The Upper Crust

$ •

4 N Pendleton St, Middleburg
(540) 687-5666


Take-Out/Delivery Options


Reviews for The Upper Crust

I love the pies at upper crust but am so frustrated with trying to place an order. I’ve been calling for 2 days & no answer. I’m trying to order 5 pies & live an hour away so I can’t stop in. Does anyone know how I can reach them??I was able to get through...they were closed for a week for cleaning. Once again - delicious pies!

This place had so many good reviews we were really excited to try it. Not sure if we came on a bad day but we were pretty disappointed with most of what we purchased. The ice cream was extremely grainy, very bizarre texture. The cookies on the ice cream sandwiches were hard as rocks. Their classic chocolate chip cookies were pretty decent and their "cow puddle" cookie had a really great flavor but was also extremely hard.

Several shop owners in this lively historic town referred us to this gem. It is located on a die street in a little historic house with outdoor and indoor seating. They bake their own pasties, pies, and that wonderful bread!A great place for a quick sandwich.

More Reviews(85)


Monday 7:30AM - 4PM
Tuesday 7:30AM - 4PM
Wednesday 7:30AM - 4PM
Thursday 7:30AM - 4PM
Friday 7:30AM - 4PM
Saturday 7:30AM - 4PM
Sunday Closed

Hours or services may differ due to COVID-19. Please contact the business directly to verify hours and availability.