“One word? Phenomenal. Within minutes, the cook introduced himself and asked us what our names were. Within 15 minutes, we knew the staff and the surrounding customers by name. Our burgers were amazing. We came for the food and root beer and stayed for the atmosphere. On the way home, we talked about how different and nice the experience was. We will definitely be back here again! I wish it was closer to home!“
“First time visit on Valentine's Day and it was great. French onion soup, ribeye, sea bass and mashed potatoes were all fantastic. Just wish everything wasn't a la carte as that drives up the price, but we'll be back for other special occasions. Our server was pleasant.“
“I think The Black Otter is a solid 4… the food was pretty good, salad bar was good, drinks were good… didn’t blow my socks off but it was good… we were here on a Friday night and it was crazy packed… met the owner Bob and he is an incredibly nice guy and all the workers in the restaurant were super nice. The decor was more modern shabby chic and I was hoping for the old school Wisconsin Supper Club look but overall it’s worth going to for the experience and the food!Kid-friendliness: Very family friendly“