49 Best Pizza Restaurants near Windsor

“Absolutely wonderful pizza! Highly recommend the Barbie! Now my Friday night go to. No cooking at my home on Fridays 😊“

“Excellent pizza, we’ve never had a bad experience (ordering more than just pizza), and we’ve been 10+ times!“

“Me and my family stopped by a day ago. The customer service was amazing. If I remember correctly, our server’s name was Trinity. He was very kind to my grandma . Also, the food was delicious, our server recommended I try the strawberry burrata which was amazing. I would stop by again. Five stars.“

“We love bringing out of town friends to Sal's. We had the Valentine's menu and it was the best food we've had in years! Tameka was amazing and the food came out so quick. Clean plates all day!“

“The pizza is amazing! The staff if super friendly and the atmosphere is cozy but hip!!“

“Always amazing here. Food , atmosphere, staff, and great cocktails to boot.“

“Great pizza. Perfectly charred underneath. Some of The most flavorful pizza sauce I’ve had in Madison. All around delicious“

“BEST PIZZA I have ever had! They have great burgers soup, salads, appetizers and pastas too. Definitely coming back.“

“the chicken dinners in the tiramisu“

“One of my favorite pizza restaurants around. Try the Macho Nacho!“

“I recommend Anna Pizza if your in the area. I myself have problems with my stomach and have to be on a KETO DIET and I order a very thin crust. I may not eat the crust but there topping and cheese are so delicious and good and they don't bother my tummy either. I think it's because they must use real or high quality products. I love there Pizza. I myself give them 5 stars.“

“The restaurant was extremely busy on Valentine’s Day but our order was ready on time. The food as always was delicious and service was still great despite being so busy.“

“Rock solid pizza joint. Great pizza. Expensive...but if you want a quality pizza every so often, it's worth it.

Spinach delight, belly buster and hot honey heater are among the best.

Love that they also serve ice cream, and the kids that work here are always friendly.

See you again soon!“

“For a loyal customer patronizing Glass Nickel for decades, I shouldn't be in a position to need to write this. With all the problems, - and it seems that nearly each order has come with one or more - I still came back for the great taste of Glass Nickel pizza. However, the most recent issue made me finally decide to take my business elsewhere. My pizza had (over three inches) of no toppings toward the edge. Unacceptable. It appears that the mushrooms are not chopped into bits anymore like in past orders, and that I appreciate, but it looks like the big barren spaces, sans toppings, made up for that. I asked for a refund, but was given a half credit. In addition, I had to dish out more for the tip and delivery charge. I'm finally done with them.“

“The food and environment is fantastic!“

“Hanging out with friends. We shared many things on the menu. Loved all of it!“

“I first stopped into Grampa's a couple of years ago while my partner and I were visiting Madison from Champaign, Illinois. We loved both the food and the atmosphere so much that when we found ourselves back in Madison over Memorial Day weekend, we knew we had to visit Grampa's again—and we weren't disappointed.
The food was just as outstanding as we remembered, and the staff was incredibly welcoming. The service was attentive and friendly, which made the experience even better. It certainly doesn't hurt that you can grab a cocktail next door while you wait for a table, either. Grampa's remains one of our favorite spots in Madison, and we'll definitely be back the next time we're in town.“

“Had our first Bucks pizza tonight. It was amazing! Can’t wait to enjoy again soon.“

“This is one of my favorite pizza places in Madison! The location is fantastic, as it’s inside Garver Feed Mill, with plenty of indoor seating and outdoor seating available when the weather is nice.

Parking can be a little crowded, especially during peak hours, but we’ve been able to find a spot during each of our visits so far.

We have a toddler, so we’re always looking for places where we can grab a meal, eat comfortably, and leave whenever we need to. This place is perfect for that.

The Smokey the Bandit is my favorite pizza, but other options, including the Mac & Cheese and Buffalo Chicken pizzas, are also delicious. When you place your order at the counter, they send you a text message when your food is ready, so you can find a seat and relax while you wait.

Individual slices are usually available right away, while a whole pizza takes a little longer to prepare, but the wait is generally very reasonable.

