22 Best Pizza Restaurants in Puyallup

“I've been eating this pizza for 20 years now!! Same great family running it and Adrian always makes me feel like family when I come in to get some pies. The pizza's crusts are never greasy and the cheese is real with all fresh ingredients on the pies!!! I still drive over from Tacoma after my family moved to get these pizzas and it's worth the 20 mins. to get there. Always super friendly staff & never disappoints. My first choice for pizza 🍕 night hands down!!!“

“Papa Murphy’s is hands down my favorite place to get pizza from. Once again blown away by the amazing service this companies workers offer. The gentleman working last night was awesome and a good man. Not only did he help walk my pizza to my car as I had my half awake toddler in my arms but prior to me entering the store he had done the same thing for an elderly lady. That man deserves a raise!“

“The most DELICIOUS pizza my family has ever tasted!! If you are craving stretchy cheese, not heavy sauce , fresh toppings….. THIS PLACE IS ITTTTT!!!

Also the alfredo is top shelf!!

The lasagna tastes like my mother makes..

This place is very affordable (family of 7 ate for only 30$) no where in washington or a mall is that possible for us.

Its our fo to place from mow on .

Also the ladies operating it are soooo kind!!

TRY THIS PLACE!! You wont regret it and your tastebuds and pockets will thank you for it !“

“Fat Zach’s offers the perfect combo of delicious wood-fired pizza and flexibility. Their on-site catering accommodates dietary needs without sacrificing flavor, and the team is always friendly and fast. A guest favorite every time.“

“The best pizza in Puyallup hands down. The “Say it ain’t so” pizza with added pepperoni is our favorite. It’s a combination of ingredients we’d never order normally. But Wicked Pie makes it phenomenal. The adult only atmosphere makes it a great date night restaurant. The customer service has always been top notch too. You can’t go wrong dining here!“

“The past two times visits to this location they’ve struggled to find the appropriate ratio of sauce to cheese. Cheese slip will occur here. It’s unfortunate my experience the past two times was lack luster. I used to come here quite often and looked forward to my most recent visits, but now I’m left with the feeling of having been better off.

As for their mixed drinks… second to none.

Lastly, waitress assistance could improve, I’ve noticed a trend of people waiting exuberantly long to receive their checks.

Overall, I’d say this place is worth the visit, I’ll give the place grace and say my most recent visits have been “off days”.“

“If you didn’t know already, this establishment provided you with tasty ready to bake meals! This particular location is always, clean, busy and usually very friendly. Like any place that is ran by people, sometimes it is just a transaction and not an experience; and that is okay! Everything is always good and fresh and looks great out the oven. If you catch them at a slow hour, they do go out of their way to be kind. I’ll keep coming back for another 10+ years.“

“Great Trivia on Thursday Nights!“

“I came in this Resturant, April 9th 2025 and I tasted their butter chicken pizza for the first time and it was amazing! The family working there were very friendly, and I had came back in 5 minutes later to get another pizza because it was actually good, they got me fresh everything and had even given me complementary galab jamen.“

“Nothing special about the atmosphere it's calm and quiet but nothing to write home about. The workers are quick and make the pizza well. The food is good it's a few steps up from a fast food restaurant but not fine dining. This makes a good stop for lunch when you don't know what to get“

“When it comes to the management (Joe and Christian) excellent customer service. The team members Nick, Alex, and the rest of team are Amazing. I have eaten at Roundtable in Puyallup at least 5 times in April. The food is AMAZING 👏🏾 The customer service AMAZING. The Price is AMAZING. The ingredients on the pizza are fresh and the crust is so delicious. The accuracy on the orders is exact with no mistakes. And your order is ready in a timely manner. Lazy day and you don't feel like cooking call Roundtable you won't be disappointed. Keep up the AMAZING WORK.

