9 Best Pizza Restaurants near Marshall

“As someone who grew up in Jersey I literally go out of my way to come here. It’s the only good pizza I’ve found down here and I’ve tried everywhere. I mean everywhere. The staff is always friendly and the Pizza is the best I’ve found around here.“

“Did a large delivery order of wings for work, everything fresh, hot, well packaged and great!!“

“Great pizza and friendly staff! Ask for Jarad, he likes to talk about crochet!“

“This was our first visit, and will be returning! The service was amazing, and the food was delicious! Everyone was so friendly, really happy with our experience!“

“Love Teddys Pizza and of course the overall environment of the restaurant complete with great conversation, live in Winchester and drive 30-40 minutes. We typically get a large White "Caucasian Pie" with pepperoni - so so good! Remember it's, Life is like a box of chocolates - NOT was!“

“Love the hot honey wings but definitely would have been better if I hadn't drove all the way back home to realize that my extra hot honey sauce wasn't in my bag :( too far to drive back but definitely will be making sure it's in there next time or just wait until we can eat at the restaurant again so I can fully enjoy my wings.“

“Ordered takeout and this pizza is delicious! Prompt friendly service and a variety of options. My personal opinion, the best pizza place in the Canaan valley area.“

“I walked in there and I didn't know what I was ordering at all. I spoke to a nice kind young man named Harold and he got me right. He was very kind and professional and he made me feel very welcomed. Harold hands down was the best worker there“

“My family and I have visited this Manhattan Pizza location a few times now, making the ~25-minute drive from Culpeper. One of the main reasons is that, in our opinion, Culpeper is desperate for more strong local pizza options that consistently deliver on food, service, and overall experience. We’re big fans of Tony’s NY Pizza in Northern Virginia, and while we wish we had something comparable closer to home, Manhattan Pizza has been the closest option for us and it’s delivered on that expectation during our visits.

From what we’ve seen, service can vary a bit depending on the day, which some other reviews have mentioned as well. At times, the staff at the counter have come across as less engaged, but on our recent visits, the staff member who brought our pizza out to the table was very kind and helpful, checking in and letting us know they were available if we needed anything. Most of our experience here has been focused on dining in rather than extended interaction at the counter.

The pizza itself is really where this place stands out. In our experience, it’s well-balanced. It's not overly greasy, it has a good amount of cheese and sauce, and it's always full of flavor. One extra-large pizza has been more than enough to feed our family of four, and the pricing has felt reasonable for the quality and portion size. That’s ultimately what keeps us coming back and making the drive on a Friday night.

The location itself is nice and generally well-kept for a pizza spot. One thing that stands out is the decorative brick wall featuring the “Lunch atop a Skyscraper” photo, which gives the place a bit of a rustic, classic feel.

Overall, it’s just really good pizza. The place was packed on the evenings we visited, which says a lot about how the local community feels about it. When we don’t feel like making the longer trip into Northern Virginia, this has become our go-to option that’s closer to Culpeper for a solid pizza night.

Thanks!“