11 Best Pizza Restaurants near Lake Mills

“Delicious food, great service & great entertainment! I love Pyramid!“

“the Chinese food was excellent and would get the tacos again“

“Pizza is always undercooked even when you specifically ask for it to be crispy and crunchy! I don't want chewy bread with cheese and sauce on it. I also ordered thin crust, and it was pretty thick. :-( Never ordering again, the last time I am cooking delivery pizza for an additional 15 minutes. Looks like it was cooked for maybe 10 minutes. The crust wasn't even browned, and then they put my cold cucumber sauce in with the pizza, so now it is soup, and went into the garbage.“

“Cute place. Food was delicious, workers are young so the service isn't great. Order was a bit wrong but its easy to take tomatoes off as long as it isn't an allergy issue. It Did take a long time for 2 subs. Then she presented me with 2 baskets, not wrapped to go. I was alone and stood at the register the entire time, , I wrongly assumed she would understand they were to go. Then another several minutes to wrap them. Again, good food, very nice girls but slow.“

“We stumbled upon this resturant while at 2025 Goat Fest. What a find! Great food, cozy atmosphere, wonderful staff. We will make the hour drive to come again. It was literally that good.“

“Gordy’s has the best pizza and italian food in the area! They run fantastic specials almost every day and offer many unique items. Their staff go above and beyond in friendliness and accomodation. They also are very supportive of the community. Give them a try if you are not already in love, you won’t be disappointed. 👍🏻😘😊“

“Been ordering from 'Papa Murph's' for over 5 years. My wife is addicted to the sauce-we try other locals but we have yet to find anyone that offers the balance of taste, convenience, and value we have found at Papas! And now, as much as I share my wife's joy in the pizza, I am hooked on the Calzones.

Vegetarian options: Veggie pizza avl on 'build your own' option

Parking: Public parking avl to all businesses in the strip mall.“

“Very casual setting.. greeted upon arrival, order came to total of $55. There seemed to be a little miscommunication between the order. But a quick phone call to address the so-called problem, was quickly addressed and corrected. Very happy with the service with only three people working, with the amount of service they had at time. Again thank you for your time and hospitality as the order is prepared.. very well done for the only three people on staff.. I highly recommend this establishment.“

“Better than pretty much any big chain pizza you're going to get and they're not riding the inflation dragon. They understand times are tough and have kept their delicious product at a reasonable price.“

“The pizza and breadsticks were amazing! They were SO busy and a little behind but Rob kept the communication open and the mood light. We'll definitely be ordering again.“

“Hot, Fresh, Fast, and Yummy..“