order right or made sure to correct it in n appropriate way. Mistakes happen and it’s always been ok! We made Warrenton our forever home and of all the locations and states and cities and decades ordering Papa John’s, this location by far is the best. This review isn’t for a recent order either. It’s the cumulative experiences and me realizing I needed to share my good experiences. Thanks for helping this Mom out and making our days easier!“

“We called 5 different pizza delivery places and all of them denied our requests and thought we were prank callers just because we laughed a little but this one Jeremy I think it was his name. Best service took only 30 seconds with our service and got our job done. Best service. Thank you.“

“This restaurant needs to do a better job at checking their to-go/delivery orders. From my experience, there are almost always errors. Today I received regular pizza bites vs the buffalo chicken ones and I had to completely unwrap my chicken Caesar wrap to eat it because the wrapper itself was wrapped into the sandwich. Clearly they were in a rush. Food is good, but wish quality control was better.“