The Independent Pizzeria
$ • Pizza, Italian Book a table: 7:00 PM 7:15 PM 7:30 PM MoreAbout The Independent Pizzeria
Customers' Favorites
Cheese Pizza with Basil
The Farmer
New Haven
Stevedore
Syracuse
Clam Pie
The Independent Pizzeria Reviews
144 ratings
Share your opinion about The Independent Pizzeria
Best pizza I’ve had in the US. We actually ate so much it was ridiculous ;) The mushroom and fontina is insanely good. Well, so are the others. And yes, I was invited there and got to learn about pizza, the dough is a wonder. Gave me a whole new guiding light for what it should be like!
Very good pizza with superb homemade crust. The hours are rather limited. Directly opposite the beach.
Awesome pizza, I guess Neapolitan pizza? Stevedore was 5/5, no complaints.
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | 3:30 - 8PM |
| Friday | 3:30 - 8PM |
| Saturday | 3:30 - 8PM |
| Sunday | 3:30 - 8PM |
The Independent Pizzeria is known for serving some of the best pizzas in the city, perfect for a cozy night in with loved ones. Their menu features unique combinations of fresh and delicious ingredients, paired with perfectly cooked dough, making each pizza a standout. Favorites include the State Fair and Pepperoni pizzas, while the thin crust and chewy texture add to the overall phenomenal experience. The restaurant is a hidden gem in Madison Park, with big flavors and high quality. Pizzas are fresh, hot, and cooked to perfection, with generous toppings that offer great value. Customers appreciate the friendly service and the option to order ahead, which helps ensure they get their favorite pizzas before they sell out. The tomato sauce is flavorful and fresh, the cheese is perfectly melted, and the pepperoni and sausage have great taste. Although the crust can be a bit soft on the bottom, it is still delicious, with the outside crust cooked just right. Takeout-only service makes it a convenient choice for any occasion, and many visitors look forward to returning whenever they are in town. The location in Madison Lake offers outdoor seating, which is appreciated, although the inside can sometimes be crowded and messy. Overall, the pizzeria remains a favorite for many, still thriving in a city where good food can be hard to find at reasonable prices.