31 Best Pizza Restaurants in Puyallup

“Fat Zach’s offers the perfect combo of delicious wood-fired pizza and flexibility. Their on-site catering accommodates dietary needs without sacrificing flavor, and the team is always friendly and fast. A guest favorite every time.“

“Excellent flavor and great quality toppings and crust! Our new local go to!“

“ABSOLUTELY INSANE! This crust a soft with a little crunch to it, the flavor is authentic, the sauce is flavorful and rich, and the toppings are ALWAYS fresh! I have been to this spot 3 times now and every, single, time, they have gone above and beyond to assist me as best as possible! You can tell they really do put effort into their work. Hands down the best pizza I have tasted in forever. If you love pizza as much as me this is a must-try place.“

“Papa Murphy’s is hands down my favorite place to get pizza from. Once again blown away by the amazing service this companies workers offer. The gentleman working last night was awesome and a good man. Not only did he help walk my pizza to my car as I had my half awake toddler in my arms but prior to me entering the store he had done the same thing for an elderly lady. That man deserves a raise!“

“The best pizza in Puyallup hands down. The “Say it ain’t so” pizza with added pepperoni is our favorite. It’s a combination of ingredients we’d never order normally. But Wicked Pie makes it phenomenal. The adult only atmosphere makes it a great date night restaurant. The customer service has always been top notch too. You can’t go wrong dining here!“

“If you didn’t know already, this establishment provided you with tasty ready to bake meals! This particular location is always, clean, busy and usually very friendly. Like any place that is ran by people, sometimes it is just a transaction and not an experience; and that is okay! Everything is always good and fresh and looks great out the oven. If you catch them at a slow hour, they do go out of their way to be kind. I’ll keep coming back for another 10+ years.“

“Lucas, the general manager, helped organize an amazing event for my family to celebrate our wedding. He went above and beyond to accommodate a fluctuating guest count and deliver an amazing experience for our guests the night before our wedding.

Special shout out to our server, Alex!

The Rock in Puyallup is an amazing spot with great food, drinks and staff. 10/10!“

“I accidentally forgot to complete my order online but the Sienna and the rest of the staff honored the 30% off coupon and helped me recreate my order. She was super helpful ringing me up. They had it all ready in less than 10 minutes. I wish there was a spot to sit but that's not on them. Awesome location!

Vegetarian options: Dairy free cheese options“

“I'll clarify before the fact, I had food from the restaurant again the next day and the quality was much improved.

I have a strong nostalgia for the twists, so I ordered 12 and added 6 for the first time use of the app or whatever it was. 18 glorious twists. Except when I picked them up they were not at all fluffy, they were crunchy and as they got colder they got hard.

Like I said at the top, I did have a redo the next day. The pizza was as good as I remember it, and that batch of twists was spot on, exactly how I remember.

3 star for food for the up and down consistency, 4 stars overall. All of the staff was friendly and made picking up my food a good experience.“

“I stopped in to grab a quick pizza and try it out. I am super picky. I really really liked it, and the guy working was very nice too. :)“

“The staff is always excellent and welcoming but today I had an exceptional experience with a brunette with sparkles on her cheeks. She was lively, welcoming and rocked it out with everyone that was in line. Keep up the great work guys and gals at this location. Pizzas are done nicely with care and cooked to perfection. Tables and chairs need to be cleaned a little better or redone to make the dining experience that much better“

“I tried the calzone from Papa Murphys! They are really good and worth the price. I got a Pepperoni and added Sausage. I am not a fan of the sprinkle parm so substituted it for mozzarella on top! It was busy when I went since it was Tuesday and they run a special on that day. The Store was very clean and All the Girls working are super friendly. Didn't have to wait to long was in and out in less than 5 minutes! Well worth a try!“

“Great Trivia on Thursday Nights!“

“Ate here the other day. Their pizzas are very good. A little pricey, but generally worth it. What I do not understand is their pricing. We ordered a Daily Double: any 2 pizzas for $28. But on the receipt it says $28.98. Huh? was there some fine print somewhere that I didn’t notice and was not brought to my attention by the host? The pint I ordered was listed as $8 on the menu, but I was charged $8.28. Same with the salad. What the menu showed as $8 was actually $8.28. Can anyone explain this to me? It was generally a good experience, you do have to place your order at the window and go pick it up like at a fast food joint. So the service was lacking. But doing it yourself saves on the tip. I just don’t understand the pricing.“

