Joey Gerard's - A Bartolotta Supper Club
5601 Broad St, Greendale
(414) 858-1900
Customers' Favorites
Joey's Ice Cream Sundae for Two
Twin Veal Tenderloin Medallions
Classic Bartolotta Caesar Salad
South African Lobster Tails
Prime Rib and Lobster Tail
Joey's Classic Relish Tray
Strawberry Schaum Torte
Classic Shrimp Cocktail
Crackers and Cheese
Lobster Tail Add On
Menu
Photos
+85 photos
+84 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Great place with terrific staff We were a group of 5 and, unfortunately, 2 of the 5 steaks we ordered were cooked wrong One was was too rare and the other WAY overcooked They did their best to correct the underdone steak but not much to address the overcooked steak All the sides were really good so it wasn't a total loss We would go back but be really careful what we ordered
Excellent from drinks, to appetizers, main dishes, desserts and coffee. We went to celebrate a birthday and an anniversary. Very attentive waiter. This is our go to place for celebrations with the family.
We have eaten here many times in the past and miss some of their old entrees like Chicken Marsala and Trout Almondine. The relish tray, which is very good, used to come with the meal as well which added to the value, although you can buy it for ~$15. The chicken piccata I had in the past was bland, and their seafood tray Friday special was terrible when we tried it in the past - mainly breading. The coleslaw was not good on our last visit as well, and it had an off taste - made...
You May Also Like
Ricardo's Pizza - 5627 Broad St
![]()
Pizza, Vegetarian
Broad Street Coffee Co - 5635 Broad St
![]()
Coffee Shops, Coffee & Tea, Coffee
National Bakery & Deli | South – Greendale - 5637 Broad St
![]()
Bakery, Gluten-Free