Gotham Bagels
112 E Mifflin St, Madison
(608) 467-7642
Customers' Favorites
The Original V the One the Only the Greatest Vegan Sandwich in Madison
The Peruvian Chimichurri Chicken Salad Greens Avocado Onion
Everything Bagel with Vegetable Cream Cheese
Super Egg Bagel with Scallion Cream Cheese
Bagel with Cream Cheese
Super Everything Bagel
NY Delicatessen Salads
Cream Cheese Flavors
Bagel & Cream Cheese
The Brighton Beach
Menu
Photos
+55 photos
+54 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
The food is delicious and I’ve never had a bad service experience. The only thing that has had me hesitant to comeback is the wait time. Last time we waited an hour for our bagels and once we finally got them they all had the wrong type of bagel. We understood they were busy so they might have not had the specific bagel we wanted but it would have been nice if they communicated that. The bagels were still good though and the pickle they add on the side is my favorite.
They have the best bagel in Madison, hands down.
However, it does take a long time to get a single bagel with cream cheese. I really like the product, but I don't go very often because of how long it usually takes to prepare orders.
However, it does take a long time to get a single bagel with cream cheese. I really like the product, but I don't go very often because of how long it usually takes to prepare orders.
This is a 12.67/10 swimming past any other bagel shop near lake Mendota.Gotham bagels is very deceiving name I was expecting emo bagels that had piercings . Such an electric atmosphere filled with the sweet smell of fall and salamander. I like the fact that I wasn’t looked at weird for wearing no shoes I have an amputation on my right big toe so I was a little nervous, but the place felt like home. I got the number 12 with only the bagel part. It was so good I highly recommend...
You May Also Like
Sol's on the Square - 117 E Mifflin St
![]()
Korean, Vegan, Vegetarian
Heritage Tavern - 131 E Mifflin St
![]()
New American, American, Gastropubs, Vegan, Vegetarian
Draper Brothers Chophouse - 101 N Hamilton St
![]()
Fine Dining, Italian, Seafood