New American Restaurants near Fort Atkinson, WI

“The biggest part of their business is carry out and delivery but they also have tables inside to eat there if you like. We choose to eat on site.It was clean, neat and casual.The menu was excellent. Lots of choices and priced reasonable for todays standards. I had a delicious in house roasted prime rib sandwich with good fries.My friend had one of the best mac and cheese dishes shes eaten out. It was very creamy with lots of cheese flavor.My sister had the 1/2 # burger of day which was also well prepared and delicous. We will for sure come back and try some other dishes on their large and varied menu. The hot coffee was good as it was cold outside.“

“I enjoyed White Christmas great and yummy food loved the Winter wonderland drink loved the actors and actresses spectacular wonderful waitress Callie I love the Fireside Happy Holdays to the staff and the Klopcic family, may God bless you all!“

“This was one of my go-to places to eat for a while, as it was quick, easy, and the food was always good. They also have a selection of different soups per day which I really enjoy, and the cookies are my favorite. However my last couple experiences were not so great. I’ve been met with cold food the past couple orders, (I always pickup at schedule pickup or I even come a few minutes earlier.) Tonight my order tasted like it sat out for an hour, and on a few other occasions my food has just been room temp upon pickup. I’ve never had a bad experience dining in, but for the nights I want to stay home, please do better!“

“Excellent in every way. Service is top notch, great food and drink options, we were a group of 8 that became 9; they didn't miss a beat. We had a lot of fun and will definitely be back whenever we are in the Whitewater area. It is a gem that should be enjoyed by all.“

“Quintessential Wisconsin supper club! Cool location right near the local airport makes for a fun fly in destination. Food and service was excellent! Highly recommend the fish of the day special as well as the spinach salad. The lobster mashed potatoes were good but I don’t think it was worth the up charge. The creme brûlée was fantastic as well. Definitely worth a visit!“

“A heartfelt thank you to Jefferson Cafe for graciously hosting our board members and community partners for brunch this morning. It was a productive gathering where we shared updates about our nonprofits, discussed future plans, and explored potential partnerships. The customer service was exceptional, the food was served promptly and was delicious, and the pricing was competitive. We had a wonderful time and eagerly anticipate returning next quarter!“

“Absolutely loved this place! Not only was there excellent craft beer (had the loveliest flight of them), excellent food, and excellent service, the art featuring pieces of Wisconsin and Whitewater legends and lore makes for a singular experience. Highly recommend the Blood Moon beer!“

“Swung in for a quick beer and bite to eat after hiking in Kettle Moraine. Everything was great!“