Schlotzsky's

881 N Casaloma Dr, Appleton
(920) 731-7272

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

California Chicken & Avocado Flatbread
Beef Bacon Smokecheesy Sandwich
Turkey Bacon Club Sandwich
Schlotzsky's Potato Chips
Strawberry Chicken Salad
Roast Beef Sandwich
Deluxe Original
Fiesta Chicken
Cinnamon Roll
The Original

Featured items
The Original
Where it all started. ham | salami | 3 cheeses | olives | lettuce | onion | tomato | mustard | signature sauce | sourdough bun
Bacon Smokecheesy Sandwich
CHOICE OF: smoked turkey | ham | chicken | roast beef COMES WITH: bacon | smoked cheddar | chipotle mayo | sourdough bun
Turkey Bacon Club Sandwich
turkey | bacon | 3 cheeses | lettuce | tomato | lite mayo | signature sauce | sourdough bun
Pick Two
Mix 'n match any 1/2 of two entrées to enjoy more variety. Choose from sandwiches, pizzas, salads or soups. Excludes Calzones and Spicy Menu.
Cinnabon® Classic Roll
Warm dough, legendary Makara® Cinnamon, topped with rich cream cheese frosting.
Broccoli & Cheese Soup
Creamy blend of cheddar cheese and broccoli florets. Topped with cheddar cheese.
Chicken Bacon Ranch Calzone
ranch | mozzarella | chicken | bacon | red onion
Chicken Avocado Cobb Salad
lettuce blend | chicken | feta | bacon | avocado | egg | tomatoes | cucumber | croutons | ranch dressing
Fountain Drink
Roast Beef & Cheese Sandwich
roast beef | 3 cheeses | pickles | lettuce | onion | tomato | lite mayo | signature sauce | sourdough bun
Avocado Turkey Sandwich
turkey | avocado | lettuce | onion | tomato | lite mayo | sourdough bun
Fiesta-Style Sandwich
CHOICE OF: smoked turkey | ham | chicken | roast beefCOMES WITH: cheese | olives | roasted red peppers | lettuce | red & green onions |tomato | chipotle mayo | jalapeño cheese bun
French Dip Sandwich
roast beef | 2 cheeses | caramelized onions | sourdough bun | au jus on the side
Tomato Basil
Fresh, ripe tomatoes, basil and onions blended into a smooth, creamy soup. Topped with croutons and parmesan cheese.
Pepperoni & Double Cheese Pizza
2 cheeses | pepperoni | marinara
Loaded Baked Potato Soup
Hearty cream soup with potatoes and bacon bits. Topped with cheddar cheese, bacon bits and green onions.
Turkey Original
turkey | salami | 3 cheeses | olives | lettuce | onion | tomato | lite mayo | signature sauce sourdough bun
Smoked Turkey Breast Sandwich
turkey | lettuce | tomato | lite mayo | sourdough bun
Double Cheese Pizza
2 cheeses | marinara
Ham & Cheese Original
ham | 3 Cheeses | olives| lettuce | onion | tomato | mustard | signature sauce | sourdough bun

Meal Deals
Sammie Sampler Bundle
Mix and match four (4) small sandwiches and any entree salad (protein not included).

Calzones
Chicken Bacon Ranch Calzone
ranch | mozzarella | chicken | bacon | red onion
Italian
Genoa Salami, Cotto Salami, Ham, Pepperoni, Mozzarella, Shredded Parmesan, Marinara
Sausage & Pepper Calzone
ranch | mozzarella | Italian Sausage | red pepper | banana pepper | red onion

Sandwiches
Bacon Smokecheesy Sandwich
CHOICE OF: smoked turkey | ham | chicken | roast beef COMES WITH: bacon | smoked cheddar | chipotle mayo | sourdough bun
The Original
Where it all started. ham | salami | 3 cheeses | olives | lettuce | onion | tomato | mustard | signature sauce | sourdough bun
Turkey Bacon Club Sandwich
turkey | bacon | 3 cheeses | lettuce | tomato | lite mayo | signature sauce | sourdough bun
Fresh Veggie Sandwich
cheese | cucumber | olives | lettuce | onion | tomato | ranch | sourdough bun
Smoked Turkey Breast Sandwich
turkey | lettuce | tomato | lite mayo | sourdough bun
Roast Beef & Cheese Sandwich
roast beef | 3 cheeses | pickles | lettuce | onion | tomato | lite mayo | signature sauce | sourdough bun
Avocado Turkey Sandwich
turkey | avocado | lettuce | onion | tomato | lite mayo | sourdough bun
Ham & Cheese Original
ham | 3 Cheeses | olives| lettuce | onion | tomato | mustard | signature sauce | sourdough bun
Fiesta-Style Sandwich
CHOICE OF: smoked turkey | ham | chicken | roast beefCOMES WITH: cheese | olives | roasted red peppers | lettuce | red & green onions |tomato | chipotle mayo | jalapeño cheese bun
Deluxe Original-Style
Like The Original®, but with more than double the meat. ham | salami | 3 cheeses | olives | lettuce | onion | tomato | mustard | signature sauce | sourdough bun
Turkey Original
turkey | salami | 3 cheeses | olives | lettuce | onion | tomato | lite mayo | signature sauce sourdough bun
Albuquerque Turkey Sandwich
smoked turkey | bacon | 3 cheeses | fire-roasted vegetables | lettuce | tomato | chipotle mayo | signature sauce | jalapeño cheese bun
Cheese Original
3 cheeses | olives | lettuce | onion | tomato | mustard | signature sauce | sourdough bun
French Dip Sandwich
roast beef | 2 cheeses | caramelized onions | sourdough bun | au jus on the side

