Red Eye Cookie Co.

935 W Grace St, Richmond
(804) 620-7280

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Jay K.

It's too bad they're now CLOSED. Amazing cookies!
Guess that's the way the cookie crumbles....

Todd Rich

Placed an order for pickup today. Store opens at 11am. Was there at 12:15pm, store was dark, door locked, no one there. Nice. So glad I drove 20 minutes to get there and paid for parking, for no reason.

Baba Bobo

my roommate has brought me cookies from here and wow it's extremely underbaked but they still taste good

sagar kabariya

Javad was great help and cookies was delicious

Kole Lutz

Looks good although expensive, $4 per cookie updated as of Jan 2026

Justen Lewis

awesome owner delicious cookies, a great businessman for sure :) Brayden was the bomb

P C

Worst cookie ever in my life, The cookie felt like stale and it’s 5$ a cookie not worth it at all. I ordered chocolate chip but there nothing in it, there is no 0 rating that is why I gave one star, never going again

Terri K

Amazing smells, that have the taste to match! We tried the snickerdoodle, chocolate chip, and oreo cookies. All of them were a hit, and I highly recommend this place!

Stephanie Yera

We came in on the late end of the night and Sarah and Gabby were the sweetest angels in the world. As someone who has worked in customer service industry for 5+ years, these girls need a raise!!!!! Immediately!! They provided the most genuine experience and made sure we were all taken care of to the best degree. They were so thoughtful and accommodated our food allergies and questions. They met every expectation and went beyond. Would rate Gabby and Sarah 100 stars if I could.

Mary Soden

The cookies!!! Awesomeness! Good size, ingredients fresh. BAKED FRESH. Not frozen. Gotta try ! Now, if they could make sugar free cookies taste like this I'd be 🙆🏼‍♀️.

Paige Bordwine

The online order was easy and the cookies were great!

Christine Ryan

Gooey and under cooked texture… cookies fall apart

Nathalie Rodriguez

Bit basic

bassboy94

Got a small box with assorted cookies. I swore id be good but i ate two on the way home! Really exceptional cookies!

Samantha

These things should come with a warning label! My husband and I almost hurt ourselves eating these cookies so fast lol. We had them delivered to the hotel we're staying in for the weekend and they were still nice and warm when we got them. We shouldn't have bought a dozen because now we're going to have to restrain from eating them all tonight lol.

Loading...