18 Best Pizza Restaurants near Hinesburg

“Got 4 Takeout hot subs, All came out fantastic fresh ingredients, If you get the large you better be hungry. The Fire-Cracker is probably one of the best sandwiches ive had in a long time. The 2 chicken sandwiches were both larges and it was about 2 meals worth of food...

My only thing is: 1 Large with Chips for 17.50 is a bit steep but not too bad if you include the 2$ bag of chips. So you basically have to pay for the chips even if you dont like kettle chips. (which i love and buy frequently) If i could buy the sandwich for 15$ alone i would much prefer that. But this kind of moves the chip product so it makes sense.“

“Great food, friendly service, very reasonable prices. That's what keeps me coming to Papa Nick's, usually once a week (more often in the summer). And I have to drive over the mountain from Fayston to do so. I love this place--Voula does a fantastic job. I just wish they could some day go back to having their Greek Nights on Thursdays. (They do have occasional Greek entrees but it's just not as predictable as it was before the pandemic. Then again, nothing is...) Highly recommended!“

“Paid a quick visit to your Shelburne location today to pick and go. Ordered just a plain pie and some wings. Amazing pizza and delicious dry rub wings. Will be coming back. Kudos to the amazing staff (I didn’t get his name) as well who recommended things to do for us out of staters visiting for a bit.“

“Stones Throw Pizza & Wine is an absolute gem! Our small group from CVU had an amazing time learning to make pizza from scratch. The whole experience was fantastic, from the cozy atmosphere to the incredibly fresh ingredients.
A huge shoutout to Lilith, our host, who made the day truly special. She was super knowledgeable, patient, and made the whole pizza-making process fun and engaging. We learned so much about dough, sauce, and toppings!
The pizza we made was, without a doubt, the best we've ever tasted. It was such a blast creating our own pies and then enjoying them together. If you're looking for a unique and delicious experience, especially with a group, Stones Throw is the place to go. Highly recommended!“

“My son stopped in when coming back from Montreal with friends. Random stop. “Best pizza I have ever had”“

“I am from New Jersey.I remember they had a spot in Woodbridge mall and until recently I believed them to be the alternate to sbarro shopping mall pizza.I was wrongBack home, we had dozens of top notch pizzerias so I never tried them but up here in vermont I can honestly tell youThey make good pie.Easily one of the best New York style pies around.Take that to the bank.“

“Fresh, tasty, and authentic! Thanks Carlo and the crew for a great lunch and dinner. We had a fresh salad and tasty garlic bites in their awesome restaurant, then took home 2 great pizzas for dinner later that evening. All our ingredients were fresh, and well seasoned, ricotta to die for! We got a mickster and a prosciutto pie and, can’t wait to go back and try more!“

“We had the best time at Backyard Bistro. Staff was so attentive to my shellfish allergy. The food was amazing, Wine and cocktail selection was perfect. Thank you Jill and Adam Spell & staff, you continue to deliver incredible food and ambiance. Love the atmosphere and will definitely return.“

“Stopped by this pizza place during a road trip, and it was a pleasant surprise! The picture doesn’t do it justice—the crust was perfectly crunchy but still soft and not dry on the inside. The flavors were incredibly well-balanced, and the taste exceeded my expectations. Highly recommend!“

“Just love this place. Delicious food - the pizza is amazing, but so too the salad (with Tahini dressing - I order extra!) and don't get me started on the cannoli! Bright, clean space, amazing wine selection, very friendly staff. Top notch in every way!“

“We order take out every once in a while from Zachary's, and it's always delicious. What gets us to go to the Milton location and get food, hang out, and order drinks, though, is the monthly stand up comedy they host. The stand up routines are funny, and we really look forward to going!“

“Great Food, I simply love your meat lovers New York style and Sicilian pizzas.“

“Amazing and friendly and delivery service“

“My friend and I went for dinner… we started with the poutine, and it was excellent! My friend had the pepperoni pizza and I had the bacon avocado burger with onion rings. Both entrées were amazing! Also, we really enjoyed the margaritas. They were very fresh tasting! Everything we had was fresh and delicious. I would definitely recommend and we will definitely be going back again!“

