Off the Rail
44 Gottfried St, Elkhart Lake
(920) 876-4194
Customers' Favorites
Egg Puffs with Bacon Cheddar and Green Onion
The Commuter Breakfast Sandwich
Trolley with Everything Bagel
Trolley Breakfast Sandwich
Locomotive Sandwich
Underground Sandwich
First Refill Is Free
Eurorail Sandwich
Blueberry Muffin
Seasoned Chips
Menu
Photos
+51 photos
+50 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
This place was the BEST recommendation I got all year! The weekend “organized chaos” was fun and a great way to chat with strangers in line! The service was amazing and the and the sandwiches were FABulous! We’ll be back
Breakfast sandwiches and bagel sandwiches were huge and tasty. The ingredients are fresh, and you can taste that these aren't pre-made or previously frozen. Our wait on a busy Sunday morning for 5 sandwiches and a blueberry muffin was only about 15 minutes, which was worth it for the quality of the food and coffee. The staff were friendly and managed the busy crowd well. Another great place to visit on our next trip to Elkhart Lake.
You May Also Like
Lake Street Cafe Inc - 21 S Lake St
![]()
American, Wine Bar, Pizza, Vegetarian
Paddock Club - 61 S Lake St
![]()
American, Wine Bar, New American, Vegan
Harry's Pizza e Vino - 111 E Rhine St
![]()
Pizza, Beer Bar, Cocktail Bar
The coffee was excellent. The atmosphere was very nice. The building seems to be an old mill which has a nice touch to the feel.
The muffins are exceptional: baked fresh daily - a must.
Expect a long lineup during peak hours. Well worth the wait.