I highly recommend this place for families with toddlers. There’s plenty of space to move around with a stroller, and the overall atmosphere is welcoming, relaxed, and family-friendly.“

“I’m so thankful I discovered Zoe’s! It’s like having Ian’s pizza but with way better crust. 🤣❤️ I get my nails done in Waunakee and my nail girl told me about this place. Bet I come here every time I get my nails done! Today I had their special - chorizo - and when I say it was BOMB I mean it!!! This pizza is so dang good, and every flavor I try has been consistently delicious. 🍕 😍 lunch prices are amazing too! I highly recommend giving this place a try even just for a slice.“

“Very good pizza and chicken. The ladies in there are always so nice too !“

“I Normally grab a slice or salad for lunch but won a free large pizza on the rewards app, so ordered dinner for carry out. Called to order and staff was very helpful and friendly. Order was ready promptly, and when I went in to pick up, I noticed the clean restaurant with cute decor and even an ice cream station. Pizza was hot & fresh and crust was pleasantly crisp compared to the boxed slices I usually get. We all loved the sauce and toppings, and my 94 year old father in law declared it “the best pizza I’ve had in a very long time”. Will definitely be back!“

“What a great little hidden gem! Great drinks, gourmet food, amazing staff and we even got to meet the owner, Steve! Very friendly atmosphere. We will definitely be back!!“

“You all need to start filling the tator tots full the last couple of orders have been 3/4 th full mot acceptable. Did you all change the bread or something and stop cutting the meatballs in half for the bomber subs“

“★☆☆☆☆ – Consistently Disappointing Experience Disappointment every single time — whether dining in or ordering delivery. The food quality is consistently poor, and any time you try to offer constructive feedback, the owner, Adam, becomes defensive and dismissive. Instead of addressing concerns, he’ll tell you that you “don’t know what you’re talking about” and promise to refund your order — a promise he never follows through on. This is by far the worst Glass Nickel Pizza location I’ve experienced. With so many better pizza options in Sun Prairie, I regret giving them multiple chances. Do yourself a favor: reheat a frozen pizza. It’ll taste better, and you won’t have to deal with Adam’s attitude.“

“Be it food or service both are top notch.“

“Large menu, awesome pizza, pretty good wings, and usually pretty quick at delivery.“

“By far the best pizza in town! Low in calories, thin new york style crust and very yummy. The staff is amazing- they are all related - its a family owned business and they are extremely friendly! I highly recommend the place- its for sure a must try!“

“Joe at Pizza Hut did not serve me pizza. Joe served me a moment.

The second he walked out of that kitchen, I swear the restaurant lighting got better. The confidence? Radiant. The energy? Sparkling. The customer service? Absolutely giving.

When he handed me my pizza, it wasn’t a transaction—it was a performance. A masterclass. A cultural reset. The cheese was cheesing, the crust was crusting, and Joe was absolutely thriving.

I’ve seen celebrities with less presence. I’ve attended events with less production value. Meanwhile Joe was out here making sure every customer felt seen, appreciated, and emotionally nourished.

By the end of my visit, I wasn’t asking for extra parmesan. I was asking myself if I had witnessed greatness.

Pizza Hut needs to protect Joe at all costs. Put him in the company museum. Put him on a billboard. Put him in charge of world peace.

Five stars. No notes. Slay.“

“The pinnacle of Sourdough baking that I have found in the Midwest. Amazing! Great Job!“

“For what it is, MOD works. It will never be five star dining. Pizza quality varies depending on who is making it. It is usually pretty fast, and tastes all right. There is better pizza in town, if you want great pizza. If you just want a decent lunch, this is where you go.“

“I want to recognize the outstanding service of Chrisi! Second day at her work and she has given us the best service ever from all the time we've been here to eat! Her attitude was amazing, always smiling, recommending deserts despite being busy! Food was delicious but BRAVO for her!!!!!!!!!!!!!! La Brioche is lucky to have her as part of the staff!!!!! Thank you again for making our brunch so bright!!“

“They donated pizzas to a Make-a-Wish party, and I can't thank them enough!!“

“Zero late night fights …at times that skunky smell can b a good thing…“

“Always loved Papa Murphy's Take and bake! They get my order right every time, and our prompt for my pickup time. My favorite is the hawaiian, plus mushrooms.... YUM!
I can get two 16-in pizzas for about $30, that's a deal!“