“This was last week: My family decided to get some pizza at Folino’s after going to City Market. Because after getting some healthy things, we were down for some bad decisions. Folino’s Pizza next to a dispensary which honestly was probably their best move possible. The place was PACKED like sardines. (Which I had on pizza once and never again…. Why don’t we ever argue this? Why do people actually argue to the death about pineapple on pizza and NOT HAIRY FISH??? Why are we so divided on this?!) The menu was pretty interesting and easy to follow and we picked two pizzas and wings…. We sat down…. After we paid….. after we tipped, before service was done. I would soon be able to conclude why. You can literally pick a seat anywhere and get a nice glass of water from cups that had seen better days and worse mouths. Next to the garbages…. Next to where you pick your silverware…. My son helped her restock the water. Totally fine. And then we saw…. The utensil/sauce station. Well…. It was PACKED. Garlic, parmesan, salt, pepper, hot sauce, pepper flakes. Some empty, others at various stages of full and honestly take your pick. We got one of each. Went through silverware and it was like a treasure hunt! Some had old food and stains on them and I got to see what popular picks were at this place:-) I think we made the right picks!!! While I like leftovers at home, these were not the leftovers I had a hankering for… decided to pick else wear and found some that were clean clean. Again this place is packed! Line going out the door( to be fair there may have been a few who got mixed up with the Jazz Lettuce place next door). The food sounded/smelled so delicious. We were already hungry and down for some wildfire awesomeness…. And now, we wait….. and wait…. And wait some more. Did…. Did they forget about us? I see some people eating, some people who look famished and well we decided to shoot our shot and ask people how long they had been waiting/if they ordered. Yes. Just yes. The line is moving and fast. I went to their website to see if it was like Disney with the fast passes or something… I can’t even begin to tell you how bummed I am writing that “no” here. After like an hour the wings came out. And I swear to God, with seasoning wings, these kids understood the assignment. However taking a bit of the wing, the chicken fought back. The chicken skin was….. oh God, a good vet could have saved it... a while later, the Buff Chick came out and oh sweet mother of God those candied jalapeños are just the bees knees…then they bought out The Vegan Supreme…. No onions…. And she made a point to say, no onions…. So I knew immediately, there was onions somewhere… which is just fine. My mouth just tingles and gets kinda itchy. Aside from that lil fun fact about me….. those pizzas were amazing and the crust is just what you’d want. And despite a crowded kitchen with no hair nets and loose styles everywhere, there was little to no hair in the food! The pizza is definitely worth buying just not the wait unless you have the afternoon and no perishable groceries in your car (City Market) to waste…. My guess with the line out the door, they preordered online within a couple hours getting there. My husband loved that we tipped to have the home experience and got to not only wait on ourselves and clean up after our selves, he also loved that he was able to clean the table off from the previous people and the bundle of pizza tray holders from them as well. My son loved that he found a wing order he didn’t want to touch at all. If you have an afternoon to waste by the water cooler and tables with an awesome pizza sheen on it… get here faster then they open. You won’t be disappointed with disappointment. Buttttt, (and this is a big but here) if you want some awesome pizza with awesome flavor and amazing crust, definitely get it here. Just order online. Get all your chores and shopping done… maybe make time for a movie. After all that, it might be ready and you too can be in the line out the door…. Looking at all the people in the dining area like you dodg“

“The thick crust pizza was a little too thick if you know what I mean. And don't get me started on the crazy bread. It gives my senile aunt Mindy a run for her money. I probably won't come back but I am rating 5 stars because the tiling in this place is immaculate. I have never seen cleaner grout lines.“

“Absolutely amazing food! So happy to be able to try! Thank you for all you do“

“The food is fantastic with large portions!! I highly recommend that you make a stop here for Lunch or Dinner you won't be disappointed!!“