9 Best Pizza Restaurants near Poultney

“One of the best pizza's anywhere! Got the Mediterranean pizza- beautiful. Toppings nicely browned and generous. Absolutely delicious. Very comfortable inside.“

“Had takeout from Bernardo 5 two nights in a row ~ delish! Last night we shared a corned beef & cabbage special (& it was so good!), & tonight we had a white pizza (very scrumptious). All of the staff were super friendly & made me feel very welcome. We will be back, for sure. Thank you for two great meals! 💚💚 Karin & Bob Birbeck, Wells, VT“

“First time tried the pizza and it was excellent and macconi cheese was good thank you. Now I know where to go get pizza thank you. It was quiet too.“

“My son and I love the food here! It is always fresh hot and cooked to perfection. In addition the employees are so professional and sweet to talk to and order from, the customer service is exceptional! I had the pleasure of speaking with the owner one day and he takes a lot of pride and care on how he runs his business. He is extremely responsible, very intellectual and just a very good person who cares about his customers the community and his employees and business. I hope to get pizza here with my son for a long time and wish you all success in our local community!! After growing up in VT and being alumni of Castleton College, I can say this is a business we should all be supporting and helping to grow! we switched our Friday night pizza place so should you!! thank you!!!“

“Nestled in the heart of a charming small town, Fairhaven Pizza delivers not only a taste of local warmth but also a bold culinary experience. Just stepping inside feels like entering a family kitchen, where the owner personally greets each guest, infusing every bite with passion and pride. There’s pictures of all the families that are connected to the restaurant who’ve been coming to this restaurant for decades.

We couldn't wait to dive into our two picks: the classic Cheesesteak and the all-encompassing Italian--The Works. First up was the Cheesesteak, and let me tell you, it was love at first bite. This wasn't your typical Philly knockoff--each bite was packed with massive chunks of tender, flavorful meat, topped perfectly with gooey, fresh mozzarella that melted into the bread. It’s really high quality cheese. Speaking of the bread, it's made in-house, and it shows; fluffy inside with a satisfying crust, it was the perfect vessel for that generous helping of steak and cheese.

The Italian Works was equally impressive. Bursting with layers of cured meats, fresh greens, and oil and vinegar, every bite was a rich and balanced mix of flavors. It's the kind of sandwich that seems simple, but you can taste the careful preparation behind each ingredient.

Fairhaven Pizza's sandwiches are more than a meal--they're an experience steeped in the warm spirit of this charming town, crafted by someone who truly cares about every detail. Whether you're a local or just passing through, these are two sandwiches you won't want to miss!

They also have all the typical Italian dishes you'd expect. We will definitely try something different when we come back into town.“

“ordered from our favorite pizza spot. wings and pizza and of course never lets us down with how amazing their food is. my kids love this spot. highly recommend them!“

“Although I like this place I ordered the rocket burger and basically poutine. My French fries had ONLY the slightest bit of gravy on them (no cheese even though that’s what I ordered.) the rocket burger had the tiniest bit of boom boom sauce on the bottom of the sandwhich. I get y’all may be understaffed but make your food correctly how people order it and these reviews wouldn’t happen. Again, I love this place as much as the next, but it’s upsetting I paid 40 dollars for food that wasn’t made correctly.“

“Passed through Fair Haven and found this wonderful bar open on July 4th. The food and drinks were great, but most importantly, Danielle tracked me down on FB when I accidently left my wallet on a bar stool. We made arrangements for a pickup the next day, and all was intact. Thank you Danielle!“

“The Vermont Horseman’s Association recently had Scarlotta’s Food Truck at our horse show. Great food and service was excellent. They were fantastic and several members have asked to have them back.“