Mario's Italian Restaurant
TEMPORARILY CLOSED$ •
About Mario's Italian Restaurant
Mario's Italian Restaurant Reviews
120 ratings
Wow — just wow! Mario’s totally blew me away. When I don’t feel like cooking, this is officially my new take-home spot. The crew was super friendly, the environment was great, and the food… unreal! Big portions, amazing flavor, and that “just one more bite” kind of good. Love what the new owners are doing in Edgerton — see you again soon, Mario’s!
I had the three-piece cod dinner tonight, with a loaded baked potato and the house-made tartar sauce; the food and service were both absolutely amazing. It's so nice to have a place in town that has a great fish fry and offers delivery. Thank you, Mario's team.
We ordered the Super Mario pizza tonight and it was FANTASTIC!! Hot upon delivery too!! Thank you!!!! Delivered by a super friendly guy. Very happy with our order!!
Mario's Italian Restaurant offers excellent food, including well-made pizzas, breadsticks, and spaghetti, as well as delicious Italian subs and Italian beef. The portions are generous, and the prices are reasonable. While some customers have experienced slow service, others have reported friendly and efficient delivery. However, there have been some issues with orders being prepared incorrectly, so it's essential to double-check orders before consuming. Overall, Mario's provides a pleasant dining experience, but attention to detail is necessary.