“Gas station with plenty of pumps and parking. With 3 restaurants inside. Rocky Rocco, Cousins Subs, and A & W Rootbeer. Pretty quick no matter which counter of food you want. Plenty of restaurant seating. Gas station has everything you need for snacks and drinks. Right off the interstate.“

“When we got there, one family was having their pizza made. We placed our order, a family sized Pappa's All Meat. The one employee was very efficient and had our pizza ready quickly. I appreciated the generous quantity of meat on the pizza. It could have used more cheese, though. Prices are reasonable.“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“the online ordering was a breeze and pick up was ready exactly when they said it would be. the za itself is fantastic, we ordered one thin crust and one hand tossed and they were both wonderful. we will definitely be back!“

“The gluten free crust was delicious and I watched the folks working change their gloves when they were handling my pizza to prevent cross contamination. It’s a bit of an awkward wait (longer than you’d expect), and I wouldn’t recommend eating at the tables inside unless the weather is poor. Go outside and enjoy the view!

Dietary restrictions: Gluten free crust is available.“

“Went in tonight at a little after 5pm to a completely packed store. Must have been 10-15 in line ahead of me. Two workers. Sounds like a complete disaster, right?Nope. These two were on top if it. They kept everything moving, and after a little while the manager showed up and hopped right in to help out.It took about 20 minutes to get my pizzas, but I have no complaints. I was very impressed with how well the manager handled everything, and the three of them cranked through the pile of orders while still remaining friendly, courteous, and professional.We don't eat here super often, just because there are plenty of other pizza places that do the cooking for you, and when I'm hungry, I don't want extra steps. But I've never been so impressed with a crew before, and we are definitely going to make this a frequent stop.Keep up the excellent work!“

“I have been too many, many different restaurants trying different things and this restaurant is like a One-Stop shop for everything you would want. It doesn't matter what type that you're looking for. These guys have it and they're very good. They're very respectful. They're enjoyable to be around. They're very, very affordable and I would recommend this 100% of the time every time. You don't need to go anywhere else. They have pretty much anything you would want. I would recommend them every time“

“The chicken and potatoes were delicious! The salad bar is amazing! Pizza is awesome and dessert cookie pizza is delicious!! Pizza ranch certainly is “all that” and then some“

“Pizza is good as all food goes, and the service is really good. I ordered a pizza and it showed up in around 15 minutes. Always a great option for a party. The desserts are to die for, and they always are concistant with their orders bringing the food in good shape. The staff is kind, and they apologize if they run late. I usually pick this option for convenience and comfort. Nobody outpizzas the hut, and they are true.“

“Hey hi ooo uh hi r go ouo I vhi hi Gus“

“05AUG2025.

Not sure why this place received such poor reviews but I have to disagree. I am a huge pizza lover and this hit the spot!

Customer service was great and with a smile.

Picked up a duo pepperoni slice around noon. The slice was soft, cheese was plenty,sauce had the right level of seasoning, and the dough was airy and light.

Perhaps it tasted so good because of the time of day. The lady behind the counter did inform me that all the slices were fresh.

I'd urge you to pick up a slice around noon and see for yourself.“

“The chicken and potatoes were delicious! The salad bar is amazing! Pizza is awesome and dessert cookie pizza is delicious!! Pizza ranch certainly is “all that” and then some“

“OMG we had a rip snorting time at the ski hill and were starving. My daughter came up the the wonderful idea of grabbing some pizza and having a milkshake. So we stopped at this location and did exactly that. Lisa knocked it out of the park with great service asking how we were feeling today. Then she made one of the best milkshakes ever!!! Yummy! I highly recommend this spot for a nice and convenient stop for some great tasting food!!!“

“Have not been there in a long time, decided to stop in and we’re glad we did. The restaurant was super clean, and the staff was friendly! While we waited the owner came out and introduced himself. It was such a nice gesture to see how proud he was of his store and the recent improvements. He stated he recently took ownership of this restaurant. He talked highly of his staff and you could see the respect was truly given! We were impressed by the food and by the character of the owner and the employees. While this may have been just grabbing a quick pizza it was definitely a business model others should take note of. Way to go East Side Madison Toppers!“