Shy Guy Gelato

Gelato, Ice Cream, Frozen Yogurt, Dessert

457 St Paul St, Burlington
(802) 355-2320


Take-Out/Delivery Options


Reviews for Shy Guy Gelato

Came here moments before they were closing, mainly because I needed some gelato therapy and saw that it was walking distance from our AirBnB, in addition to having 5 stars! I like that there are only a few choices in flavors - helps my indecisiveness and also makes me feel like it actually is homemade in small batches. Really tasty, rich texture and interesting flavors.

This is a true gem! I've eaten at Shy Guy ever since it opened, and I have to say the owner is truly a person who's life's passion is his store and his customers. Shy Guy is easily one of the top 5 gelaterias in the United States. I brought my Italian father here and he said it is the only Gelato he's ever had state side that might be better than what he's had in Italy. High praise indeed! The owner has invented some wild flavors that truly show his full review

Having eaten Gelato all across the US and most of western Europe, there was only one other gelateria that came close to the level of quality as Shy Guy. That was in Rome, and as delicious as their classic offerings were, Paul's is equal, and he offers more adventurous flavors. The cider donught is perhaps the best dessert I've ever had in my life.

More Reviews(77)


Monday Closed
Tuesday Closed
Wednesday Closed
Thursday 12 - 7PM
Friday 12 - 7PM
Saturday 12 - 7PM
Sunday 12 - 7PM

Hours or services may differ due to COVID-19. Please contact the business directly to verify hours and availability.