Dametra (Dee)“

“Ate here the other day. Their pizzas are very good. A little pricey, but generally worth it. What I do not understand is their pricing. We ordered a Daily Double: any 2 pizzas for $28. But on the receipt it says $28.98. Huh? was there some fine print somewhere that I didn’t notice and was not brought to my attention by the host? The pint I ordered was listed as $8 on the menu, but I was charged $8.28. Same with the salad. What the menu showed as $8 was actually $8.28. Can anyone explain this to me? It was generally a good experience, you do have to place your order at the window and go pick it up like at a fast food joint. So the service was lacking. But doing it yourself saves on the tip. I just don’t understand the pricing.“

“I tried the calzone from Papa Murphys! They are really good and worth the price. I got a Pepperoni and added Sausage. I am not a fan of the sprinkle parm so substituted it for mozzarella on top! It was busy when I went since it was Tuesday and they run a special on that day. The Store was very clean and All the Girls working are super friendly. Didn't have to wait to long was in and out in less than 5 minutes! Well worth a try!“

“I accidentally forgot to complete my order online but the Sienna and the rest of the staff honored the 30% off coupon and helped me recreate my order. She was super helpful ringing me up. They had it all ready in less than 10 minutes. I wish there was a spot to sit but that's not on them. Awesome location!

Vegetarian options: Dairy free cheese options“

“I’ve left several reviews with this Mod pizza but they keep disappearing , which is sus.

I’ve had a good experience most times income here. Sometimes the workers skimp out on putting toppings and on numerous occasions the oven has broke. But the majority of times this place has been pretty good overall.“

“I had a delicious vegetarian spread. The hummus plate was wonderful, loved the added veggies. The falafel was amazing as well but a little tricky to eat as perfectly fried balls. A disk or patty like would make it easy to eat but that’s a micro critique. It’s hard to be mad at a perfectly fried falafel ball. Tha ambiance was on point. Cute spot! Loved the dickcore.

Vegetarian options: Vegetarians would have an easier time than vegans, obviously, but we chose this life 🤷🏼‍♀️“

“Didn't actually buy pizza here. HOWEVER, we had a PIZZA EMERGENCY, and needed 2 pizza boxes. Pizza Hut said NO but the kind fellow in this Dominos gave us two pizza boxes for FREE, and the dining room wasn't even open! Secured 3 lifelong customers in us!
-Rian, Elijah, Anthony.“

“I order from this restaurant about once a month (delivery, in store pickup, and curbside pickup). My food is always perfect, the in-store staff is friendly and helpful, and the delivery drivers are courteous and fast.

The inside of the store is basic but clean. There are a few tables to eat at and some candy/trinket machines for kids.“

“Sky was the only one working when he took my order over the phone. I had a coupon for any large piece of for $10 so I picked the large stuffed. When I got there to pay the tiny print said not stuffed pizzas. So I was able to get a create your own with up to five toppings which I’ve never tried before. Sky easily changed my order, even though he had started the crust and sauce already. It was very kind and patient to everyone on the phone at the register and waiting even though he was the only employee working and it was very busy time I think sky should’ve had more help. It was not easy for him to smile, but he was wonderful at everything.!!! The pizza was delicious and you couldn’t beat that price! I would love to have More coupons like that!“

“Best grinders I’ve ever had. Hands down it’s my favorite food from any restaurant/eatery. The sauce, the meat, and the bread is all top notch. Can’t go wrong on a grinder there especially for $6.50. I love it and I wish I could rate more than 5 stars!“

“I generally avoid dominos like the plague because it’s just “cheap” tasting and I’ve continuously been less than impressed but after an exhausting long day with the kids we just didn’t have it in us to make dinner so we ordered a couple pizza for the kiddos and called it good.And it was good! They were cooked well, reasonably priced and piping hot. The quality has def gone up in the last few years and the staff at this location were very kind and helpful“

“Love trackside Pizza, all the food is made with such fresh ingredients. Also The staff are super friendly. The downside might be that they are a little bit expensive, not too bad though, not like unreasonably expensive. It's pretty cool to be sitting there and have one of the trains come flying by it shakes the whole building it's really really cool, I had watched the newest final destination right before coming here and I was not ready to see a train come flying by at full speed. So definitely come here, don't watch final destination bloodlines before doing so.“