Not Licked Yet Frozen Custard
4054 Main St, Fish Creek
(920) 868-2617
Customers' Favorites
Chunky Monkey Sundae
Door County Sundae
Frozen Custard
Banana Split
Turtle Sundae
Hot Fudge
Burger
Pie
Menu
Photos
+46 photos
+45 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
I liked the custard, chocolate was great. What I didn’t like: their sign. It felt like I was walking into a cursed German fairy tale. However they had plenty of seating and parking.
One of the best cherry pies I've ever had and the homemade whipped cream was AMAZING!! Very generous pieces. Frozen custard was also amazing. The day was a bit overcast and spotty rain when we got there but the outdoor heaters gave us comfort. Very polite staff.
Got there at just the right time, so there wasn't a line or a crowd of people. The custard was creamy and we ate it by the water watching some ducks and one lost seagull. (There is no indoor eating area.) There was a small playground area for the littles.
You May Also Like
Wild Tomato Wood-Fired Pizza & Grille Fish Creek - 4023 WI-42
![]()
Pizza, Salad, Mediterranean, Pet Friendly, Gluten-Free
Blue Horse Beach Cafe - 4113 Main St
![]()
Sandwich Shop, Coffee & Tea, Pet Friendly, Vegan
Kettle Black Fish Boil - 4158 Main St
![]()
Cajun/Creole, Chicken Shop, Hot Dogs, Seafood