“I generally avoid dominos like the plague because it’s just “cheap” tasting and I’ve continuously been less than impressed but after an exhausting long day with the kids we just didn’t have it in us to make dinner so we ordered a couple pizza for the kiddos and called it good.And it was good! They were cooked well, reasonably priced and piping hot. The quality has def gone up in the last few years and the staff at this location were very kind and helpful“

“I order from this restaurant about once a month (delivery, in store pickup, and curbside pickup). My food is always perfect, the in-store staff is friendly and helpful, and the delivery drivers are courteous and fast.

The inside of the store is basic but clean. There are a few tables to eat at and some candy/trinket machines for kids.“

“Best grinders I’ve ever had. Hands down it’s my favorite food from any restaurant/eatery. The sauce, the meat, and the bread is all top notch. Can’t go wrong on a grinder there especially for $6.50. I love it and I wish I could rate more than 5 stars!“

“I’ve been to Greek restaurants in seattle before and the food is mediocre. So I wasn’t really interested in going to this place. Only came because the daughter wasn’t interested in the food at market. Wow! Have I been missing out. Their food is very, very good. I am impressed and I’ve been to Greece. I’m definitely looking forward to coming back and trying more of their dishes.“

“Didn't actually buy pizza here. HOWEVER, we had a PIZZA EMERGENCY, and needed 2 pizza boxes. Pizza Hut said NO but the kind fellow in this Dominos gave us two pizza boxes for FREE, and the dining room wasn't even open! Secured 3 lifelong customers in us!
-Rian, Elijah, Anthony.“

“When this MOD opened they were spot on. Over time, the quality diminished. Today, Employee Bear made my pizza and cooked it. Usually when i ask for well done, it's still a bit doughy for me but Bear knows exactly how to prepare, cook, and present the pizza. It was perfect down to the cut. A+++ This guy should be the manager as he obviously cares for the pizza and the people buying it. Thank you!!! Perfection!“

“Love trackside Pizza, all the food is made with such fresh ingredients. Also The staff are super friendly. The downside might be that they are a little bit expensive, not too bad though, not like unreasonably expensive. It's pretty cool to be sitting there and have one of the trains come flying by it shakes the whole building it's really really cool, I had watched the newest final destination right before coming here and I was not ready to see a train come flying by at full speed. So definitely come here, don't watch final destination bloodlines before doing so.“

“Your store righted 2 wrongs that were not even from their location. Catelyn and Kelsey (and everyone else) were so helpful, kind, and considerate. We will never go anywhere else. I know that it's just pizza but you store and your employees have most definitely set the standard for all other branches“

“Rey is a true photography visionary! I have had the pleasure to see his eye for detail and maximize customer value! I would recommend any one that works with him will see especially my properties.“

“The service at this location was amazing! The young lady who brought my order out to my vehicle was super sweet. I immediately opened up my box and was thoroughly impressed. It was made EXACTLY how I requested!This is the best pepperoni pizza I have ever had from Pizza Hut! Will definitely be ordering from this location again!Thanks Pizza Hut !!!!“

“Sky was the only one working when he took my order over the phone. I had a coupon for any large piece of for $10 so I picked the large stuffed. When I got there to pay the tiny print said not stuffed pizzas. So I was able to get a create your own with up to five toppings which I’ve never tried before. Sky easily changed my order, even though he had started the crust and sauce already. It was very kind and patient to everyone on the phone at the register and waiting even though he was the only employee working and it was very busy time I think sky should’ve had more help. It was not easy for him to smile, but he was wonderful at everything.!!! The pizza was delicious and you couldn’t beat that price! I would love to have More coupons like that!“

“We requested our pizza well done. It was perfect! We had several other items, and they were all well prepared and tasty. Only 2 employees (that I could see) were working. But they were getting everything out very timely and accurate! Well done!!“

“Definitely my go to bar gotta get down here“

“Unique pour your own. Relax atmosphere.“

“Great Gas Station Prices. Most Organic Products in the Area“