Pizzas & Flats
BBQ Chicken & Jalapeno Pizza
chicken | 2 cheeses | BBQ sauce | onion | pickled jalapeños
Four Cheese White Pizza
mozzarella | cheddar | feta | parmesan | garlic spread
Double Cheese Pizza
2 cheeses | marinara
Veggie Pizza
2 cheeses | mushrooms | green bell pepper | onion | olives | tomato | marinara
Meaty Pizza
mozzarella | parmesan | pepperoni | bacon | Italian sausage | marinara
California Chicken & Avocado Pizza
chicken | bacon | 2 cheeses | avocado | roasted red peppers | lite mayo | chipotle mayo
Pepperoni & Double Cheese Pizza
2 cheeses | pepperoni | marinara
Supreme Pizza
pepperoni | Italian sausage | mushrooms | green peppers | red onions | mozzarella | parmesan | marinara

Salads
Chicken Caesar Salad
romaine lettuce | chicken | cheese | croutons | Caesar dressing
Chicken Avocado Cobb Salad
lettuce blend | chicken | feta | bacon | avocado | egg | tomatoes | cucumber | croutons | ranch dressing
Strawberry Chicken Salad
lettuce blend | chicken | feta | strawberries | pecans | croutons | red wine vinaigrette
Greek Salad
lettuce blend | chicken | feta | banana peppers | tomatoes | olives | red onions | Greek dressing

Pick Two
Pick Two
Mix 'n match any 1/2 of two entrées to enjoy more variety. Choose from sandwiches, pizzas, salads or soups. Excludes Calzones and Spicy Menu.

Kids Meal
Cheese Pizza
cheese | marinara | sourdough crust
Grilled Cheese Sandwich
3 cheeses | signature sauce | sourdough bunchoice to add: ham | smoked turkey | chicken
Pepperoni Cheese Pizza
cheese | pepperoni | marinara | sourdough crust

Desserts
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Like its bigger sibling, except smaller.
Sugar Cookie
Soft and delicious.

Cinnabon
Cinnabon® Classic Roll
Warm dough, legendary Makara® Cinnamon, topped with rich cream cheese frosting.

Chips
Schlotzsky's Sour Cream & Onion Chips
Schlotzsky's Salt & Vinegar Chips
Lays®Baked Chips
Schlotzsky's Potato Chips
Schlotzsky's Cracked Black Pepper Chips
Schlotzsky's Jalapeño Chips
Schlotzsky's BBQ Chips

Beverages
Fountain Drink
Bottled Water
Bottled Beverages

Soups
Broccoli & Cheese Soup
Creamy blend of cheddar cheese and broccoli florets. Topped with cheddar cheese.
Tomato Basil
Fresh, ripe tomatoes, basil and onions blended into a smooth, creamy soup. Topped with croutons and parmesan cheese.
Loaded Baked Potato Soup
Hearty cream soup with potatoes and bacon bits. Topped with cheddar cheese, bacon bits and green onions.

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+53 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+52 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

I drove 2 hours to eat at this Schlotzky's and it was totally worth it! With most stores shutdown and this being only 1 of 2 locations in WI, I was so happy to find it! Great food, awesome service, lots of seating. Loved the vibe!
October 2025
Never had a sandwich here before. The sandwich itself was delicious. The person I had to receive my sandwich from was super nice. The gal that I had to order from was the most unfriendly person. No smile, not welcoming in the slightest. I was afraid to ask any questions. I hope this person had a better day, but first experience was not the greatest.
October 2025
We came in 35 minutes to close. Waited 10 minutes while young worker was doing something on at the register, no customer ahead of us. We placed our order and sat to eat. The entire time we ate the workers made it LOUD and clear how many minutes they had before it was time to close. Very obvious they wanted us out as soon as possible to close. We did leave about 10 minutes before close. Ive worked in the food industry and get it but w
It's not like we came in 5 minutes...
August 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Papa Murphy's | Take 'N' Bake Pizza - 851 N Casaloma Dr
Pizza
Carmella's an Italian Bistro - 716 N Casaloma Dr
Italian, Vegetarian
SAP - 708 N Casaloma Dr
American, Bakery, Gluten-Free, Vegan, Vegetarian

Schlotzsky's

881 N Casaloma Dr, Appleton, WI 54913
(920) 731-7272