Pegasus Pie Co.

CLOSED
$$ •

320 S 1st St, Mount Vernon

About Pegasus Pie Co.

Pegasus Pie Co. offers delicious treats in a welcoming and friendly atmosphere. The bakery features a charming interior, which can be a bit confusing, but it has everything needed, including seating and wifi. Highlights include hand pies, a 5" lemon meringue pie, jalapeño cheddar biscuits, peanut butter cookies, and the standout Mediterranean Avocado Toast with house-made bread, avocado, sweet cherry tomatoes, fresh basil, feta cheese, and balsamic vinegar. There is also a wonderful assortment of savory pies, quiche, and a great coffee bar with skilled baristas. Guests can even watch the bakers in the back doing their craft. The shop features a cute selection of gift items and has tables inside for those who want to enjoy their treats on-site. The staff is friendly and accommodating, even staying open late for customers. Prices are a bit high, but the quality makes it worth a visit. Located on a cute little street with many other shops, there is plenty of free public parking available.

Pegasus Pie Co. Reviews

4.5
51 ratings
Restaurantji Rating
5
82%
4
4%
3
2%
2
6%
1
6%
Food
4.4
Atmosphere
4.3
Service
4.4

Great hand pies and paninis! The soups are delicious as well! Very friendly service! Highly recommend!

The most delicious pastries and pies in the Northwest! The pasties have the exact balance between sweet and tartness and not an excessive amount of sugar. The filling gets to speak very loudly for itself. Great spot to have lunch and desserts. I also hear they serve espresso now!

We had the best work meeting ever this morning thanks to a scrumptious quiche and indulgent cinnamon rolls from Pegasus Pie Co. Absolute best crust EVER.

Read All Reviews(51)

Ratings

Menu

Add a Menu
Pegasus Pie Co. Menu
Pegasus Pie Co. Menu

Photos

Add a Photo
Pegasus Pie Co.
Pegasus Pie Co.
View All Photos
Updated on: