50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Mcfarland

“Amazing staff,food & drinks! Always delicious a prices are reasonable 🍕❣️“

“I came with 5 other people and we ordered 4 appetizers, 9 entrees + a pizza to share amongst us and their was not a complaint about any of your dishes. We love your food, the atmosphere is wonderful, so I have nothing to say about improving your business, it’s perfect!! Well done!!“

“Exceptional Service & Incredible Turnaround!

I cannot say enough great things about the team at the McFarland Pizza Hut, especially Brooke! Recently, our workplace had planned a pizza party for 60 people, only to realize—just two hours before the event—that no one had actually placed the order. With no pizza places opening until 10:30 AM and our event starting at noon, we were in a serious bind.

I called the McFarland Pizza Hut as soon as they opened, explained the situation, and without hesitation, Brooke assured me they could handle it. In under an hour, they prepared 20 pizzas, double orders of all breadsticks (with plenty of sauce), and had everything ready to go. Their efficiency, professionalism, and commitment to customer service were truly outstanding.

Thanks to Brooke and her team, our pizza party was saved, and everyone was able to enjoy a hot, delicious meal on time. If you're looking for a place that goes above and beyond, this is it. Highly recommend!“

“Great pizza and nice ambiance as usual. What made our evening even better were the warm smile and friendly personality of our waitress Mel! She nicely engaged in joking conversation, went above and beyond to accommodate our special request, and frequently checked in to make sure we had everything we needed. Outstanding food and service — we’ll definitely be coming back!“

“always solid pizza, great crust!“

“One of my favorite pizza restaurants around. Try the Macho Nacho!“

“The pizza is amazing! The staff if super friendly and the atmosphere is cozy but hip!!“

“Good stuff. Worth stopping in for sure!“

“The pizza is amazing. Staff are great! I love the atmosphere!“

“Wow! This is the east coast food I grew up eating! Delicious #nailedit“

“The absolute best pizza in the area. Won't go anywhere else for pizzas and meatball subs!“

“Great pizza. Perfectly charred underneath. Some of The most flavorful pizza sauce I’ve had in Madison. All around delicious“

“We had a really enjoyable experience as a party of three. We lucked out with timing and were seated after about a 20-minute wait; shortly after, the walk-in wait jumped to over an hour, which says a lot about how popular this place is.

The atmosphere was fun, with 80s and 90s music playing in the background, and the service was excellent. We ordered a make-your-own pizza with olives and mushrooms, which was fantastic—flavorful with a noticeable kick from black pepper, so something to keep in mind if you’re spice-sensitive. We also tried the vegetarian Brussels sprout pizza; it was good overall, though not quite as rich or bold in flavor. The beet salad was outstanding.

All in all, an unexpectedly great dining experience outside of Chicago.“

“Had our first Bucks pizza tonight. It was amazing! Can’t wait to enjoy again soon.“

“The food and environment is fantastic!“

“Rock solid pizza joint. Great pizza. Expensive...but if you want a quality pizza every so often, it's worth it.

Spinach delight, belly buster and hot honey heater are among the best.

Love that they also serve ice cream, and the kids that work here are always friendly.

See you again soon!“

“For a loyal customer patronizing Glass Nickel for decades, I shouldn't be in a position to need to write this. With all the problems, - and it seems that nearly each order has come with one or more - I still came back for the great taste of Glass Nickel pizza. However, the most recent issue made me finally decide to take my business elsewhere. My pizza had (over three inches) of no toppings toward the edge. Unacceptable. It appears that the mushrooms are not chopped into bits anymore like in past orders, and that I appreciate, but it looks like the big barren spaces, sans toppings, made up for that. I asked for a refund, but was given a half credit. In addition, I had to dish out more for the tip and delivery charge. I'm finally done with them.“

“The restaurant was extremely busy on Valentine’s Day but our order was ready on time. The food as always was delicious and service was still great despite being so busy.“

“Always amazing here. Food , atmosphere, staff, and great cocktails to boot.“

“Hanging out with friends. We shared many things on the menu. Loved all of it!“

“Great pizza, breadsticks, and dessert pizza!!! Amazing service!! Highly recommend! Also appreciate the veteran’s discount! Thanks Spinners for a great dinner while passing through with our family!“

“One of my favorite pizza restaurants around. Try the Macho Nacho!“

“My wife and I have ordered from this Papa Murphy's many times over the years, and have always been pleased with the service, amount and consistency of toppings, and of course, the delicious pizza. In my opinion, the experience here surpasses other Papa Murphy's locations I have patronized over the years.“

“Greatest Pizza in the world.“

“We had Ian's Pizza Cater our wedding. This is the location we got to have one of our favorite planning memories. Food Tasting, what really made it an incredible experience is Staci, the Account Manager, who took the time to get to know us, explain all the different recipes, how they work with allergies, and even took notes on everything we were saying during the tasting. She stayed flexible and understanding while working with us to have our favorite food on our big day! The Garver Feed Mill is also a beautiful building that helps any visit there feel special.“

“Met my friend there for lunch got sausage and mushroom regular slice a one trip salad bar and a drink. It was absolutely the best and I can’t say enough about how wonderful the salad bar was. The potato salad, cottage cheese, lettuce, cucumbers everything was so fresh. This will be our new spot to meet up. I recommend you stopping in.“

“Great service, great food!“

“If you’re in the Monona area or nearby cities and craving pizza, Rocky Rococo absolutely delivers 🔥🍕
From the moment you walk in, the vibe is welcoming and friendly, and the staff go out of their way to make you feel taken care of. The pizza? Next level. Perfectly thick, buttery crust with just the right amount of crisp, loaded with fresh toppings and rich, flavorful sauce. Every bite tastes like it was made with care.
The slices are huge, the ingredients taste fresh, and everything comes out hot and fast—exactly what you want when you’re hungry. Whether you’re grabbing a quick lunch or feeding a group, this place hits every time.
Honestly one of the best spots in the area for comfort food done right. Highly recommend if you want consistently great pizza and friendly service. I’ll definitely be coming back!“

“I was having problems with my online order and when i called Thomas answered the phone and was so helpful! Some of the best customer service i’ve had in a very long time! He even called me back after we were disconnected! went above and beyond to help! Give Thomas a raise!! lol“

“By far the best pizza in town! Low in calories, thin new york style crust and very yummy. The staff is amazing- they are all related - its a family owned business and they are extremely friendly! I highly recommend the place- its for sure a must try!“

“This pizza was fantastic! We had stopped buying Pizza Hut pizzas years ago because the taste went down-hill and cost went up. We only went to Pizza Hut this time because everyone else was closed on Easter, and we're glad we did! Now the pizza tastes GREAT, and the price was surprisingly low!“

“They donated pizzas to a Make-a-Wish party, and I can't thank them enough!!“

“we came in on a Thursday afternoon at 4:00 so it wasn't busy. The service was good. We liked our drinks, a raspberry martini and an old fashioned. The bruschetta was some of the best we ever had, and we enjoyed the linguine and lasagna.“

“First time me and the lady have ever had deep dish. Both of us have been wanting to try it for a long time. Placed order over the phone. They were pretty busy when I arrived. Minimal staff pumping out orders. Staff was super kind. They were apologetic for the wait but it was really no problem with how busy they were. 11/10 the pizza was absolutely phenomenal. Some of the best we’ve had. Would recommend to everyone. Will be ordering again soon.“

“Food is always good, fast service, friendly staff“

“Very friendly and cooperative staff. I asked him for tax exemption for Oregon Community Pool, he asked the tax exemption number which I don’t have.
Then I request him for a discount and he added 15% on the bill and never asked for tip.
Such a gentle person, I recommended the staff for their welcoming attitude and response.
Excellent services……….“

“Place was spotless but the floor still looks dirty only because it is very, very old and the grout looks dark. Also several of the lights were burned out which does not look good. The place needs a refresh of the appearance. Even though it looks dirty, it was spotlessly clean - a good job by the staff.“

“When we got there, one family was having their pizza made. We placed our order, a family sized Pappa's All Meat. The one employee was very efficient and had our pizza ready quickly. I appreciated the generous quantity of meat on the pizza. It could have used more cheese, though. Prices are reasonable.“

“Large menu, awesome pizza, pretty good wings, and usually pretty quick at delivery.“

“This is by far my favorite pizza! It’s a must have for me weekly. Luca’s is a treasure in our town and definitely worth a trip if you’re in a neighboring town and want to come pick one up you won’t be disappointed.“

“I have been too many, many different restaurants trying different things and this restaurant is like a One-Stop shop for everything you would want. It doesn't matter what type that you're looking for. These guys have it and they're very good. They're very respectful. They're enjoyable to be around. They're very, very affordable and I would recommend this 100% of the time every time. You don't need to go anywhere else. They have pretty much anything you would want. I would recommend them every time“

“The gluten free crust was delicious and I watched the folks working change their gloves when they were handling my pizza to prevent cross contamination. It’s a bit of an awkward wait (longer than you’d expect), and I wouldn’t recommend eating at the tables inside unless the weather is poor. Go outside and enjoy the view!

Dietary restrictions: Gluten free crust is available.“

“Zero late night fights …at times that skunky smell can b a good thing…“

“The best in town. Would recommend“

“Love the birthday gift certificate program. It gave me the opportunity to try a new pizza, the BBQ pizza is wonderful, and also a new store. The online order was correctly done and ready to be picked up at the time I requested. I will definitely be ordering online again!“

“The pinnacle of Sourdough baking that I have found in the Midwest. Amazing! Great Job!“

“Always so fast, yummy pizzas and lots of options“

“We were given a five star experience. The food was impeccable perfectly presented and seriously good. We were well attended by a professional waitstaff. The hotel is in the middle of a remodel but once inside the restaurant we thoroughly enjoyed ourselves.“

“🔥 What We Ate & Loved Smoked Wings – Smoked, then deep-fried to perfection. Flavorful, tender, and done right. Truffle Fries – House-made fries tossed with white truffle oil, Parmesan, and herbs. Absolutely amazing and well balanced — you can tell these are quality ingredients, not shortcuts. Pesto Pasta – Mushrooms, tomatoes, caramelized onions, and house pesto with cavatappi pasta, finished with white wine and cream. Freshly cooked al dente. Everything about this dish was pure perfection. Deviled Eggs – Four deviled eggs topped with smoked paprika, chives, and crispy shallots. Simple, elevated, and flat-out delicious. Crème Brûlée – Amazing. Smooth, rich, and executed exactly how it should be. Salted Caramel Blondie – Different than what I was expecting, but in a good way — unique and worth trying. 🍽️ Overall Verdict 9.3 out of 10 Ollie’s delivers top-tier food, consistency, and flavor across the board. This is the kind of place where you don’t rush — you sit down, enjoy the meal, and appreciate the craftsmanship. I’ll definitely be back to eat in the restaurant again.👍“

“Relaxing meal with fabulous food! Can't wait to go back.“