Eaton's Fresh Pizza - Hickory Street

$ • Pizza

Menu Order Online

About Eaton's Fresh Pizza - Hickory Street

Eaton's Fresh Pizza on Hickory Street is a long-time family favorite for custom subs and pizzas. The staff is always helpful and friendly, and the quality and consistency of the food are top-notch. They are happy to squeeze you in and make a fantastic sub sandwich or a custom pizza for you to take and bake at home. Pricing is perfect, with a 12” sub and a drink for a great price. The storefront is clean and well-stocked with a variety of drinks, snacks, and even non-food items. Vegetarian options are fully customizable and abundant, and they offer a cauliflower pizza crust for gluten-free diets. Kids love picking up a pizza to cook at home, and the workers are warm and kind to them. Eaton's has been a beloved spot since the early '90s.

Customers' Favorites

Gluten Free

Pizza

Photos

Add a Photo

View All Photos

Recent Reviews

4.4

157 ratings

81%

Food

Atmosphere

Service

Share your opinion about Eaton's Fresh Pizza - Hickory Street

Write a review

I picked up a cauliflower crust take and bake yesterday. The online ordering process was a breeze! I fired up my grill and baked it on a kamado style grill at 500 degrees, and I can tell you this was by far the best take and bake pizza I have had to date! I would recommend it to anyone!

The staff at this location are exceptional. They are consistently friendly, welcoming, and make every customer feel like family.

The food is equally impressive, with a wide selection of delicious, homemade favorites. From freshly made pizzas and sub sandwiches to breadsticks and other classic comfort foods, there is something for everyone to enjoy.

If you’re looking for an authentic local restaurant with a classic Wisconsin “Mom-and-Pop” atmosphere,...read full review

Eaton's Pizza always has the best food! And the service from the employees is the best!

Read All Reviews(157)